patekova
1817
Seems like in Patek, "round" watches are definitely in and "form" watches are definitely out. My view is very different. What is your view?
For many years at least through the 1990s, vintage form watches, especially rectangles, were viewed as more desirable (and valuable!) than round watches, at least in time only watches. But that is no longer the case. The 5135 was revolutionary - a jumbo 50mm rounded rectangular ("tonneau") case with the highly desired annual calendar function. It caused quite a stir and for a while was a highly sought after timepiece. But that didn't last long. Not many people seem to care much about it (and I say that as someone with a contrary view and as the happy owner of this watch). Also I love 1940s/1950s rectangles with the 9-90 movements. Again I definitely am in the minority on this. Even square time only vintage watches were once highly desired - not any more. For me, round is great, but I equally like form watches, particularly rectangles.
So Forum members which side are you on, or possibly both sides?
Best, patekova
Seems like in Patek, "round" watches are definitely in and "form" watches are definitely out. My view is very different. What is your view?
For many years at least through the 1990s, vintage form watches, especially rectangles, were viewed as more desirable (and valuable!) than round watches, at least in time only watches. But that is no longer the case. The 5135 was revolutionary - a jumbo 5...
Hi Patekova, thank you for an interesting post ! For me, I appreciate...
both but do prefer more the round cases perhaps because the shape is easier to get used to. When I bought my 5396, I did consider the tonneau one seriously. At the end, I thought the 5396 would be closer to the classic Patek DNA. The Gondolo I think is re...
I agree...
...I definitely prefer the shape of the movement to follow that or the case.
Well, the round case is the perfect case.
So the form case is (and was) always a matter of taste, fashion, and "Zeitgeist"... 😉
Perfect while seeming to be an absolute is often subjective. Much as I like rectangles I like them as a variation.
If I could own only one watch I would opt for round.
I wonder....
.....if its more about what one is used to? I have mostly round watches and I have always worn round watches. When I put a rectangular watch (or other different shape) on my wrist, it feels and looks "wrong" to my eye. I think this is largely a norming pr...
My view is akin to yours, I would take a Cassa di Forma watch any day, the trouble is all the great ones are vintage, i would love Msr Stern to re- introduce the banana....
we already had the Eiffel Tower as the Pagoda and the Manta Ray as the millennium 5100 then these fabulous pieces; the 492 re-introduced as the Patek Geneva salon unique edition maybe we can see a modern Hour glass??? so yes I LOVE these Best Imran ...
Thanks Imran for the superb scholarly reply!!!!!! Of all the vintage rectangles, the "Bananas" Ref 2442 is my favorite, especially in RG! [nt]
I remember years ago, when vintage watches were much less expensive, seeing a 2442 RG go at auction for $100K USD - now that same watch would be much, much less (and that is without factoring in inflation). Mean time recently a Calatrava time only went fo...
My next watch will not be round for sure.
I'm Looking towards an ellipse 3738j or g, 5124j gondolo or the 5711 Nauti. So no round watch for me if I decide to save up for a next great timepiece. Also very keen on a jlc reverso which is a bit more accesible.
It all depends on how is the watch. Rectangular, Tonneau, TV Cushion shaped, Square, Ovale or Round, it doesn't really matter for me. The watch is what really matters.
Since we are in our Patek Forum, here is one of my dream Patek Watch. Ref 5100G. ...
Thanks Amanico for your reply! I feel much like you that it is the specific watch rather than a generalized category that should be the decisive factor. As far as 5100G, I think it is very special and
5100s are a bargain today - relative not only to others Pateks, but relative to the significantly higher prices they sold for just a few years ago. Best, patekova
Round watches are fine but
these are my two favourite watches currently. One is the ref 1530A (yes, that's right - exceedingly rare in stainless steel) and the other is the 3969R of which I just left a deposit on yesterday! Not only are they both not round but they are in a size th...
Thank you Patekova!
I have decided to ignore the norm and buy what I feel most comfortable with. The shape of the watch is a factor I am less concerned about than the size, the lugs and the weight of the watch. I am a bit strange because when I drive a car, I have to be at o...
The Gondolo line is a very elegant timepiece.
Yours very lovely. But its best in very formal occasions. Like a tux or 3pc. Suit for evening wear. You would look funny wearing it with a sports jacket. My opinion only. Best wishes. Again you have a lovely watch. Geross.
Thanks Geross for your kind words. One of the pleasures of Patek or any watch for that matter is incorporating it use
in one’s personal sense of style. I can definitely see it with a tux - but not for me. For my small wrist the watch is enormous and sporty. Hence I like it on the opposite end of the spectrum, with jeans. Yes, I know, but it’s platinum and has diamonds, h...
I think the nice thing with all PP annual calendar pieces
Is that they are incredibly versatile. With the right strap they are instantaneously transformed to suit any style I think. Yours is a cool piece. Can be dressy with a glossy crocodile strap or very casual with a grained calf. Not long ago I saw this piec...
Thank you Keks for your detailed endorsement. While the watch
Is very much under appreciated I very much appreciate your compliments on the watch. Best, Patekova
Just now my increasingly tired eyes noticed
a very cool detail on your 5135.... very cool I think: ...
Thank you Keks for posting 2 great images. The image of the G is an incredible high resolution shot. Looks beautiful
and I love it with that strap. Makes me think about possibly doing something similar with my P. And yes, good eye catching the “Tiffany”. Tiffany put it over the edge in a positive way for me. Haven’t found another image online, auction or otherwise of 51...
There are no hard fast rules in fashion.
You do what seems to make you happy. And what you deem apropriate. Best wishes. Thanks for sharing your joy. Geross.