ThomasM
[PuristS]
14331
I like Urwerk and respect Felix Baumgartner a hell of a lot...
how many versions of certain base models did they release?
and this against a total production of how many?
Come on, Mostel, dont put me in the awkward position of pointing out things which I dont personally have an issue with, just to make a point about a meta-issue.
Pretty please? (I could name many more...)
And by the way, I AM ThomasM, but that doesn't mean my OPINION is gospel or always correct - I've never felt this way, don't feel this way now, and please shoot me if I ever do. But this is a different issue than how I feel I should moderate this forum - there I do have to make decisions and enforce such decisions, much as I find that aspect of moderating distasteful.
What is at issue here is the repeated to the point of nauseum "I hate (all) their limited editions" or "all this forum posts about are RO/ROOS" WITHOUT an attempt at something positive, something positive like what pplater did in the OP to this thread.
You've been around long enough, Mostel, that I hope you understand the distinction I am making, the line I am drawing and why, and that we can have this head butting without being offended or pissed off beyond redemption.
and without assuming undue familiarity, as Moc so rightly points out.
Cheers,
TM
"Those less royal"...
The terrific photo of the 'pianoforte Millenary' by AucklandKiwi a few threads below is a wistful reminder that this is not the RO/ROO forum, but the AP forum. Personally, it was a mild discomfort with the porthole case of the RO/ROO family which made it ...
Of course not. We're a sophisticated bunch...
Even if the octagon still tends to dominate. It is understandable, but many of us also love the other lines. ...
Thank you for your understanding, Michael... :-)
...and for the lovely tribute to Maranello. Cheers, pplater.
Beautiful watches gents...
But I believe his watch would be a tribute to Bologna or Modena (which are the original and later homes of Maserati). Maranello is home to Ferrari. Great watches and a very nice idea to have a thread dedicated to the NON-RO/NON-ROO models. I look forward ...
Can we enhance the thread with some wishlist pieces?
Two of mine... the 4101, incredibly captured here by our own Fx: And the 2012 Gstaad Classic... I really like this one: ...
I wish I were the "ferryman".......
That's a beauty Pplater, I really love the Jules ligne and this one in particular. Cheers from rainy and cold Perth. Francois
It is also a bit Audemars Piguet's Fault.
But I do agree with you that summing a brand to one watch is exasperating. So many nice watches exist, beside the Royal Oak. And so many Royal Oak are not that interesting, at least from my point of view. While in the haute horlogerie, there are some mons...
Im confused, Nico...
the market has, in the past, bought more RO and ROOS, than other models - Millenary, JA, Edward Piguet, Carnegie, etc. before that, the classique, the Huitieme, and numerous unnamed model lines over the decades. The market has turned the RO / ROOS into a ...
Thomas, since you ask
Thomas, If there is any 'fault', it would be that AP makes RO and ROO like they are coins being spilled from a slot machine. There are 10 limited Editions for every 10 limited editions. There are ten non-limited editions for every ten non-limited editions...
I agree, Mostel, but the problem is...
you and Nico and Moc and all the others who love to keep bringing up this point about AP and RO/ROOS and limited editions...then you'd have to do it about MjLC as well... and (gasp) PP...and (GASP! Horrors) Dufour...after all, wasn't a certain"simple" mod...
bravo to pplater, and suggestion to those who wish this forum wasn't "just" RO / ROOS
or any of the other perennial hit list of "wrongs" that AP supposedly commits - 1. too much dominance of RO / ROOS on these boards - post original posts about non- RO's; support non-RO threads and models; BUY them! and share them here (again, thank you, p...
Thank you TM....
It was not intended that we might 'go down that road' again, so apologies if that has become the case. From a personal perspective, any commercial imperative, any commercial strategy, for any product or any brand, is wholly legitimate whether the end goal...
My apologies, pplater, for pouring gasoline onto a spark...
and unintentionally hijacking your great OP! :-( I applaud your approach, thank you. I am traveling (three countries in five days) and upside down on my timezones. Maybe I shouldn't address "broader issues" in this state, but sometimes... :-( I do have so...
It seems this thread got a bit off track...
I am certainly first and foremost a fan of AP's Royal Oak. Its really the AP that first captured my attention. However, I would love to see some photos of other APs of the past and present which are not ROs or ROOs.. I remember in the 1980s AP had a "Bamb...
I say relish the opportunity!
to continue from Thomas from a different perspective: I actually like that AP has supposedly 'so' many LEs. Its an amazing design laboratory that gives its designers, and the public a very- very rich variety of watches to wear, enjoy, and importantly drea...
Hang on a second Thomas,
let me explain a little bit my point of view,as you mentioned my name. Noone here wants to self proclaim a guardian of standards,just giving opinion and share feelings. Broken records?,digressions? ,speculations?If it wasn't for all that this site wouldn'...
dear Mo, I assumed no familiarity with you and, appreciate that you
assume no familiarity with me. Thus, please allow me the courtesy of moderating this forum as I see fit, You don't know me well enough to tell me how to moderate it. that said, my apologies if my impression of any persistent negativity on your part was in...
God forbid me telling you how to moderate Thomas
Never it was my intention at all,but since my name was called i thought to drop a line. No need to apologize,"virtual talk" has its dangers . Thanks for replying ,sorry for the misunderstandement. Mo
Ack
Thomas, I hear you loud and clear. I'd be the first to include all major brands in this. PP is not a sacred cow to me at all. Or any brand really. Dare I dissent at least on the Dufour or general Independent front... I don't know any indie making countles...
I like Urwerk and respect Felix Baumgartner a hell of a lot...
how many versions of certain base models did they release? and this against a total production of how many? Come on, Mostel, dont put me in the awkward position of pointing out things which I dont personally have an issue with, just to make a point about ...
Absolutely, Thomas. The same can be said about many brands.
Included AP. ;) My point was to say that AP can't be summed to the Royal Oak. But ask to people who don't know much about AP. They will say " Royal Oak ", and better " Off Shore " while there are many other ( more? ) interesting models at AP. People used ...
That's a nice watch!
And thank you for referencing my post above! I only have the one Audemars Piguet (the Millenary Pianoforte), but might spring for a Millenary Quincy Jones or Jules Audemars Ultra-Thin over the next few years. It may be sacrilege to admit it, but I have ne...
Your GS is a dreamwatch Kevin
Hi Kevin, No need for a RO when you can wear such a piece of watchmaking genius Kevin! Best Dje
I agree completely! the only problem...
Is that those non RO's are stratospheric :) Seeing one of these below in the steel would be nice! I guess those that purchase these watches, aren't in it for 'show & tell' :) they're in it for the reasons one buys a Dufour! The Cabinet no. 5 is also s...
Beautiful, beautiful Chronometres....
...thank you for the reminder. Still, not all of the non-RO need to be stratospheric, do they? Aren't there some simple JA models? Even some vintage - do we not have any vintage here? The value in vintage never ceases to amaze. Thanks again. Cheers, pplat...
Nice post pplater.
While the RO turned me on to AP and the Jumbo is my all time favorite RO, over the years I have acquired two non RO AP pieces that are both very special to me. As far as LE's I could care less if a watch is a LE or non LE, it is all about if "I" really li...
Aaaahhhh, Jerry...
...can't get enough of that 'brother from another mother'. An EoT set to Vienna??? There HAS to be a story there, doesn't there? Cheers, pplater.
No good story.
Just had that on it when I purchased the EOT. I sent the watch to Clearwater and they put it on the correct location, now I have no excuse to not know true noon. Photo below in another reply. JerryW
WOW!!
awesome Sonnerie and EOT!! Must be exciting picking which watch to wear in the morning!!
Sick Jerry!
Oh my.....amazing set! Possible to get a shot of the EOT next to a Ro or ROO? Thanks!
A good thought PP
and reminder! I don;t have any more AP as I sold off my small ROO (with delight) but the non-ROOs from AP have s much more substance and appeal for me. Whatever sells I guess and you can;t fault the AP executives for thinking that way. That is a classy re...
Oh that sonnerie!
AP has so many models in the Jules and millenarian case that speak to me. I absolutely love the deadbeat millenary but the 4101 is a great alternative. I was close to getting a Maserati a couple of years ago but wasn't fast enough. I should have known bet...
