Horological Meandering

1440
477

• Show profile
• Show other posts

Sweeping generalization - in good fun

Having sampled many an Islay malt, I disagree with your assertion on 2 levels.  First, as others have pointed out, the intensity that Laphroaig provides is what I like most about it.  Peat and iodine in spades, and the greater the flavour the better for me.  I will admit that not everyone is able to appreciate this intensity in the same way....I would argue that one is not superior to the other, but simply different. 

But a larger question - just exactly which Laphroaig are we comparing to the Lagavulin, and perhaps considering inferior?  Just to put some perspective on the question, and address a generalization....I can assure you the Lagavulin you hold in such high praise is no where as smooth as this particular Laphroaig is - not by a long "shot."  ;-)

FYI - watch included in photo to keep relevant to the forum.  ;-)

The Laphroaig (10 Y.O.) is not for the faint of heart, that is for certain, but to imply it is in some way inferior is certainly off the mark in my opinion.  With warmest regards, a "Friend of Laphroaig."   

Cheers, Al

PS - yes, yet another box to deal with after this bottle is gone.....