WatchProSite

Officine Panerai

Advertisement

Either you hate it or you love it...

 

I find this piece hard to take a middle position on, unless one isn’t sure yet.






  login to reply
Suggested threads *beta
30 Comments view entire thread 

Well I for one love it! Wish they launch this dial with the right hand version

 
By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : February 17th, 2021-16:00

Thank you 🙏🏼. I felt this would have been so nice in a 1940s case without the crown guard!

 
By: ArmisT : February 17th, 2021-16:06
I still wonder what motivated the destro decision on this one. C’est la vie.

You’re right this would look nice in the 1940s with no crown as well

 
By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : February 17th, 2021-17:04

+1

 
By: Cookies : February 18th, 2021-00:13
I like it too. It’s different. Agreed on the RH version. I will wait for it.

I have nothing against Panerai,

 
By: Thomas_3 : February 17th, 2021-17:07
I just can't stand that what I consider to be an ugly-ass crown guard. Remove that and for me it would be perfect.

Remove that, and the exact same watch would be called a Radiomir rather than a Luminor ;-)

 
By: FabR : February 17th, 2021-18:17

I admit that I’ve developed more of a liking for Radiomirs over the years...

 
By: ArmisT : February 17th, 2021-18:38
but I still think the crown guard is cool and defining.

Definitely, we are speaking of two a priori equally legitimate Panerai lines, in my view, both with a very clear identity. Here's my only Luminor, in front of...myself at age 21! ;-) Cheers.

 
By: FabR : February 17th, 2021-18:50
...  

Would anyone have noticed Stallone was wearing a Panerai if it had been a Radiomir?

 
By: Uncle Chico : February 18th, 2021-00:43

Sure, though some may argue the Radiomir is more historically significant than the Luminor -- I am no expert, but for me it's hard to think of Panerai without thinking of both lines after 70+ years😉👍

 
By: FabR : February 18th, 2021-04:29
No message body

Are you sure that isn’t Patrick Swayze ...

 
By: Cpt Scarlet : February 18th, 2021-02:21
In the background ;-))

It was James Dean trying to look like Patrick Swayze trying to look like me...it was a real mess that day! ;-))

 
By: FabR : February 18th, 2021-04:26
No message body

ROFL 🤣 👍

 
By: Cpt Scarlet : February 18th, 2021-06:10

They both indeed do have a clear identity...

 
By: nacelle : February 17th, 2021-20:33
No message body

👍

 
By: nacelle : February 17th, 2021-20:36

Agreed, it would have been perfect without the guard.

 
By: ArmisT : February 17th, 2021-18:35

It is part of Panerai DNA. It was their solution for the water resistance of their watches.

 
By: amanico : February 17th, 2021-23:49

Absolutely, I totally appreciate it as that...

 
By: ArmisT : February 18th, 2021-00:00
and also aesthetically. But this particular dial in a 1940 case would have been more intriguing overall IMHO...but it wouldn’t have the destro feature that I find equally intriguing.

Aaah, yes, ala 6154?

 
By: amanico : February 18th, 2021-00:02
Credit: Christies. ...  

YES, that’s the one!

 
By: ArmisT : February 18th, 2021-00:08
Thank you for adding that picture and reference number.

But Panerai is all about simplicity and legibility.... Hey, one out or two ain't bad!... so 50% out of character but it's super cool and I love it!

 
By: InDebtButOnTime : February 17th, 2021-17:30
No message body

:))) They could have at least shot for a 75% passing score;)

 
By: ArmisT : February 17th, 2021-18:46

I do like it, it's definitely a dial that stands out among several similar offerings -- but I agree, depending on what your position is on the brand, either you'll love it or you'll hate it! ;-) Enjoy.

 
By: FabR : February 17th, 2021-18:16
No message body

Well put, Fab. Thank you 🙏🏼

 
By: ArmisT : February 17th, 2021-18:47

They might have considered...

 
By: sergio : February 17th, 2021-19:41
a DLC or composite case, it would have had a nice...cappuccino...effect. Just go on enjoying it too much!!!

Well, I for one, love it!

 
By: nacelle : February 17th, 2021-20:32

A watch with a strong character and an original dial. Enjoy.

 
By: amanico : February 17th, 2021-23:50

Crown guard and sandwich dial - defining character traits.

 
By: Uncle Chico : February 18th, 2021-00:44

Looks like a guy was putting texture on his ceiling and sprayed his watch instead.

 
By: Blansky : February 18th, 2021-06:37
Note to self. Never take the crystal off your watch when painting.

😂 That was actually also said the first time I posted...

 
By: ArmisT : February 19th, 2021-01:48
and it’s very true! Ever since then, when looking at it closely and noticing the texture and monotone color, I can only see it as how you describe. It’s the uniqueness of the dial that keeps me intrigued