Why Not? Tudor Black Bay 58 PuristSPro Edition

Mar 23, 2018,17:49 PM

Two little tweaks made to the new Black Bay 58 and it becomes a perfect Tudor heritage diving watch.  I mean it's a damn nice original to start with as Nico said in his thread (39mm x 11.9mm case, beveled lugs, gilt writing everywhere).  The addition of the Tudor rose and the red writing complementing the red triangle just makes it spectacular, don't you think?

Who's with me on this besides Nicolas and Echi?  I have to think there's at minimum 50 of us who would buy this concept version.

And now, who has a contact at Rolex/Tudor to help sponsor the watch?

Original pic from Tudor website and then tweaked for rose logo and red writing

More posts: Black BayGiltTudorTudor Heritage

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread


Always a good advice Nico👌 [nt]

 By: Gelato Monster : March 23rd, 2018-18:22
No message body
login to reply

Too kind. [nt]

 By: amanico : March 23rd, 2018-18:27
login to reply


 By: Harry2 : March 23rd, 2018-20:24
A man of serious taste, as usual I’d be in
login to reply

What if

 By: Gelato Monster : March 25th, 2018-04:04
We add full minute/second military ring like 5517?
login to reply

Is there a vintage Tudor Sub that had the full minute markers on the bezel?

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-07:34
I don’t know vintage Tudor subs 792x that well. You other PuristS definitely know more than me. I think the 15-minute markings on the bezel has been standard with Tudor vintage for a long time though, so it makes sense the way it is with the Black Bay 58 ... 
login to reply

No marking would be very clean

 By: Gelato Monster : March 25th, 2018-15:47
login to reply

No lollipop unless it gets Mercedes hour hand

 By: Arie - Mr Orange : March 26th, 2018-12:07
But why change this hand lay out? IMO it should be left the way it is.
login to reply

The Black Bay is a strange mix-match

 By: Joepny : March 26th, 2018-12:49
I think the circular hour markers are taken from the 1950's Tudor submariners which were using parts from Rolex and those also used the Rolex Mercedes hour hand/lollipop seconds hands for the most part. There was an exception with pencil hands. The snowfl... 
login to reply

The snowflake hands are a good design call.

 By: Arie - Mr Orange : March 26th, 2018-12:55
And just like you said the snowflakes will be the big brand identifier clearly separating it from Rolex.
login to reply

Oh Thank You!

 By: patrick_y : April 4th, 2018-01:34
I suggested the Mercedes hour hand and lollipop second hand too! The standard "pencil" hands will work with the lollipop second hand. But the snowflake hour hand won't work with the lollipop second hand.
login to reply

I back up this suggestion Nico!

 By: renerod : April 2nd, 2018-06:20
It would look stunning! Cheers! René
login to reply

Remember this one for the Italian market ? Please try again ❤

 By: M@ster : March 23rd, 2018-19:46
login to reply

yes the Orologi & Passioni one

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-03:58
I liked it. I’m not Italian though and Tudor has no great legacy in Italy so the wording in Italian is a novelty.
login to reply

Hi M@ster. Please check your PM! [nt]

 By: ChristianDK : April 2nd, 2018-05:21
login to reply

That's nice!

 By: patrick_y : April 4th, 2018-01:35
But we need to do something different! And I'm dying for the lollipop second hand, which looks better with a hand that isn't the snowflake hour hand.
login to reply

I guess having a curved script on the bottom..

 By: Echi : March 23rd, 2018-19:48
A la “self winding” won’t make sense on this iteration. I find that touch particularly romantic along with the rose
login to reply

there is the original Tudor rose logo inside the shield

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-04:08
I don’t think Tudor has ever printed it again in modern times. this would be even cooler. ...  
login to reply

That font!

 By: Echi : March 24th, 2018-05:08
login to reply

That would perfect . [nt]

 By: Steve58 : April 14th, 2018-01:25
login to reply

I'm in [nt]

 By: emcquillan : March 23rd, 2018-19:57
login to reply

Count me in! [nt]

 By: jonrus : March 23rd, 2018-22:18
login to reply

Awesome idea.

 By: Rhyzen : March 23rd, 2018-22:20
I'm definitely in if this comes true.
login to reply

my fav release this bw

 By: keks : March 23rd, 2018-22:38
well... for a PuristS edition I would definitely be in!
login to reply

Looks great to me. I’d love one. [nt]

 By: maxfcc1 : March 24th, 2018-00:37
login to reply

Yes and no

 By: Bruno.M1 : March 24th, 2018-00:44
without the rose They must keep this for the eta movements, keep this unique for these pieces Give these eta rose pieces the chance to get special and collectible overtime That aside.... I’m interested On the other hand... I wish Tudor would not accept al... 
login to reply

well I think Tudor’s revitalization started about 6-7? years ago

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-04:30
It has not been long that Tudor came back to the world with very good modern watches. So I think all these “special edition” watches with retailers & enthusiast communities have been part of their strategy to build their business. I am sure it will become... 
login to reply


 By: FlyingSnoopy : March 24th, 2018-08:21
Isn’ There a black bay edition for harrods?
login to reply


 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-10:07
there was Harrod’s green bezel one. Bucherer had the blue bezel bronze case. I am really surprised that there was no special version in North America with any of the big Tudor ADs here. perhaps there was and it was not publicized.
login to reply

Kinda share your sentiment on special editions...

 By: Mr.Gatsby : March 25th, 2018-09:03
Shouldn’t create too many of them. Doesn’t make any sense. But in this instance if they really make one.....I’m in !!
login to reply

Why not?

 By: VMM : March 24th, 2018-02:49
Love the extra red on the dial, I think it looks much better than the original. I really like the original, but I'm not sure if I would buy it, let's wait to se how it feels on my wrist. I guess if it could be made Á la carte, we could end up with a very ... 
login to reply

the Tudor website has a watch design feature but it is not truly customization

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-04:35
i would not be surprised if they allowed more customization in 4-5 years. it would fit with the type of offerings that Tudor has made for the last few years already: variety on bezel & strap/bracelet. the next step is to allow buyers the ability to tweak ... 
login to reply

Great idea, count me in [nt]

 By: ambel : March 24th, 2018-03:49
login to reply

Definitely, I’m up for this...

 By: Cpt Scarlet : March 24th, 2018-03:55
Great idea. Hope that Tudor wants to play ball. Can we have it on a bracelet and NATO band that reflects the special edition.
login to reply

If anyone knows Monsieur Eric Pirson, CEO Tudor, or someone else at Tudor management

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-04:21
we need a sponsor there to get this project started!!! 🙏🤞
login to reply

If it’s of any help...

 By: Cpt Scarlet : March 24th, 2018-04:41
I will order more than one if we don’t reach the total needed to make the project happen.
login to reply

Savy Collector Cpt [nt]

 By: Gelato Monster : March 24th, 2018-04:46
login to reply

For the greater good ...

 By: Cpt Scarlet : March 24th, 2018-04:51
Not for personal gain. That’s my code.
login to reply

Good man! 😁

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-06:45
I have ideas to prevent behavior that is not truly long-term passion for a special project watch. I remember the Vacheron Hodinkee chronograph made 1 year ago that was ludicrously flipped by 4 buyers after about 3 months; that was out of like 35 total wat... 
login to reply

I like this idea .

 By: Steve58 : April 14th, 2018-01:29
I believe the 1st year warranty idea is solid
login to reply

If the watch fund allows and the group allows

 By: Gelato Monster : March 24th, 2018-11:37
It would be very very nice to purchase more than one of such limited edition to be passed on or gifted to family or the closest of friends.
login to reply

Cool, that would be fantastic!

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-12:27
I typically think when you have a wait-list and there's a queue of people who say they want something, you have to expect that 10-20% will change their minds for some reason. If we have 60 people on PuristSPro who say that they want to buy this special co... 
login to reply

Would love this....

 By: chris7509 : March 24th, 2018-04:42
It would look really nice .... I am interested +1 !!!
login to reply

Hehe...I think it will be a good list of special requests 😉

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-06:50
The first big steps are to get PuristSPro management (Bill, Anthony, MTF, ThomasM) to green light the project. Then perhaps find a PuristSPro moderator with Tudor knowledge (Nicolas or Miranda or Baron or DrStrong) who can manage the project. Then finding... 
login to reply

Iam all game ...why not ask for ghost bezel showing age and patina ?

 By: Horology75 : March 24th, 2018-06:24
And then we could have purist etching at the back .
login to reply

I think Nicolas asked for that too

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-06:54
The wish list grows: -Tudor rose logo on dial -red writing for 200m:660ft text -faded/ghost bezel -red seconds hand -lollipop seconds hand -drilled lugs -special PuristSPro engraving on caseback
login to reply

Yes! [nt]

 By: FlyingSnoopy : March 24th, 2018-08:23
login to reply

see picture attached

 By: ambel : March 24th, 2018-09:45
login to reply

I am in for the BB58

 By: Karlisnet : April 1st, 2018-07:14
login to reply

yes I remember the Only Watch unique piece

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-10:11
Crazy price! I think it will be very difficult to convince Tudor to do anything that gets close to that unique piece. I bet Tudor wants to keep that unique piece design separate. Like the lollipop seconds hand that a few members have on the wish list, I t... 
login to reply

Please no lollipop !! [nt]

 By: Steve58 : April 14th, 2018-01:32
login to reply

I'm in! [nt]

 By: fourtaelsgold : March 24th, 2018-10:13
login to reply

We have 20 PuristS expressed interest. We need more!

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-10:26
PuristSPro management and Tudor management will not be convinced by 20 guys. I’m pretty sure that is a cold hard fact. We really need 60-70 people with serious interest. Updated wish list: -Tudor rose logo on dial -red writing for 200m:660ft text -faded/g... 
login to reply

I'd buy one

 By: matto1 : March 24th, 2018-10:48
With red text line👍
login to reply

Fantastic! We need a big base of passionate, real people who want to own a special watch long-term

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-12:23
That'll help convince the people in power that this project is worth it
login to reply

5517 Milspec full ring marking

 By: Gelato Monster : March 25th, 2018-04:07
Instead of 12-3 quarter marking
login to reply

The faded bezel could perhaps be a dark grey [nt]

 By: Steve58 : April 14th, 2018-01:33
login to reply

I am in [nt]

 By: germane : March 24th, 2018-12:30
No message body
login to reply

Joe, hopefully Mr Kelly responds on the IG post.

 By: Jay (Eire) : March 24th, 2018-16:59
And is hopefully following here now too. It's a great idea, thanks for taking the initiative. Finally as I said on IG, I'm in too!
login to reply

thanks Jay! great that you knew his IG account

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-18:07
I heard a podcast from Dean Delray when Russell Kelly was interviewed. So I was going to hit up Dean Delray’s IG account to see if he could help get in touch with Tudor management before I saw your post. Let’s make this dream into reality!
login to reply


 By: DonQuijones : March 24th, 2018-19:20
I've been watching from the sidelines for a while. Naturally my first post has to be in support of this quixotic idea!
login to reply

thanks for your vote and we need more “lurkers” to join the party!

 By: Joepny : March 24th, 2018-20:43
It’s an uphill battle, this pipe dream of ours. But a dream shared by many starts to feel like something possible in real life!
login to reply

I think I could use one. :-)

 By: SRG : March 24th, 2018-20:49
39mm seems like a great size.
login to reply

Ok guys I’m in for this [nt]

 By: Maltie : March 25th, 2018-08:39
login to reply

I'm in too!

 By: jpd : March 25th, 2018-08:41
preferably with a bezel slightly fading to grey (as Nico had mentioned) and a lollipop second hand would also be great... But ne that as it may: count me in on this please! Best, Jan
login to reply

Don’t needle to tell you that I’d be in :P

 By: willski : March 25th, 2018-09:02
Cool watch would be even better!
login to reply

:D That birthday watch for your newborn last year has really gotten you into Rolex & Tudor!

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-09:21
We both have to work on Padj and convince him to go from handmade watches to the humble goodness of Tudor!
login to reply

Haha yes.

 By: willski : March 25th, 2018-09:54
We will get padj on board The durability and practicality of Rolex is appealing me at this stage... ...  
login to reply


 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-10:03
Obviously you'll need the new Pepsi GMT for yourself since the Batman is for your son.
login to reply

Haha yes or vica versa.

 By: willski : March 25th, 2018-10:17
The new two tone is also nice! Feels weird that I’ve (regained) strong feelings for modern Rolex... 🤔
login to reply

Why not a red rose? [nt]

 By: TheMadDruid : March 25th, 2018-09:28
login to reply

Great idea!

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-09:49
I just wish I had skills on PhotoShop to make up a picture with a red rose. It would look awesome. Ross Povey, a big Tudor collector and writer (he writes for Revolution Watch magazine) found a special Tudor made for the London Metropolitan Police unit th...  
login to reply

A rough picture - red Tudor rose

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-10:01
login to reply

What do you have agains the House of York?

 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : March 27th, 2018-13:19
login to reply

What do you have against the house of Stark? [nt]

 By: zabreg1 Mr White : March 28th, 2018-09:13
login to reply

I'm Green Lantern [nt]

 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : March 28th, 2018-10:05
login to reply

Nice ! [nt]

 By: Steve58 : April 14th, 2018-01:35
login to reply

Thanks everyone for joining the dream...we're at around 30 people

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-09:36
and maybe a few have friends/families so our real potential watch buying power is higher. We need to keep on growing. Sure it's a very long shot, but why not dream? So, we're trying to see if Mr. Russell Kelly, head of Tudor Watch USA, will read this thre... 
login to reply

I'm in but I have a more "radical" design

 By: reintitan : March 25th, 2018-11:16
which I don't think Tudor will go for: Change the circular hour markers into square hour markers for a full Snowflake dial and hands.
login to reply

I think the square markers are reserved for the Pelagos

 By: Joepny : March 25th, 2018-12:14
The Black Bay line is honoring the Tudor Submariners from the 1950’s which I think all used the circle markers.
login to reply

Good idea!

 By: Arie - Mr Orange : March 25th, 2018-11:24
I guess I would be in.
login to reply

Great idea. Interested for sure. [nt]

 By: cea : March 25th, 2018-12:02
login to reply

Awesome idea! Count me in!:) [nt]

 By: Daniel_Eira : March 25th, 2018-16:38
login to reply


 By: Plexi : March 25th, 2018-21:13
I'm in🥁👍🏻
login to reply

Pls count me in.

 By: Seeks : March 26th, 2018-06:46
Great ideas for the changes / improvements ! Many thanks
login to reply

Great idea!

 By: Fantasio : March 26th, 2018-09:56
First render looks best to me, I hope the amount of changes won't get out of hand.
login to reply


 By: Joepny : March 26th, 2018-10:28
Imran, please tell me you're talking to Tudor about it. We have about 40 PuristS who have signed up with interest for this watch concept after 3 days. Some are willing to buy more than 1 watch for friends/family. I know BaselWorld is still going on and th... 
login to reply

I'll be in too if it's not the bracelet version :) [nt]

 By: AnthonyTsai : March 26th, 2018-11:08
login to reply

I would love a rubber bracelet option like the JLC Extreme Lab 2

 By: Joepny : March 26th, 2018-11:17
or the PP Aquanaut. In golden brown. I’m not really convinced by the Tudor NATO strap design, could live without it.
login to reply

Now you have all my attention. ;) [nt]

 By: amanico : March 26th, 2018-11:26
login to reply

:O Now we're talking! [nt]

 By: Thevenin : March 26th, 2018-11:27
login to reply

If pencil hands confirmed - I am in...

 By: chronos-lorien : March 27th, 2018-02:44
I think this is a matter of proper communication with Tudor. The pencil hands (like on the Only Watch ed) should not be a problem for the manufacturer to be installed on small series (at least technically). Lets try!
login to reply

I’m sure making pencil hands in itself for Tudor is not a problem

 By: Joepny : March 27th, 2018-04:44
The bigger challenge is their Tudor design code and what image they will allow any of their production watches to have and how it impacts assembly of the watch, even if for a small special order. If you look at all the special Black Bay watches that were ... 
login to reply

I’m in too!

 By: cfn : March 28th, 2018-07:11
I would love to own such a watch, if possible. I am a recent convert to Tudor after having purchased a Black Bay Bronze Blue here in Copenhagen. Claus
login to reply

Any further news on this project ? [nt]

 By: Cpt Scarlet : March 27th, 2018-06:19
login to reply

No, it is still early

 By: Joepny : March 27th, 2018-06:49
BaselWorld is just officially ending today March 27. I have not heard from Tudor officially, but it is probably because they are focused on BaselWorld. So I guess the Tudor managers will want to have a recovery period after BaselWorld and then perhaps we ... 
login to reply

I can’t believe …

 By: Cpt Scarlet : March 27th, 2018-10:47
the great people at Tudor have anything better to do with their time than to help us with our mission for perfection.
login to reply

turnover is turnover

 By: Arie - Mr Orange : March 27th, 2018-13:13
so no, they do not have anything better to do 😉
login to reply

Tudor BB58

 By: paguiarneto : March 27th, 2018-11:56
I would be all in for this Tudor!
login to reply

Yes please

 By: Sug : March 27th, 2018-18:32
This watch with the rose on the dial? Me ready to pay up now. Count me in.
login to reply

I’m in!

 By: Questlove : March 27th, 2018-19:58
This would be dream come true!
login to reply

Tudor Black Bay 58 PuristSPro Edition - I'm in! [nt]

 By: lightspirex : March 27th, 2018-20:59
login to reply

count me in! [nt]

 By: halkcb : March 27th, 2018-21:25
login to reply

That Red Rose idea is a great one! I'm in :) [nt]

 By: YpJ : March 28th, 2018-10:14
login to reply

What if there is no gilt, bronze, red or any suggestive colour???

 By: Mary Anny : March 29th, 2018-01:14
I would buy something like that straightaway. It would remind me so much my father's 5508 it was stolen from me many years ago! Size, lungs, bracelet! Tudor often broadens watch lines! Sorry, my idea goes in a completely different direction. ...  
login to reply

A sort of monochromatic one

 By: Joepny : March 29th, 2018-05:23
Well, it might be too subdued for most. But you never know what Tudor will do in the future. I think Tudor will make other commercial versions of the BB58 over the next year after the first release will be out in July. It makes sense for their business wh... 
login to reply

No gold finishing touches

 By: Mary Anny : April 6th, 2018-07:47
Another rendering with no gilt, no red, no gold! ...  
login to reply

Last one only black, silver, and white

 By: Mary Anny : April 9th, 2018-03:53
A Black Bay 39mm so reminiscent of old Submariners with no crown guards. ...  
login to reply

Make sure you keep up-to-date with Miranda’s Tudor post

 By: Joepny : April 9th, 2018-06:08
His will be the official one for this PuristSPro Black Bay 58 project.
login to reply

My apologies!

 By: Mary Anny : April 11th, 2018-05:01
Sorry, did not know where to post te idea!
login to reply

Count me in!

 By: Nicetomeetyou : August 11th, 2018-19:57
I hope this happens
login to reply

I have never owned or even seen a Tudor watch in real life.

 By: Costa (aka Connie) : March 29th, 2018-04:16
I like the idea. I would be in on this deal. I think it would be a good way to be introduced to the brand.
login to reply

Im in for the ppro edition [nt]

 By: quatuor27 : April 1st, 2018-02:28
login to reply


 By: alexxelor : April 1st, 2018-05:44
i share , great idea , i want one . 58 it's the best tudor watch . i really hope so... we don't make the same mistake as others special edition group . to be special , our watch will have different references from the original model , like the special edi... 
login to reply

I'm in...

 By: SamiAm : April 2nd, 2018-21:10
Praying for superdome, Mercedes hour hand & lollipop second hand!!!
login to reply

Great idea athough i am a indie type of guy

 By: Watchonthewrists : April 14th, 2018-01:45
I am in 🙋🏻‍♂️
login to reply


 By: Joepny : April 15th, 2018-12:33
Make sure you respond also to Miranda’s (aka Imran) post in the Rolex forum 2 weeks ago. His will be the official one.
login to reply

Count me in for the limited edition for Purists! [nt]

 By: mustafadurrani : April 15th, 2018-10:45
login to reply

I would love to see this one !

 By: M@ster : May 21st, 2018-13:42
Beautiful blue and orange text ! 😍😍😍 Ps this is a black one but the light has made it blue-ish with orange writings ! If we can go in a different color please count me in please. ...  
login to reply

definitely a yes!! [nt]

 By: Watcholic_id : July 4th, 2018-06:28
login to reply

Let Miranda (aka Imran) know

 By: Joepny : July 4th, 2018-07:15
He is the moderator who will try to get Tudor’s acceptance. He created a thread also. Or maybe PM him if he’s keeping a list. I know that we had at least 50 PuristS members who have expressed interest. The more firm commitments we have will make it more p... 
login to reply

You’ve got Bob hope and No hope

 By: Miles_151 : July 4th, 2018-07:04
But I’d definitely be down for one if a miracle happens. Looks great. M.
login to reply

😅 I know, it’s a slim chance at best...

 By: Joepny : July 4th, 2018-07:16
Anyway, let Miranda know of your interest. He is the moderator who will try to get Tudor’s acceptance. He created a thread also. Or maybe PM him if he’s keeping a list. I know that we had at least 50 PuristS members who have expressed interest. The more f... 
login to reply

Count me in for the Purists edition. [nt]

 By: eyyeo : January 11th, 2019-19:59
login to reply