Baron - Mr Red
14613
It is a very good question
I own a 1680 Red Sub and am also considering a JLC geographic. Both are beautiful watches. WHichever you choose will be a good decision. However, in my mind there is a clear winner....
The Red Sub is an iconic watch. It will always be an iconic watch. Amongst Rolex afficionados, teh Red Sub is speciall. Regardless of how beautiful the JLC is (and it really is), it is not an iconic watch either for JLC or generally. The Red Sub will always have more of that va va voom.
So, for me, the Red Sub wins.