Sandgroper
3262
Clarification....
Gary to my question, does the watch comes with box and papers as mentioned in the ad, you replied : "The watch does come with box/open papers but it is not the original huge box with nine compartments. It is a small box as I believe the watch was bought from antiquorum a few years ago by the previous owner when I got it off his hands"
So, from this reply I obviously new that the huge box was not included but you DO STIPULATE OPEN PAPERS, which according to all the participants in this link and commun sense, means warranty, certificate, instruction manual etc. open meaning there is no name of purchaser and no date of purchase, right. Now the open papers I have received are, a small catalogue of the collection 1998/99, so before the watch I purchased from you was commercialised, the watch is not in that catalogue and a instruction manual from the same periode which therefore is useless for me as it does not relate to the watch in question. You also wrote "Open papers mean just that - open. This is a very commun term used widely in the watch community. Your interpretation is obviously not the same. There is no such thing as closed papers. I have been trading online for over a decade".
As said, the "open papers" I have received have NOTHING to do with the watch I have purchased from you and I find it very odd that you can still justify this as been commun practice in the watch community. So one would purchase a Minute Repeater and receive a chronograph, that's commun practice in the watch community!! Odd, really odd!!
Francois
Locked
login to reply
Naive/stupid question!!!
Good day all. When one sees a watch for sale "complete, with boxes and papers" what can one expect? Box and papers related to the watch in question? Box related to "a" watch? Papers related to a catalogue of watches of which none are related to the watch ...
Box and papers
Francois, From any reputable or honest seller, "box and papers" with no additional qualifiers means the original box for the watch and the warranty papers, instruction booklet, or any other printed matter shipped with the watch. Sometimes the seller will ...
Thank you Park...
This is exactly what I thought, one should reasonably expect from such statement. Now and I apologise for been a pain, what does "open papers" mean? I will detail my experience a little later. Thank you again and kind regards. Francois
Correct. All which came with the watch when it was at the AD.
Which also means the goodies, when thre are some, like a book, a loupe, gloves, and so on... But the box, the outer box, the warranty papers, the certificate ( if there is any ), this is a minimum. Best, Nicolas
Thank you Nicolas....
..it seems like common sense, isn't it? So, to recap. and if I understand well, "papers or open papers" mean, owner's manual for the actual watch been sold! Warranty and certificate (papers showing the watch caliber, metal, serial number etc.!?) for the a...
OK then!.....here I come with my little story....
recently I saw a watch for sale on the Purist Collectors Market, the watch was been sold by a Purist. There were 2 pictures of the watch and it was stipulated "near mint condition with boxes/papers. I contacted the vendor to ask for the best price, and th...
Totally agree with you. That is not very fair from your seller.
But at least you have a chance to have the manual instructions for your dish machine! :) Your watch is really splendid, and I am sure you will enjoy it, but your seller should have presented things in a fairer way, for sure. Best, my friend. Nicolas.
Merci Nicolas....
I think that any seller should just present the facts..as they are! End of story. Soon one will have to contact a lawyer to draw-up some kind of document which will stipulate that such "word" in this "context" means "this" but if used when the wind is blo...
Rarely will you ever see all the goodies...
...and things like loupes and gloves as gifts really only came into being in recent years. Others have given you correct advice. Box and instruction/warranty papers obviously need to be the ones that came with the watch. Some, but not all, will give you a...
Sad to hear of your experience Sandgroper!
It would be frustrating to be promised one thing and receive something different. I have also previously bought watches in a different but similar set up. One watch that I have came with a box that doesn't belong to the that particular watch, I wouldn't g...
Yes Sydney, the box really wasn't a problem.....
From the moment I was made aware of by the vendor, but the papers! That's was the straw which broke the camel's back, as far as I am concerned. Cheers, Francois
Gentlemen and Criminals
Francois, You are taking this in a most gentlemanly way. I would not be as gentle. It appears that the seller cheated you. Whether he did so knowingly depends on his experience selling watches. If he was selling his father's watch and has no knowledge of ...
Hi Park thank you for the compliment....
I am not a gentleman, just a normal human being who doesn't like to pick a fight, just taking life as it comes, the good with the bad, sometimes there are good waves sometimes bad waves and sometimes come the sharks. Another day, another lesson learned......
Sad to say...
but just because one buys from a collector/enthusiast forum doesn't mean there is a guarantee of performance :-( Whether shopping on Fleabay or Purists, one should practice the same due dilligence! I know from hard experience that dealers are active on th...
Open papers ...
I have seen this used in two ways by grey market dealers – either no information on the warranty at all, or an Authorised Dealers name/stamp, but no date. This implies that some of the product is excess from the dealers and the grey marketer is acting as ...
Hi Andrew, thank you for your thoughts.....
Yes it is a pitty not to have the box but in the end..well the box would just collect dust...LOL! But to be fair, the vendor told me about the box, what really makes my blood boil is the complete lack of papers, well, I am lying there are papers but not r...
Best to use ...
... your local GP Authorised Dealer for service questions, but the Australian importer is based in Sydney. I can put you in touch if required. Girard-Perregaux have a very good Patrimony Department that will provide certificates of authenticity and dates ...
I suspect you are too much of a gentleman to name and shame the seller publicly
but at least you have provided enough information that I can work out who the seller is and that is valuable information to have. Thank you. I am sorry to read your story. The term "Purist" is bandied about too often on this forum, when often it just mean...
Hi Richard, thank you for your comments and you are right..
I will not name and shame that person, he will surely recognise himself if he reads this thread. My aim was purely for self interest, wanting to know what was correct from the Watch Lovers, "Purists" view point. I now have the understanding that ethic is ...
Francois, perhaps this thread is all it takes.....
In it's own way to name and shame, without having to mention any individuals!! Hopefully, it may lead to a positive outcome? Regards Tony
I believe there is a need for clarification
Francois I have stated clearly in our email communications before we closed the deal that the box was not original and that the papers were open. I was not aware that your understanding of the term open papers is different from mine. It is a rather common...
You should have mentionned that in your FS post.
Therefore, open papers are still related to the model of the watch, which doesn't seem to be the case here.
Nicolas
I admit to having overlooked putting the word open in the ad. But this is an irrelevant point because in the email communications between Francois and me I had made it clear that the papers were open. Open papers means either papers that are blank. Watch ...
Nicolas may respond at a later time . . .
. . . but I would like to make one comment. This discussion is beginning to remind me of the Monica Lewinsky scandal that enveloped President Clinton when he claimed that he did not have sex with "that woman". After evidence emerged that contradicted his ...
Dr No
in your expert opinion, what does open papers mean specifically for this GP watch? How about for, say, a Zenith Chronomaster (since you are a Zenith moderator)? Is information of the watch printed on a GP/Zenith warranty card straight from the factory lik...
I believe you're side-stepping the point, Gary . . .
. . . as the nub of the issue, as stated by François and not denied as of yet by yourself, is the absence of any documentation that originated with the watch. This is what I received with my Zenith El Primero New Vintage 1969 . . . . . . when I purchased ...
Clarification....
Gary to my question, does the watch comes with box and papers as mentioned in the ad, you replied : "The watch does come with box/open papers but it is not the original huge box with nine compartments. It is a small box as I believe the watch was bought f...
Odd......
So as Gary points out in an e-mail to me yesterday (e-mail below), "open papers" does not mean they need to belong to the watch in question! That's my problem, English is not my mother tongue, French is.....therefore the only explanation is "something was...
Francois
GP warranty cards, as with those from other brands, come as blank cards. The information of the watch is filled in by hand. Now, open means no dealer information and no date, so technically I could have entered the info about the watch on the card and the...
Gary please.......
As I have said previously, I have received your "open papers" which consist of : 1) A little brochure/catalogue explaining how the GP started etc. with pictures of the collection 1998/99 in which the watch I bought from you is no represented. 2) An instru...
Once again
Francois Your interpretation of open papers obviously is different from mine and that is OK. I am offering you a full refund but you have not responded with a decision but only told me that "you are not unhappy with the purchase" and that " you do not thi...
Hi Gary,
As I have written to you yesterday, I do not wish a refund as I am very happy with the WATCH I have purchased, I only felt disappointed with your "OPEN PAPERS". I also suggested that instead of refund, perhaps you could join in for the cost of archives pa...
This thread is now locked . . .
. . . and any further communication between the principals will take place privately. I hope this dispute is satisfactorily resolved without further discussion on HoMe. Regarding the discrepancy between differing interpretations of the term "open papers",...
refund
Francois I am willing to offer a refund ie reverse the transaction but i cannot offer to help pay for thr archive papers because i maintain that i have provided you with accurate information. It is a matter of principle not money as otherwise i would not ...