jlc.thomsen
1721
Torn between 2 Perpetual options 5320G vs 5140p 017 (grey)-what would you do?
I’m finally getting some AD love after years of collecting and being listed.
Next step with PP is to get one of the Patek complication par excellence, the perpetual calendar.(as I already have the chrono 5170p and the world time 5110p. )
I do like both options a lot for different reasons leaning towards the more traditional 5140p. I also kind of like to stay ultra-thin and platinum in this PP trilogy.
Since it’s a Patek the next generation has been asked for advise and prefers the more contemporary 5320g (with a lot of vintage elements that is).
Note: They are offered at approximately the same price at the AD.
What would you do?
Photo credit: A collected man
Photo credits Watchbox Global on twitter
New Release
Discover Patek Philippe's 2017 Baselworld novelties: 24 new references blending tradition with modern design, including the 5320G, 5168G, and 5372P.
124 replies80365 views
New Release
Explore Patek Philippe's 2022 Watches and Wonders novelties, including the Calatrava Ref. 5226, Ref. 5326 Annual Calendar, and updated World Time models, with live photos and expert insights.
14 replies4888 views
Complications
Explore 39 Patek Philippe Minute Repeater models, from historical pieces like the Henry Graves Jr. to modern references. A deep dive into chiming complications.
54 replies13634 views
Collection
Explore the Patek Philippe World Time collection, including WT and Chronograph models. Collectors share their 5110P, 5130G, 5230G, and more.
92 replies32149 views
Collection
Patek_3944 considers compressing his Patek Philippe collection (5035J, 5110J, 5196J, 5127G, 5296G) to acquire a higher-level piece like a 5170. Explore community advice on collection strategy and prestige.
34 replies12887 views
Torn between 2 Perpetual options 5320G vs 5140p 017 (grey)-what would you do?
I’m finally getting some AD love after years of collecting and being listed. Next step with PP is to get one of the Patek complication par excellence, the perpetual calendar.(as I already have the chrono 5170p and the world time 5110p. ) I do like both op...
I this isn't the "right answer"...
But I really love the dial colour on the 5140p oh so much that I am willing to overlook the odd printing choice so that's the way I personally would go.
Thanks man.
Yes I have seen there are some font issues that have been discussed. Nothing that bothers me at all when seeing the watch in the metal. And yes the dial is truly spectacular charcoal. And still super subtle.
Thanks naut- 2-0 for the 5140p charcoal.
What bothers you with the 5320 if anything? For me it’s the to many winks to the past. What I like is the simplicity and readability and the complex case.
I know! I love it. Could really be the dark horse here.
But if I asked you about the 2 others and you HAD to choose?
Not an easy call and you'll end up with a pretty gorgeous watch either way, but given your description I'd probably suggest the 5140P....
First, its really remarkable degree of elegance (even though I admit I like the 5320 dial better -- one of the most original among all Patek PCs! ;-) Second, the 5140P has a modern yet very classical design, which will forever be good looking...your next ...
Pleasure :-) On a curious (and unrelated) technical note, I was trying to figure out how you could display the 5320 picture on the Patek page and the 5140 on the Front page...(normally this isn't possible).
It shows me you only selected the 5320 picture, so if you want it also on the Front page let me know....Otherwise let's leave it like this, which looks cool (the system might automatically change the front picture at some point anyway ;-) Cheers.
Hi Fabr it does give some irregularities when posting from the app
Only one picture made it through and then I edited and added the next one.
For me, te 5230 because it is less busy with the apertures and
no compressed numerals. Personally I always prefer a cleaner dial with apertures.
I am with you.
But PP are the best to make a cluttered dial look like it makes sense.
Yeah. You’re right. Not the worst problem to have.
Thanks for super valuable feed back everyone.
Oui j’espère bientôt.
We just sat up a training centre in Paris-need to inaugurate soon.
5320
Here's why: it's got its own thing going. And it looks great! I love its sporty/vintagey/casual vibe and have been surprised it hasn't been a huge screaming sells-over-retail success. The 5140 is great, too... but, to my eye, it's a slightly lesser versio...
I agree the dial painted colour makes it a bit cartoonish. Also in real life. What happened to Grand Feu enamel?
Will just have to live with that I think. Not the worse after all. I think it will age with grace with the blackened gold indices.
For me the 5320G without hesitation.
It has it’s own style and stands alone with it’s design. I tried it about two years ago. I felt that it was very versatile and had a great wrist presence, too. And then there is your personal next generation… 😊 Best Thomas ...
If you are able, try them on first
They fit very differently. 37 vs 40. Long straight lugs vs downward sloping short lugs. The 5320 is a cream color that borders on yellow, just fyi. Here are photos to help. Sorry the 5140 is rose and not platinum, but hopefully this gives you an idea of t...
Thank you Houston-
Yes I did try them on and live both for different reasons. What is your choice?
5320 would get my vote
Like baufoam says below, I think the 3940 does “classic Patek” better than the 5140
I get it Houston! Thanks a lot!
The plan is taking form thanks to this great forum!🚀😍
Go Grey...
By that I mean gray market unless your dealer is giving you a substantial discount sorry to keep it real but that would be my first decision my second one would be the platinum choice I have seen both in the wild and unfortunately the 5320 does not have a...
🙏 well thank you kindly for considering my opinion, but it is your emotion you need to listen to! I got it wrong so many time for my own collection, in the end others opinion don’t matter that much …
If your own emotion are not into a certain piece … for me anyway!
Completely agree here.
But since I am also listening to my family’s emotion here in this particular case, your opinion and the forum are really important players. 🙏amazing
The 5320g.
Not a doubt in my mind. I have been wearing the 5320 as a daily watch for over two years and I like it more today than I did when I bought it ( new) from an AD in Beverly Hills. I paid full retail for the watch and have not regretted that decision. As a P...
Nice point with the 3940 and your 5320 history.
Really good advice. Thanks. Conclusion: get the 5320 now and chase a first edition 3940 next year maybe😀
Check and thanks. I have no issues with smaller cases.
Sizes have become a minor issue as you mature as a collector I think. As long as the sum of elements add up so to speak.
Most importantly
which watch fits your wrist better? The 5320 is 40mm while the 5140 is 37mm in diameter, quite a difference. How important is legibility to you because the 5320 is a lot more legible compared to the dial of the 5140. For me I would go for the 5140 as I ha...
Thanks Sham-thank you WPS
They both fit well and I do like the ultra thin understated feel of the 5140p I want to thank the forum for the invaluable input!!!
Yeah really great quality feed back all over-what a true collector's forum! I did learn a lot by turning it around here-
Still not sure what we're going to end up with though 😂 In Denmark we say that you are now confused, but on a higher level.
Putting all the comments you received together, I think the most compelling argument that can be made is one in favor of....buying both references! ;-))
Seriously, these are two terrific Patek grand complications, and being confused after receiving so much feedback and information just confirms that whichever you end up choosing, you'll have made an informed decision that you cannot regret! ;-) Keep us po...
5140p subdials are too congested for my taste. I prefer the 5320g layout, but you have to love that dial color, I think.
I know the question is about perpetual calendars, but have you consider an annual calendar? This is a complication strongly associated with Patek, and there are additional options in terms of layout and color.
I had the same about the 5140p and the congestion.
But seeing it live is just very different and it seemed very elegant and not disturbing. And yes this probably might affect legibility.
I’m sure it will. I saw the blue -001 and the slate grey -017
Blue is great and a bit too shiny. Plus we’ve seen so much blue lately. The grey just emits class and refinement and matches the pt well.
Both are great. That particular 5140p is a real treasure, and the look of white figures on a gray dial is just fantastic. That said...
The 5320 is crossover casual watch that you can easily wear with dressy or casual attire. For a perpetual calendar, that's a real strength. I really enjoy watches you can wear with just about anything--makes for many more opportunities to enjoy the watch....
always a personal decision
and these two watches, besides being a perpetual calendar are so different! My vote is 5320G, it's actually so different and unique in today's collection yet is historical.
it's actually, in my opinion, lot better in person than in pictures
it feels more complete and just right
I love the unique look of the 5320. It’s a heavy hitter because it’s perpetual yet it It has a casual look.
I love that. It’s a stealthy watch. It’s very legible which is an added luck in your decision. You’re in a great position.
Yes. Definitely legible.
Sometimes I think the Patek PCs have a legibility problem. The 5320 does not. It’s high kn my list for my next Patek.
PP5140P
I see you are fine with either dial besides both models are about the same price range. Therefore, I think the PP5140P would be it. Firstly, the white prints over grey background makes the dial more interesting and less bothered by the 'irregular' fonts, ...
Thanks for your valuable input-
Yes given that the price of the 5140p was the same due to not being in the catalog anymore is certainly an argument-among all the other horological of course-
I’ve seen the 5140P-17 in the metal…
and my major impression was that it was hard to see the hands against the dial; serious legibility issue there. That said, many people don’t care as much about legibility as I do.
I get it. I think it’s a balance for PP to sacrifice some legibility to make it look more simple.
I was really surprise in how uncluttered the traditional style perpetual layout looked on the 5140. Extreme balance is also a way to deal with clutter and I wonder today if the 3940 doesn’t do that job par excellence. Photo credit private seller on Chrono...
Agreed, but just to be clear
I wasn’t talking about the legibility of the subdials. I was taking about the legibility of the silver-colored hour and minute hands against the gray dial. I found it hard to tell the time without moving my wrist around to make the hands catch the light. ...
Ok, bear with me…
I would get the 5320, and then stretch your budget and get a 5146p also. They are not at crazy prices, and I love mine - the grey dial is super and (to pick up the point on legibility) the AC dial is slightly less cluttered than the 5140 and there is (ele...
Thanks man-I'm thinking if this whole casual vs formal is dissolving and forming new standards for how you can move around with different styles and mix them-
The bank's board room to be the last place where this will happen of course-
I understand that you, who already own a chronograph and world time, will want a perpetual calendar next time.
properties even in the same perpetual calendar category. As many have already said, 5320 and 5140 have quite different. The 5320 is a rare model with an easy-to-read calendar window as a perpetual calendar and, after all, an independent second hand. I cur...
Since 5140-017 is gray, you may think that the time is a little easier to read than the black 5140-013.
However, although it tends to be a little in the dark, on the contrary, in a slightly bright place, he tends to shine more brightly in gray and bury the outline of the needle. Still, of course, both have a brilliant presence that the 3940 does not have. ...
Thanks. Yes the reflections seem to take care of the legibility on the modern pateks.
You just twist the watch a little and get good readability.
Yeah it’s beautiful.
I think the play and complexity of the stepped lugs with the case and straight cut sapphire is something that will fascinate most fans. I think Tim from Watchbox went down with this one😂in one of his presentations. Nice
I have to say that both PC actually are great in…
…different ways. The 5320 has the best legibility and fits for every occasion. The 5140p has the best and most elegant grey sunburst dial ever. Its funny to read this post, because the 5320 was my first PC and I later added the 5140P. Congratulations for ...
Thanks Erg! So you have them both? Amazing
And if you HAD to choose just one and they were priced the same?
I'd prefer the 5320, if I had to choose one. It's the best perpetual calender for the money.
But also keep in mind that the 5140P is not produced anymore.
5320
As much as the two markers at 5 and 7 annoy me (IMO completely unnecessary to have them), the rest of the watch is really nice and very legible.
Load More Comments >>