keks
4948
very very difficult call
I think both have their merits and it really comes down to what you think complements your collection and wearing needs the most.
The full bracelet aluminum I have tried in the simpler Octa Sport and thought it felt superb on the wrist. I believe the case is very similar on the centigraphe at 42mm so imagine feeling is similar. it is a beautiful color metal this aluminum. I am not sure where I heard this and perhaps it has been remedied, but recall someone mentioning years ago that there are cases where this version suffers from discoloration in the metal when exposed to sweat or saltwater. No idea if this is a fact or hearsay and also do not know how this metal oxidizes but perhaps something to consider knowing more about before committing.
The full bracelet titanium I have tried in 42 and 44mm. The 42 is more far more balanced in my opinion but I do like the absence of rubber details on bracelet and case on the 44mm version. But since you mentioned the 44mm is not even a consideration will not discuss that any more here. The dark tone of the titanium on this is extremely elegant.
So, if I had to choose one... if I could confirm that the aluminum is safe from discoloration (yellow stains from what I heard) and has an acceptable hardness level this is the version I would pick. Simply because I think the tone of the metal is gorgeous and the fact it is made of aluminum is pretty darn cool... sorry for the ramble but hope you find something in here somewhat useful! Good luck!
Centigraphe Sport : Opinions and experience please
I’ve discussed this with some of you privately and thanks for the feedback, but I wanted to open it up to the wider audience. I’m interested to hear all opinions on and experience with these two watches, the original Aluminum and the follow up in Titanium...
The First Edition Aluminum...
is a grail watch for me, for years I've tried to get one but it gets away from me due to the high price which is what it is for such a special and avant garde Sports watch. Most people are critical of its resemblance to a Swatch Irony which for me is like...
Thanks Salman.
There are detractors whom liken the look to other things, like the Swatch you mention. But like you, that’s just noise in my opinion. I wish you luck in the search for the Alu piece. They are out there, but prices can vary wildly. As does condition.
Titanium
Although the watches are not my style as the dial is to crowded for me, I like the titanium far better than the aluminum version. But I can fully understand why to do there this may be a grail watch. Reason i like titanium better is that the red on the su...
It’s taken me several years to come around to the dial.
Like you, initially I could not get over the busyness. And the hands, there’s something wrong with the hour/minute hands on these watches (the more traditional Journe hands, uniform in material/colour , would be a better fit). However, all that said in re...
I love both versions
For me, I will choose titanium for its style and the aluminium for its rarity. There is no loser really, good luck!
Just remember it's really a Foudroyante....
masquerading as a 1/100th resolveable chronograph. Our dearly departed Velociphile did some analysis of the relationship between true elapsed time and time shown measured by the Centigraphe. I can't find the post right now. Good luck in your search. Rapwa...
Yes. Thank you. I am eyes wide open on that point.
I had not seen the previous post, it’s interesting and thanks for sharing. I’ve heard many describing this watch as a gimmick, but I don’t see it that way. That said, I do understand where those people are coming from.
Too me it feels like a bridge too far (pun intended)
I never owned one but have tried them on thanks to a buddy who has both actually. To me it feels forced, like Journe saying we have to have a sporty watch. It just doesn’t feel like their space.
That’s a fair point, but he wasn’t lazy in terms of the approach to this.
I think there’s a lot of merit to the original Alu concept, and with the Ti (both the version above and the current models) he has created something which on the wrist feels incredible good. RM achieved the same, excellent wrist feel, almost unnoticeable....
I know, I did not say you did and if it appeared that way my apologies for not being clearer.
My point was sometimes a stretch is really just a quick money grab and lazy. This does not seem like that.
No water resistance for such a watch is an issue.
Otherwise not a bad effort, especially for such a small brand.
As stand-alone pieces both are nice, but there is one major issue ...
The classic CS is simply way better looking. If you put any sport one next to either the gold or platinum, it feels like a cheap replica rather than a sporty interpretation. Maybe some argument can be made for owning both. I personally don't like to own t...
I disagree and feel your opinion is too harsh and one sided, again using cars as an analogy the Classic Journes are like Rolls Royces and the Sporty Journes are like Paganis.....
both are cool just for different purposes and driving styles. S
We all have different tastes.
My opinion is based on having many opportunities to compare the two side by side in real life. I doubt I would feel the same way if I see a Rolls and a Pagani next to each other. But also they are not derivatives of each other. I think the main point is t...
My experience is similar.
On the (very few) occasions when I've tried a sport Journe, I was really taken with it.... until I turned back to my platinum CS.
It’s funny, I actually have no love for the classic. I think the Sport is a more appealing all around watch.
But that’s the fun here, we can’t all like the same things and “liking” is entirely subjective (or most of the time at least, we do all suffer from outside influences in terms of our likes and dislikes).
Honestly
My entire collection was never defined by what’s unique, but rather what spoke to me at the time. It’s a constant evolution and I have pieces I know I will grow out of and ones I will keep for a long time.
very very difficult call
I think both have their merits and it really comes down to what you think complements your collection and wearing needs the most. The full bracelet aluminum I have tried in the simpler Octa Sport and thought it felt superb on the wrist. I believe the case...
Thanks Keks, a ramble is good some times!
The rumors regarding the Alu are something I’ve not been able to verify, and I’ve spoken to a several owners of the Alu watches. But this is something I’m trying to get as much colour on as possible. A second question I have on materials is regarding the ...
My input. (partly a repeat of what we discussed via pm...)
I think for the aesthetics, in real life, the Au comes out as the winner. It is really an unusual appearance and a very pleasant subdued, whitish shine. I also think, it is much more interesting from a collection POV. It is (as far as I know) the first wa...
Thanks Christian.
The parts question was also something that is a factor, especially for wear and tear on the bracelet. It’s also helpful to know that the official comment is that the staining seems to be irreversible. My view and the consensus from the people I have spoke...
Great input Christian
Has there to your knowledge been any issues surrounding the rubber components on these references? I am mostly referring to the crown as it will be subject to winding on a mechanical watch but also curious on the bracelet as I suspect after some wear the ...
To my knowledge...
No quality issues with the rubber. I asked mr Journe why he had out phased the rubber parts. The answer was two fold. First, the supplier of the rubber parts had become unstable and causing delays. This had made him reconsider the rubber. The rubber parts...
Rubber is definitely an issue
I just got mine Rattrapante ( you can review my post ) , bracelet with rubber. The bracelet rubber got off one from day TWO. And the second rubber comes off from day THREE. After One year waiting I have to send it back. One year waiting, Two day enjoyment...
oh dear - that doesnt look good. So sorry for you!
I have to say this is the first time I hear about this. Has anyone else here in this forum had similar problems with their rubber bracelet?
Thanks for responding, it’s another data point which I’m sure will be helpful to others.
I picked up a CTS late last year. Very happy to add it to the collection.
Mine either.
I had the 42mm centigraphe sport on thebrubber strap. Loved the watch. On the titanium bracelet or if possible a red rubber strap it is a keeper. I replaced it with the fold ratrapante partially because I wanted a bracelet.
Thanks for sharing Dustin, and sorry to hear/see this.
I’ve talked to a lot of owners of these watches, mostly the older models, and this is not an issue anyone had identified. Hopefully there is a fast remedy and you have this watch back on the wrist ASAP. Please do keep us updated on progress.