vic93
61
ulimate choice: 5016 or 5078+5004?
Love to own a Patek minute repeater as an ultimate collection. To spend similar level of the money will you decide to have:
1) only one ultimate watch 5016P/R, or
2) a few combinations: 5078P+5004P or even 5078P+5970P+5070P
and what reason is your choice? thanks for your opinions for my reference.
Available on the marketplace
2,850 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
Complications
Explore Patek Philippe's 2011 minute repeater novelties, references 5216 and 7000, showcasing high complications and design details.
14 replies158947 views
New Release
Discover Patek Philippe's 2017 Baselworld novelties: 24 new references blending tradition with modern design, including the 5320G, 5168G, and 5372P.
124 replies80365 views
New Release
Explore the Patek Philippe Ref. 5208 triple complication from Baselworld 2011, featuring a minute repeater, monopusher chronograph, and instantaneous perpetual calendar.
34 replies66555 views
Complications
Discover the Patek Philippe 5207, a Grand Complication featuring a tourbillon, minute repeater, and instantaneous perpetual calendar. In-depth review and collector insights.
62 replies41619 views
Collection
Explore Patek Philippe perpetual calendar chronographs. Collectors share why they chose their 3970, 5970, and 5270 models, offering insights on design, value, and personal preference.
77 replies37661 views
Complications
Explore Patek Philippe's striking watches, including the 5078P, 5033P, and Sky Moon Tourbillon. Discover collector favorites and the artistry of minute repeaters.
24 replies23566 views
ulimate choice: 5016 or 5078+5004?
Love to own a Patek minute repeater as an ultimate collection. To spend similar level of the money will you decide to have: 1) only one ultimate watch 5016P/R, or 2) a few combinations: 5078P+5004P or even 5078P+5970P+5070P and what reason is your choice?...
that's easy
The 5016 has perpetual calendar, tourbillon, and minute repeater. Tourbillon doesn't do anything useful in a wristwatch (only pocket watches benefit when vertical in vest pocket as worn in the 1800s). Minute repeater hasn't been useful since electricity w...
chronographs, chronographs and chronographs
Imo a minute repeater is not the most important in a watch collection. It's personal taste ofcourse but I would not buy a minute repeater or tourbillon. I like those watches and I appreciate the complication but it's not for me. If I had the money I would...
It's always good to have a favorite complication.
My personal favorite complications are perpetual calendars and striking watches. Yours are chronographs. Strong preferences are called for when it comes to collecting watches. And a fine company to purchase chronographs from indeed! I know the 5959 is too...
indeed
forgot it ;-) but when you have the money a 5959 is also a must have After the chronographs my 'wishlist' would probably have some Patek worldtimers ranked pretty high
If according to the earlier expert comments ...
You would be better off NOT buying at all. I certainly dont remember when was the last time i actually used my chronograph 5970. But then i realise, i am buying because i like the brand, i like collecting because it gives me a bundle of joy. So, regaredle...
101% agree with tic-toc...
Frankly, nowadays all these functions are really not useful; if you guys think in this way... say; Do U really need a moon phase? When will you use your split second chronograph when all the games are recorded by eletronic watches? what you buy is the cra...
I agree with Larry.......................
The 5016 would also be my choice, its so beautiful.
I agree with the others here
The Chrono is a more useful function. I have actually been using it a bit more lately, timing things. More importantly though, the 5016 specificzlly is a very thick watch, almost not wearable in the 5002 sense. It's more of a showpiece (a hamburger lump o...
I faced the same dilemma...
...but the fascination of pushing buttons won me over, so went for 5078P plus 5004P. Both totally different, yet each wonderful. Still....5016P with breguets and a salmon dial....mmmmm....!!!! In any event, you can't go wrong with these choices - enjoy!! ...
I think you are referring to the 5101P
I've never seen a 5016 with a salmon dial. I think you made a great choice. The 5078 and 5004 are very important watches to own. If you really like Breguet numerals, then maybe a 3939H is for you! I personally really like the 5078 myself; I think I like i...
Actually no..
..I have a 5101P already....very nice watch. I have seen only pictures of a salmon dial/breguets 5016P...loved it. The 5004P is a great watch - one of my favourites...sent it to the factory for the upgrade on the chrono to make it reliable, as mine is one...
Thanks for the information.
Did some research and I did find the salmon dialed Patek 5016, you learn something new every day. What was the original problem with the 5004? I heard some weren't working properly, but I wasn't aware of the actual problem.
Alignment in the chrono mechanism...
...affected the early production...chrono hands stuck during operation. Had it happen to mine. No probs since the service and replacement/update of the centre bridge. Tim
I really like the 5074
Personally, I prefer the 5074 over the 5016. I just really love the bezel on the 5074 (which is the same bezel as the 5070). My ultimate collection would be a 5074, 5078, 5070, and 5970. This is of course a dream. The 5004 is a great watch and Split-secon...
great advices.....
This topic does not have a easy answer.....one ultimate vs few good collections. I agree that most of the functions are not very useful in this century. However, I do have a passion on minute repeater....it "talks" to you instead of you read it......plus ...
After very very careful consideration I ordered the 5016P
Got approval from PP after much letter writing, and paid a substantial deposit to my PP AD to secure the order for my GBP£318,100 watch-purchase (!). Then, later that year, received back-word that Philip Stern was cancelling my order because he disco...