sam1234
358
Is that a fact or an opinion?
Because "if you express it as an opinion - in your opinion, "just about everything here is opinion", that's a fair opinion and very polite. But a blanket statement, presented as absolute fact - "just about everything here is opinion" - that is likely to be viewed as impolite."
*Jeez, by the thinness of some skins I'm guessing it must be the first time on the internet.*
"In my opinion" I happen to agree with mdg's comments. 40mm+ watches do look silly on a lot of people, and we're just too polite to say. In fairness, and also in my opinion, watches 33mm and under can look silly on a lot of people, and we're just too polite to say. I'd still choose too small over too big any day. Most will notice if something is overpowering your wrist while the subtlety (and dare I say elegance?) of small watch will more likely go unnoticed.
All of course, "in my opinion".
Shocked that the 33mm Patek 3919J actually fits my 7” wrist
A friend had his 3919J on today in 33mm and he let me try it on. I was quite surprised it actually fit my wrist. I was concerned and really put off by the 33mm and avoided purchasing one online sight unseen, but now that I tried it, I may buy this or even...
That is perfect!
I’ve been thinking lately that if one must wear anachronistic wrist wear, why not do so in anachronistic sizes. Seriously, this looks fantastic on your wrist!
If not a disease...
... you should create a development thread on all Pateks you bought and sold in the past 12-18 months as a warning to others... LOL... The 3919 looks good on you in terms of size. You gotta love the hobnail bezel and the Roman numerals though.
7.25" wrist here...
and watches like that look just fine on me. A lot of the larger watches (40mm+) look silly on a lot of people but it isn't polite to say so. Here's a little secret: there are a lot of stunning watches made in the last 40 years that are less than 38mm and ...
I think it’s all about the way you say it
If you express it as an opinion - in your opinion, watches over 40mm are not an attractive aesthetic on most people. That’s a fair opinion and very polite. But a blanket statement, presented as absolute fact - watches over 40mm look silly on people - that...
Is that a fact or an opinion?
Because "if you express it as an opinion - in your opinion, "just about everything here is opinion", that's a fair opinion and very polite. But a blanket statement, presented as absolute fact - "just about everything here is opinion" - that is likely to b...
I can see my comment made an impression on you
MDG made a comment that saying something was impolite. My follow-up point was simply the observation that whether someone finds something impolite or not is often more a function of how something is said, not what it is that is said. That is all. No thin ...
My apologies NickO.
I seem to have misinterpreted your remark. In the past we've had situations on this forum where any comment suggesting a contrary viewpoint, regardless of how civil in tone, was subject to rebuke. I've seen it often suggested that every non factual statem...
Agree.
The 3919 is a classic and looks terrific, and it's actually better proportioned for the movement that the 5119. Both references are extremely elegant though.
That looks great on your wrist
If you like that size, consider the 5026 as well. 33mm with the classic Calatrava case, but automatic with the 240 movement.
Size actually matters less when one tries a smaller watch
Nothing wrong with a 33mm watch on a 7 inch wrist. Afterall, the 3919 was in production for a long time until 2007 and wrist sizes have not suddenly grown since then even though fashion preferences have.. I have a 6.75 inch wrist and notice how the 31mm 3...
Thank you for saying so!
It was discontinued in 1998 but I was fortunate to come across it 2 years ago when it was a special order for a client who cancelled their order.
Good to see that you are passionate about Patek overall !!
Will be interesting to see what you will end up buying and selling.
The 5119 is also a top watch
Compared to this 3919 Uhr 5119 looks "modern", due to ist 36 mm.
I really
like a sub-40mm Patek Philippe Dress Watch. I don’t unilaterally dislike all “Modern” Patek, but those smaller, subtle timepieces really speak to me. My wrist is 7 3/4” around and I have no problem wearing a 36mm Patek. Thanks for sharing the 3919. That’s...
Watches were this size for years
because it is the perfect size. Many people nowadays may prefer 40-42mm dress watches but to me they are really way too big for most people.
Fitting
You are right, one has to try out before jumping to a conclusion. This watch fits and looks good on your wrist.
