Comments:
I have had the pleasure handling both pieces and listen to them. Sadly a few years apart so I couldn’t say which one sounds best. And however interesting and impressive the AP is, that 5078 made me fall in love after a few minutes on the wrist. And I’m not even really into classical watches.
Enjoy both!!
Chime off...I am fortunate enough to have these 2 references. Which do you think sound better. I feel that the PP has better rhythm and musicality but the AP has its own charm. Which do you prefer?
Patek
The AP regulator looks very interesting, but I like the cleaner look of the Patek, which I had the privilege to handle and listen to last summer (thank you Mr Vergotti).
In white metal, I would go for the AP. The regulator plus the jumping hour and the minute repeater... Great combination. BUT I would first go for the one which better sounds. And here,
I don't know...
I tried to load a video of both chimes..but was not able to do so.. [nt]
No message body
While I’ve never listened to that specific Patek, the sound of their MR is IMO just unbeatable.
And aesthetically, to me it also wins over your other AP. In any event, those are both truly spectacular pieces, so congrats regardless of any rankings!😍😉
Patek 5078
It's a wonderful reference with no extra complications (which can obscure the sound). Simple understated case and white enamel dial that doesn't give a hint of what's underneath. It embodies all that Patek is!
I actually like the Roman Numeral version of the 5078P a little better
It's a true classic. To me Peter Speake-Marin simply copied this classic layout that had been employed long before his wrist watches even existed. The beauty of the 5078P is that it doesn't seem like anything special until you really start to inspect it ... and then it's VERY SPECIAL!
I don’t know about the sound.
But that PP is my absolute grail. My exit watch. So, no contest for me.
Is that a 5078? The hands and numerals don't look like a 5078
Did you have the dial changed?
I thought the 5078 either came with roman numerals, or with silver breguet and breguet hands?
Your version looks amazing!
never listened to any of those
So I cannot judge the sound. On the other side the PP is "simply" a beautiful and elegant watch with a great complication. The AP adds some elements to the design and to the movement that make it more peculiar. I would go for the AP.
Patek Philippe chimes the best imho. But that AP is also stunning with the jumping hr function [nt]
No message body
Both sound so good...
I like the AP movement more. I can't say why, I just do.
I like the case of the Patek Philippe more. It's thinner too. And automatic.
Both sound great.
And nobody cares which one I prefer.
Oh wow! You have got some heavy metal there! 👍🏻👍🏻
I have had the pleasure handling both pieces and listen to them. Sadly a few years apart so I couldn’t say which one sounds best. And however interesting and impressive the AP is, that 5078 made me fall in love after a few minutes on the wrist. And I’m not even really into classical watches.
Enjoy both!!
Thanks for comments all...
I personally like the PP better - both for its aesthetics and acoustically. Unfortunately I couldn’t load a video of both watches but on the AP, you can hear the regulator whirling when the repeater is engaged. This bothers me quite a lot and is an issue that they have rectified with their new current repeaters. The PP is almost deadly quiet.
PP for me.
No matter how the sound quality would be (I never had the chance to prove it personally) for me this watch is the most
beautiful PP ever.
Best, Thomas
beautiful PP ever.
Best, Thomas
Amazing pieces
Honestly, those are two very fine watches, I can’t comment on the sound but well done acquiring them and thanks for sharing.
Both are damn good ones to have & congrats for that...
AP would be my choice bcos sometime a quirky one works better just to say ‘don’t be too serious in life’
Best
Mahesh
Best
Mahesh