Survey: Which Royal Oak would you choose …

Jun 24, 2024,07:12 AM
 

Friends,

If you had the choice of either the:

1. 5402 - 39 mm

2. 15202 - 39 mm

3. 15500 - 41 mm

To add to your collection. Which would you choose?

You can only choose one of the three choices. No long stories or long questions etc. Just choose one of the three. You are not allowed to resell the watch ever.

Assumptions:

• All prices exactly the same.

• All full set.

• All in NOS condition.

Thank you.









More posts: 152025402Royal OakRoyal Oak Jumbo

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

15202

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : June 24th, 2024-07:20

15202

 
 By: m2 : June 24th, 2024-08:05
AP RO wears 2mm or so large, so the smaller size is preferable imo.

15202

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : June 24th, 2024-08:12
The 41 mm too big for my 7 inch wrist, and I prefer a matching date wheel if a watch is going to have a date!

15202...right size

 
 By: halkcb : June 24th, 2024-08:15

15202

 
 By: Arronax : June 24th, 2024-08:19
I find the 41 a bit too large.

Marc, are you sure the first one is the correct 5402?

 
 By: ArmisT : June 24th, 2024-08:27
I don’t know enough, but I went to look it up thinking this is the original, but wondered why the AP logo is at 12 o’clock. But looking up an AP site article shows a 5402st version which is similar to the 15402 although with white date wheel. Please clari... 

You are too clever… 🤝

 
 By: SingaporeMarc : June 24th, 2024-08:48
I wanted to see who would notice. Series A 👏 ...  

5402!

 
 By: HK852 : June 24th, 2024-14:36

🤣🙏🏽

 
 By: ArmisT : June 24th, 2024-19:47
But I think there may have been different dials, since your other picture also pops up. That’s why I’m asking.

and your vote is ...?

 
 By: Marc_Personal : June 25th, 2024-06:23

5402 A-series

 
 By: ArmisT : June 25th, 2024-08:33

the dials of the 5402 were different with the different series

 
 By: Marc_Personal : June 24th, 2024-09:06
apchronicles.audemarspiguet.com

Very nice, this explains it!

 
 By: ArmisT : June 24th, 2024-19:51
Interesting that there was such degree of difference. Regardless, very educational article. Thanks.

41mm, I have a 20cm wrist

 
 By: The Berlin Flatline : June 24th, 2024-08:40

15202

 
 By: smironov : June 24th, 2024-08:59

15202

 
 By: AlfaQ4 : June 24th, 2024-09:01

I really prefer the 41mm size.

 
 By: shafran : June 24th, 2024-09:13
So 15500

15500 Blue dial

 
 By: Moka-Tiger (Ron) : June 24th, 2024-09:25

5402

 
 By: VinnieD : June 24th, 2024-09:47
the purest and most historical one!

15202 for me also.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : June 24th, 2024-11:01

15202 (16202 better)

 
 By: 1WatchMan : June 24th, 2024-11:12

5402

 
 By: SALMANPK : June 24th, 2024-11:20

16202 (as a choice above the listed 15202) bc of the upgraded movement.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : June 24th, 2024-12:00
The 15500 is too bulky and sporty and the 5402 is too brittle and I’m not a fan of date windows with different colors (compared to the dial)

Agree

 
 By: smironov : June 24th, 2024-12:25

15202

 
 By: LarsG : June 24th, 2024-12:28

The 15500 for me

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : June 24th, 2024-12:30

5402.

 
 By: Ajas : June 24th, 2024-12:34

15202.

 
 By: bruckner4 : June 24th, 2024-13:26

15510 for me.

 
 By: Champthekid : June 24th, 2024-13:50
So 41mm which works well for me. ...  

I like the movement better in the 15510.

 
 By: Champthekid : July 7th, 2024-22:40
It’s more important than the date wheel color to me 👍

#2

 
 By: BR8 : June 24th, 2024-22:07
For me.

Results

 
 By: Marc_Personal : June 25th, 2024-06:31
Thanks to all who responded Results: 1. 5402-39 mm 6 votes 2. 15202-39 mm 13 votes 3. 15500-41 mm 3 votes The 15202 is a clear winner here. Having said that: a) I have posted a "nicer" picture of the 15202 compared to the 5402. b) I did not talk about the... 

Even later than wangany ☺️

 
 By: MTR : July 10th, 2024-20:16
But it won’t change the result. 15500 for me. Cheers Thomas

15202 Gen 2

 
 By: SingaporeMarc : July 10th, 2024-15:33
🤝

from those 15202 but 14802 is the one for me

 
 By: GuinnessForMeAndTheWatch : July 12th, 2024-06:59

15202

 
 By: Eikþyrnir : July 13th, 2024-21:24
Again and again

15202

 
 By: EugeneT : July 14th, 2024-13:18
nt