Baron - Mr Red
14613
As a general rule....
there is nobody on this site that can lay claim to knowing what is the nicer of the two. Some say the black dial and platinum are a negative, yet others say that is what they like about it. It is just silly to say one is better than the other.
I have now had the fortune to have tried both watches on my wrist. I remain with my original view that the 5970P has something about it, and maybe that is its rarity, but it seems to be the Daddy. If i had a 5970R and had the choice of keeping it and missing the 5970P, or selling the 5970R to buy the 5970P (and those were my only options), then yes I would make the trade to buy the 5970P. That is a personal view. It does not make me right. But, it does make me right for my personal choice. There is a similar dilemma on the 5070s too, with a choice of 4 different possibilities. Unless you are Tim!
Both watches are stunning. In my opinion, they both represent one of the most beautiful watches from PP. Many people have said if you can, then have both. If you can't, then you just have to listen to the heart. If you keep coming back looking at the 5970P with that little "yearning" calling to you, do the trade.
5970 Dilemma?????
I find myself in a situation......I have been offered a 5970p at list price from my AD....But I already own what I think is the most beautiful 5970. For me the 5970rg is just perfect....The warmth of the Pink gold is just fantastic....I have held all the ...
lucky you...
A few observations 1. You love your 5970Rg 2. You are ambivalent about the platinum model 3. You feel that the plat model is possibly more deirable than the rg but 4. you would either have to break your one model rule or 5.sell some of your watches. Both ...
Great responce Julian....My eyes and heart have always made the decision for me....
But can I trust them this time???? M.
If only...
to buy just because it is tempting, NICE but NOT nice enough to push you over the edge to buy, to buy just because it is something we can give to our sons, I say walk away. Regret over not getting something can be resolved with the passage of time and inf...
Simple...
... IMO, the 5970R is one of the nicest Patek, in the nicest metal... Basically its my grail watch. Closest as possible to perfection. You seem to agree with me on the warmth of the RG, and how this watch is a step above the YG and the WG. Point is : How ...
Thanks Karim, I wish it was simple....
You make a good case Cheers M. This message has been edited by Miles151 on 2009-05-31 04:02:11
the answer has been found...
".....I have found that this rule has helped me put together a varied, colourful collection....So what to do??? " You break your rule Miles. I can promise you, there won't be any crying about the presence of an extra 5970 in the patchwork of your collecti...
I would not buy it
If you have the 5970R and think this is the best looking 5970, keep the 5970R ! If you need to sell other watches before you can buy the 5970P it depends on how much you like those others. If money isn't a problem and you could buy it without any problem ...
Simple:
Go to your AD with your 5970 RG on your wrist, and then have a look in real on the 5970P. Then follow your heart, you will know if the 5970P is worth sacrificing your 5970 RG and some other watches you obviously love a lot. Best, Nicolas
good advice....
I would just add that you do this trip about three or four times just to be certin about your decision Cheers
take the one that makes you happy...
for me, i'll take both. that's a great collection in my opinion, and sell the others. but, it may not be for you or others as posted. I think it's a personal decision that nobody can answer for you.
Two dilemmas!
Dear Miles If you don't buy it, you will have another dilemma: Which one of your sons - you seem to have more than one - gets the 5970R?? If you have two sons, each of them will get a 5970, if you bought the 5970P. Then, they will have to decide on the me...
Like your way of thinking......
So then give the 5070p to the son with the Rg 5970 and the 5960p to the one who wants the 5970p..... Great idea.....I can see some arguments in the future M.
Keep the 5970R
You definitely want to keep the 5970R. Doesn't seem like you like the 5970P that much, don't feel obligated to buy something just because your AD has something rare available.
If it is about 'collectibility'
then clearly, get the P. That's a no brainer. If it is about 'love', keep your R. I've bought oh so many watches because of so-called collectibility, and just about never kept them... watches are very very personal things. However, it is really hard to le...
Thanks for the great reply...Collectibility and Love...In that order...
I have made my mind up that whatever happens I am keeping the Rg 5970 as for me this is the best looking 5970 ever made....And I would always regret selling this stunner......I am more in love with it's rarity and collectibility than the dial that's for s...
my pleasure Miles.
I'd say 'good luck' but clearly, you are a very lucky man already!
5970 Delemma
Hello Miles, I agree with Bruno's advise. If you have to sell one to buy this, then think twice before making any move. I see we both agree the 5970R is our holy grail of PP collections. In that case, the 5970P would really have to stir my blood before I ...
Looks great.....I'm sure my kids would thank me.....One day...
Is this your only 5970????? M.
This is not a problem...
so if you really don't know what you want, do the obvious: nothing.
Miles, keep the 5970R
Miles, unless you can afford both the 5970R and 5970P, I wouldn't give up a watch that I love for one that might be a bit more collectible. If you could afford both, then by all means buy both. I think all watches of the 5970 series will be collectible. I...
here is how I LOOK at these 2 pieces
As mentioned in one of my previous threads, I had the good fortune of looking at these 2 watches side by side at a local AD recently. BTW I was shown the watches as a courtesy and not as a potential buyer.. Following is my impression; I did not find the P...
I have seen the 5970P in metal recently...
It doesn't look great in metal other than it's a 5970 PLATINUM. I will be very blunt with you and hope it will help. If rarity is the attraction, this piece will fade very quickly in your heart as it belongs to one that's 'very sought after' because of it...
SOMETIMES, IT PAYS TO RECONSIDER THE RULES
Hi Miles, First off, I can see what a struggle this is for you and I empathize with your plight. I feel that there have been many good suggestions made in this thread and it seems they have been helpful for you. I have often tried to make myself stick to ...
Why follow a "rule" that makes you painful?
Who set the rule anyway? Was that you yourself?
My choice is clear!
It seems some of the guys who are lucky and already own a 5970 have a little problem with the new platinum version. Hey, every 5970 is gorgeous and important! If I would be in this position I'd have a little problem, too. Thinking:" DAMNED, IT'S REALY NIC...
As a general rule....
there is nobody on this site that can lay claim to knowing what is the nicer of the two. Some say the black dial and platinum are a negative, yet others say that is what they like about it. It is just silly to say one is better than the other. I have now ...
I wish i had this Dilemma!!...
Both absolutely beautiful watches....if you can afford it buy the 5970P as well.
I am sure there are a dozen other so-called collectors waiting io aquire it from your AD
Just take the plunge, it you find after wearing the P for several weeks it's not for you then sell and trade up to a 5074P, My holiest of the holy grails on my wish list.
The PP 5970P looks terrible!!!Keep your PP RG and ...
enjoy it fully. With the rest of your cash, put it in the stock market. You could then get a PP 5970P for free from the profits and slow depreciation of the PP 5970 P as the black dial just does not do it!!!!! I am wearing my PP 5970G for ever!!!
It would be really good....
....if comments were kept positive. Saying things like the 5970P looks terrible is just an opinion and actually not especially helpful. And, for me, I am much more likely to participate in a debate if its kept positive...or at a minimum avoids negativity.
Hi Patektime1 registered today :-) Your watch is the best in the world!
You are exactly the type I meant. Of course the new version is realy ugly and you have the best taste and the only watch. Thank you for your differientiate opinion!!!
Keep the R, and use the cash you save to buy...
...a dozen cases of Romanée-Conti. Santé! Tony P
Yes I agree . The RG is too beautiful to give up. The DRC is a great ...
alternative or even Chateau Lafite En Premiur 2008 which will far outstrip all investments in the midterm......I am sure the Pp 5970Rg that you have is smiling at you right now!!!
I'm surprised at so many relative cool response
to 5970P, it seem many view Patek as kind of stock for investment. When watches like 5712, 5980 were "HOT", there were lots of praises etc etc, but now it seem those "passions" died down. I am amazed at comments like "lack of legibility" or "size of date ...
Miles, good luck with your final decision making...............
Reading what you have already written, I agree with your decision. Keep the watch that you love. For me I want to say buy the 5970P, but that is only because it is one of my grail watches. Please keep us updated with what you decide to do.
keep your 5970r
if you'd buy 5970p, I think it would be for 'wrong reasons'. If it was a watch meant for you, you'd not need to ask perfect strangers about how to spend your $130,000 BTW, I had 5970P on my wrist.....nice....but not my cuppa tee....
5970P! That's it for me! Gorgeous!!!
The one to get and to keep. Beside many other reasons I like the bigger date very much. Every Chrono from Patek is nice, but this will be the most important one in the future of 5970's. Beside that, everyone who owns a 5970 (doesn't matter wich colour) is...