This or that

Sep 04, 2024,20:22 PM
 

I cannot ignore these two at a very similar price point… Which one for you, and why?


*Images borrowed 








  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Tougher call than I thought…

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-20:39
Yes purer without date. But if I want the less “dressy” of the two, could one argue the date makes the JLC a touch more casual than the GO?

I have enough casual steel watches 😉

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-20:52
Eye on the gold ones now 😂 We agree the GO is the purists choice with no date 👍🏻 Thanks for weighing in mon ami

Pleasure, mon ami!

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-20:54
Why not this one? ...  

Ooooh that’s a nice one

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:18
I hadn’t thought of. I watched a review and enjoyed it, alas the price looks to be a bit prohibitive for this time around !

Ok, I’ll check it out

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:23
Thanks! 👍🏻

Enablers …

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:31
What are friends for 😂 Cheers my friend!

1-0 GO then

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:28

Another good choice

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : September 5th, 2024-00:17

I knew you would say that.

 
 By: amanico : September 6th, 2024-20:17

You think well. ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 6th, 2024-21:57

The GO dial is very charming indeed

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : September 5th, 2024-00:16

100%

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:17

Too kind, mon canard. :))))

 
 By: amanico : September 6th, 2024-15:04

Oui oui! Quack quack!

 
 By: patrick_y : September 9th, 2024-13:32

Hahahaha! ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 9th, 2024-14:19

In this case, for me, the JLC in spite of things like the date.

 
 By: BigFatPauli : September 4th, 2024-20:30
The dauphine hands and simple makers along with the better balanced case dimensions win me over.

The hands and markers are killer on the JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-20:41
Both watches are 39 x 9.5 mm

1-1 tie

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:29

In time

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:02
Hoping you are correct! Thanks

Of course

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:34
But we can enjoy discussing and I can procrastinate putting off the decision a little longer 😉

Can't decide!

 
 By: Dimardi : September 4th, 2024-20:52
I keep going back and forth between the two...initially I was leaning JLC by the slightest of margins due to it's, in my opinion, higher versatility quotient (if that's a thing..lol). But then I look at the GO and it's so playful and seems like you could ... 

Swiss Neutrality? ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-20:57

I see what you did there! 😎

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:02

Hahaha!!! ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-21:12

I'm good with that! LOL

 
 By: Dimardi : September 4th, 2024-21:12

I see! ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-21:13

See, it’s much more difficult than I originally thought!

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:01
The tiebreaker for me may be the JLC’s mesmerizing silver sunburst dial. That is really something else. The cherry on top is the blued seconds hand. The GO has a similar color silver dial, but it is fine grain, not sunburst. On the other hand, the GO is s... 

Yes, most probably. ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-21:25

I can’t argue the JLC is the more versatile of the two

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:03
Thanks for your insight!

1-2 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:29

JLC for me.

 
 By: bruckner4 : September 4th, 2024-21:03
Dauphine hands, dart indexes, numbers font -- all winners. The GO has its charms, though...

🍻

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:25

1-3 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:30

As it should be ! 😎

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-16:14
Thanks for participating

I'll live with the date on the JLC

 
 By: Thomas_3 : September 4th, 2024-21:05
because I really prefer the applied numerals. Absolutely nothing wrong with the other, it is beautiful but I'll take the applied numerals.

👍🏻

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:25

Without the date, I agree.

 
 By: amanico : September 4th, 2024-21:30

Thanks for your reply

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-21:32

1-5 JLC by a landslide so far!

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:31

1-4 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:30

Nice suggestion

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-22:45
However I’m leaning towards the MC if I go JLC, its aesthetics are more pleasing to me . Thank you

Again, now we're talking 😀

 
 By: eklektik : September 6th, 2024-21:46

I have a thing...

 
 By: HighEndOne : September 4th, 2024-22:23
I never have cared for the numerals shown on watch dials. The 12 - 3 - 6 - 9 - thing never really appeals to me. In this case I will have to abstain. Both have charms. GO has the heritage of German excellence. JLC is the master of movements, IMHO. Flip a ... 

Thanks for weighing in

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 4th, 2024-22:48
Wish we shared the same problem. My finances would likely be in better shape. I love the numerals on dials, hence my weighing this decision and also loving other dial designs such as Omega Seamaster 300 Heritage, and more recently , the GO SeaQ 39.5 mm, w... 

Interesting set of remarks — both are beautiful — were it not for the date, easily the JLC.

 
 By: orahu : September 4th, 2024-23:37
The GO doesn’t sing to me — so, I would be inclined to think about other options. I have no idea about the price point for either of these watches. But, Moser, Rolex 1908, the new VC 56 in rose gold?

Thanks for your response

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:10
And suggestions. Pre-owned, these 2 I’m considering are priced much lower, so I’m afraid those alternatives are going to be prohibitive for me

Interesting as both are modern takes on 50-60 year old dress watch design. At first I saw an easy decision for the GO. Not a fan of 3 o'clock dates that disrupt dial aesthetics and balance and

 
 By: InDebtButOnTime : September 4th, 2024-23:52
I like the style of the numerals on the GO. But the more I looked the more I realized this is a tighter race than originally thought. The JLC is super clean and snappy looking. Also its hands are uniquely cool and fun. Both brands have earned high respect... 

Great analysis

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:16
Thank you for your comments. At first it was an easy GO decision for me , but then this damn JLC creeps in! Yes, I can afford one (both are priced about the same). So yes, agreed, I should make no sacrifice . It’s just a matter of choosing now !

2-5 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:32

It so perfect and charming

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:18
Then surrounded by the soft glow of gold=1 irresistible package !

Totally

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : September 5th, 2024-10:51

3-5 still JLC!

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-01:32

I love JLC

 
 By: RogerParadise : September 5th, 2024-01:52
but in this price range, GO would be the better choice, JLC is outstanding in higer ranges

4-5 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-02:04
Interesting insight, thanks !

The GO wins for me.

 
 By: Moka-Tiger (Ron) : September 5th, 2024-02:23
No date and a very unusual, sleek and a sense of uniqueness because of the number font. The JLC, while nice, looks like many others. (Think Calatrava).

ALL TIED UP!

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:00
Thanks

I'd opt for the JLC

 
 By: vitalsigns : September 5th, 2024-04:28
Perfect proportions and style I'm not a fan of the 60s GO style

5-6 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:00

5-7 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:01

JLC for me

 
 By: jml_watches : September 5th, 2024-08:14
Hi I prefer the hands & dial layout. The date doesn't bother me. Though it might be a different story after I've tried them on. We e all looked at watches & thought they looked great - but after trying them on it's an almost instant no. Enjoy making the d... 

5-8 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:01
Isn’t that the truth!

The JLC for me as well

 
 By: andrea~ : September 5th, 2024-08:39

5-9 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:01

Between these two the GO 👌🏻

 
 By: KMII : September 5th, 2024-08:40
Nothing wrong with the JLC but between these two the GO simply has the more unique, distinctive design 😊👍🏻

Well said my friend

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : September 5th, 2024-10:51

6-9 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-12:02
👍🏻

JLC

 
 By: smironov : September 5th, 2024-15:44
I like the font and hands on JLC better. Enough to compensate for the date cut out.

6-10 JLC

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-16:17
Looks like the community has spoken. With some members forced to abstain because it was too close to call. Welcome to my world 😂 Thanks everyone for weighing in!

If I was buying for myself I’d go with

 
 By: Derreck : September 5th, 2024-17:06
the JLC. It’s fresher and sportier, I can see myself wearing it even with a jeans and t shirt, GO on the other hand even though beautiful to look at, on the wrist to me would seem a bit too classical and outdated and I wouldn’t wear it. Just my personal o... 

Agree JLC is the sportier of the 2

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 5th, 2024-18:01
That probably suits me best since my lifestyle rarely calls for a dress watch. Although I’m betting either can be dressed down with the right strap. Thanks for your comment

Glashutte deifnitely, and I am a massive JLC Fan.

 
 By: eklektik : September 6th, 2024-19:37
The basic JLC is rather plain and does not bring any excitement for me. This glashutte however with its special font and dial is a nice tribute to historical timepieces. Much more interesting in my eyes. You need to go Ultra Thin or to the models with com... 

I don’t know yet 😂

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : September 6th, 2024-20:27
Thanks for your reply!

JLC even if I’m not a fan of the date window location..

 
 By: Echi : September 7th, 2024-05:10
While I like the GO, I think I’ll tire of that look at some point.

My vote is for the Glashutte, with one caveat.

 
 By: Thaddeus : September 9th, 2024-16:58
I own the 2018 green annual edition with the textured dial, and I adore it. Love that Tiki-lounge font of the numerals! However, I suggest seeing and handling the GO in real life before coming to a decision. At the very least, check out some youtube video...