salihyoluc
25
Which one is a better investment/collectors item, 5970 vs 5270?
Hi Guys,
I'm a new member and a proud owner of a Patek 5550p. I purchased my watch couple months ago and could not be happier. It was a hard debate between that and a 5270G, and even though I liked the style of 5270 better, being 300 limited happened to be the key factor of my decision to purchase 5550p.
Now, I'm thinking about getting a second Patek, which makes me go toward to 5270G, but I got confused by some people suggesting 5970 more. I like both watches equally (well, almost), 5970 is more expensive but I think 5270G has good pricing right now and that may change in the near future, especially if they stop making it which is the rumor of Basel. So, it seems a little better investment to my amateur eyes. I also considered the 3970, but since I have a 37mm 5550p, I would like a change.
What do you guys think?
Thank you,
Salih
Available on the marketplace
Complications
Explore Patek Philippe's 2011 minute repeater novelties, references 5216 and 7000, showcasing high complications and design details.
14 replies158947 views
Reference Guide
Mark in Paris recaps 2016 Patek Philippe articles and previews 2017 Aquanaut and Caliber 240 anniversaries. Essential guide for collectors.
30 replies149252 views
New Release
Explore the Patek Philippe Ref. 5208 triple complication from Baselworld 2011, featuring a minute repeater, monopusher chronograph, and instantaneous perpetual calendar.
34 replies66555 views
Review
In-depth review of the Patek Philippe 5370P split-seconds chronograph. Explore its platinum case, black enamel dial, and CH29-535 movement. A potential icon.
97 replies62730 views
Review
Mark in Paris reviews the Patek Philippe 5270 (3rd generation) in G and R, detailing its dial, case, and in-house movement innovations. A must-read for collectors.
83 replies55911 views
New Release
Baselworld 2011: Patek Philippe 5270G perpetual calendar chronograph with in-house caliber. Explore its design, features, and collector reactions.
46 replies52048 views
Which one is a better investment/collectors item, 5970 vs 5270?
Hi Guys, I'm a new member and a proud owner of a Patek 5550p. I purchased my watch couple months ago and could not be happier. It was a hard debate between that and a 5270G, and even though I liked the style of 5270 better, being 300 limited happened to b...
Sorry, but its all the wrong reasons that are motivating you...
... is it so hard to just buy what you like? Even if its a Tissot or an Omega with all my due respect for those brands. Sounds you do not like watches for what they are but for their worth. Sorry, you ask what we think about it, i think you are motivated ...
well..
I thought I was clear explaining I almost like both the same. And in that case, it only makes sense to ask people who knew better about the subject which is being the better direction. But it seems that I was not clear enough. Salih
actually you were...
... just saying that what should split your decision is the one that makes your heart beat a little faster, not the one that might gain value. For that, you are better asking dealers and AD's, and even them cannot read the future. How to predict the futur...
You said in your post that
you liked 5270 more but took 5550P because it's a limited edition of 300 pieces. In case you have been following this site and the general spirit here, you should understand that after your comment you can't really expect very constructive and positive co...
That's true...
... because I enjoy having a more unique piece when it comes to try to get a collection together. That does not mean I like or enjoy my 5550p any less. My question is very clear actually, I'm not asking anyone to predict the future, just asking their opin...
It's a matter of taste...
The movement of 5270 is fantastic. But do you like the size and dial? Best, Kari
I think they are being a little harsh
It is obvious you are passionate about watches otherwise you wouldn't be spending considerable sums of money on Pateks. You come to this site for expertise opinions as an amateur watch collector, and you get shot down. Not everyone on this site is wealthy...
No problem...
... maybe I was not able to explain myself enough, but thank you for your support. Your words described exactly what I wanted to tell here. I'm sure I'll get some enlightning and valuable comments about my question which might help me decide.
yes...
... sorry, i might have sounded a bit harsh. Now, if i were you, i'd take the 5270. The movement is much superior, and it feels so too. Wind it, trigger the chrono, you will feel a world of difference with the 5970. The proportions of 5270 are also much m...
thank you
for a good explanation and no hard feelings of course. I have tried the 5270 on and absolutely loved it. I haven't had such a chance with 5970 though. I can only say I like them equally based on photos. I was originally going for 5270 but some pointed me ...
Mmmm....
.... from what you said, i try to guess. You are more or less new to Patek. Chances are you will go for 5270G. You have a "fresh eye" on the issue. Actually we have more to learn from you that you from us :) The hardcore fans, will instantly be more under...
It is much more secure and interesting to listen to your heart, and to ask your wrist
Which is the best sized for you. Compare both of the 3970, 5970 and 5270. Take time in looking at them, observing the dials and the movements, as well as the cases. Try them, taste them, feel them. Take your time, enjoy the doubt. Personalize your choice,...
Personally
I would try to find a new 5070R. The line has been discontinued, but there are some new ones around. IMO the most beautiful PP on the market. The watch would also offer a stark contrast to your 5550P.
Buy it if you like it!
I paid 40% more than list price for my 5070G, definitely a bad investment, but I feel great when I wear it. It happens a couple o times a week. The G is the most understated so it hardly gets noticed by untrained eyes. Buy with your heart! in this way, yo...
Exactly---Buy the one that appeals the most to you...
Not what you think is better investment. For me the answer was 3970P with silver dial. For you it might be any of the above!! Cheers,
You knw what I find most frustrating?
Is finding an AD willing to take the watch out of the plastic, or worse, the box. Then there is the AD who has had no 5070, 5970, or 3970 to even look at- ever. And that includes NYC Patek. I got to hold the 5270 twice in the plastic. It looked a little f...
Right place to go...
Hi Joe, Geneva, Paris, London. In Patek's own Salons you are most likely to find the watch. Geneva is the best bet - also the cheapest. Best, Kari
I will give you my advice but my commission rate is 5%
As we are talking about investment, my advices are not free. :) Fx
"... better investment ..."
... is something we don´t discuss here, or at least we shouldn´t do it (only :-) ) Especially when it comes to PP it happens too often that we discuss investment instead of sharing passion & knowledge. Please, don´t get me wrong it is nothing personal...
+1
Very well said. If one is soliciting advice on the investment potential of a particular piece they should probably direct their energy into developing a relationship with a dealer. This site is a pleasure to read because of the "love for watches" that exu...
Agreed
It's my opinion but discussion about investment potential sours the discussion.
5970 is more beautiful for me
although I have no idea of investment. Watch shouldn't be treated primarily as an investment tool.