I like Tudor. I own two Tudors. But...

Nov 10, 2019,15:58 PM
 

350,000 CHF for the ceramic black bay is insane.



Absolutely bonkers. Yes, it is for charity. So how much can one claim as a tax deduction? One must subtract the "retail" value of the item obtained in charity auctions. What is the retail value of this watch? If the normal black bay on strap with same movement costs US$3400.00, how much of a premium does one add for ceramic case with sapphire back? I'll be generous and give a new retail value of $5000.00.

At today's exchange rate, CHF350,000=US$350,945.00!

Do you think the winning bidder is claiming about a US$346,000.00 tax deduction? Do tax deductions work the same way in Europe?

Did the winning bidder do well with his money? I think not, and I highly doubt anyone else would give him/her CHF350,000 to break even should he/she ever decide to sell it...
But maybe it is a better deal than paying 31 million CHF for that Patek monstrosity smile


More posts: Black BayTudorTudor Heritage

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Thank you for having writing down my question.

 
 By: Tyo : November 10th, 2019-16:05
But sorry I don’t have the output. Some here may. But I think tax reductions depend on where you live. I don’t know if one can claim for one. Anyway, the prices fetched for most of the pieces are just insanes. But this is for a good cause so why not?

That’s true. [nt]

 
 By: Tyo : November 10th, 2019-16:27

The simple answer is ....

 
 By: Cpt Scarlet : November 11th, 2019-00:40
It’s gift for charity.

Tudor never makes a piece unique

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : November 11th, 2019-00:43
If Rolex would make one unique watch for the same auction .. a unique non complicated watch, it would fetch at least 10 times more So it's extremely rare to be able to buy such a piece. It's clear Tudor is a fantastic brand and more and more people are co... 

It is the second Black Bay Only Watch, isn't it?

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2019-01:08
The first was top! ...  

yes

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : November 11th, 2019-03:03
there was also the left-handed bronze But it's each time a different watch so still unique. I don't think they made other than these for only watch

As someone said (better, sang)...

 
 By: Mary Anny : November 11th, 2019-01:39
It's a coat you wear twice a year!

There was a post somewhere two years ago (at the time of the last Only Watch) about the tax deductibility on winning bids given it’s a charity.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : November 11th, 2019-04:14
I think from a US tax payer perspective unless the charity is registered in the US it’s not deductible. So an contribution to an overseas charity is not usually deductible. There might be some exceptions based on tax treaties the US has with various count... 

yes gronefeld buyer is in NYC....

 
 By: keks : November 11th, 2019-09:31
one of the more reasonably priced pieces in that auction in my opinion...

It's too much for a Tudor. But whoever won. Congratulations, you have a kind heart.

 
 By: geross : November 11th, 2019-04:24
Best wishes, keep well and enjoy your new Tudor. Cheers 🥃 Geross

what is paid at a charity auction...

 
 By: keks : November 11th, 2019-09:33
is generally nothing to do with value of underlying item... I have been to plenty of silly charity auctions... one where buyer bought a pair of shoe laces for usd 25k... what matters is that the money goes towards a good cause. tax write-off or not does n... 

When people start paying for rotting watches,

 
 By: nwk00 : November 12th, 2019-07:09
you know the value of watches to people is really quite subjective.