SchmidtSol
55
Request for guidance and feedback on these two PP
Dear all,
I am in the process of applying for a PP minute repeater. The 5178G and the new 5374G were my finalists also with a view on my rather large wrist (sorry for the poor pictures). While I have a clear favourite, I wanted to hear your thoughts. So which one do you prefer? Looking forward to your feedback and guidance. Thanks...
Rotate images:
This message has been edited by India Whiskey Charlie on 2021-08-14 20:38:43
New Release
Discover Patek Philippe's 2017 Baselworld novelties: 24 new references blending tradition with modern design, including the 5320G, 5168G, and 5372P.
124 replies80365 views
New Release
Explore the Patek Philippe 5178G-012 minute repeater. HERMINATOR reviews its blue enamel dial, strap versatility, and community reactions to this modern classic.
47 replies16817 views
Manufacture
Recap of a visit to the Patek Philippe Geneva Salon, featuring grand complications like the 5160G, 5178G, 5374P, 5372P, and 5208P. Essential for collectors.
39 replies13928 views
Complications
Explore 39 Patek Philippe Minute Repeater models, from historical pieces like the Henry Graves Jr. to modern references. A deep dive into chiming complications.
54 replies13634 views
Manufacture
Explore the intricate case profiles of Patek Philippe's 2017 collection. Mark in Paris highlights subtle design details and craftsmanship that define the brand's unique aesthetic.
35 replies11953 views
New Release
Live shots from BaselWorld 2017 showcase Patek Philippe's new complicated watches: 5316P, 5178G, 5078G, 5372P, and 5131P, with expert insights.
18 replies11681 views
Request for guidance and feedback on these two PP
Dear all, I am in the process of applying for a PP minute repeater. The 5178G and the new 5374G were my finalists also with a view on my rather large wrist (sorry for the poor pictures). While I have a clear favourite, I wanted to hear your thoughts. So w...
If it was me
I would select the one with the crème dial. The blue dial has the perpetual calendar and all but somehow the dial seems to crowded for me
5178, no contest
But I admit to bias, that’s been a grail of mine since it was introduced. Either way, Congrats on your future PP.
oops
Hit send by mistake. I agree, the simplicity of the 5178 is the way to go. It will never outstay its welcome. Way way above my pay grade, but one can dream! Congratulations whichever you choose!
No brainer for me as well
If you ask me, 5178 with no hesitation but the only opinion that matters is yours
5178G 15:0 5374G
Dear friends, Thanks indeed for your kind feedback and clear messages. My preference was/is the 5374G, but I will need to think about this based on your unanimous and sound guidance .....
While my preference also rests with the 5178 -- the simplicity and cleanness of this reference are just unbeatable in my view -- you are arguably considering two watches at the very top of Patek's catalog...so there's truly NO wrong outcome here! :-)
Please follow your heart -- and if your initial "clear favorite" was the 5374, then chances are THAT is the right Patek for you! Please keep us posted, and thanks for consulting the community on this most important decision ;-) Cheers.
Allow me to be the contrarian. Assuming in the metal the blue dial is a beautiful as on the 5370P, my strong preference would be the 5374G. Why?
Patek for me is all about complications and to have a MR combined with a perpetual is both practical (the repeater), romantic (the MR) and technically extraordinairy. Blue enamel is just amazing! I also prefer the case style of 5374. For me, again if the ...
From a pure design perspective, I would pick
5178G because the clean dial enables the focus on the MR. However, I would consider your overall collection to see what fits better in terms of complications and dial color/design.
5178G
Hands down, the 5178G. To those who don’t know what it is, it look like a simple time-only watch. But if you know, you know. So understated and subtle.