Tim_M
1381
Count me among the fans
Philosophically, these watches were a bold departure. There's something to be said for management that shows courage and makes a leap of faith.
The Rolex approach is very fair to current owners and respects the enormous tradition, established reputation, and customer preferences associated with the brand.
When Nataf arrived at Zenith, they were an obscure marque with almost no Asian and American presence, and those that did know them in Europe mostly identified the company as a supplier of parts and movements.
So... the Defy was a hugely bold act by management, and that's to be admired.
As for the watches themselves, they exceed expectations when examined in person. The cases are sturdy, the detailing is far more considered and thorough than it appears in photos, and the overwhelming impression is of a baroque bank vault, if such a thing can be imagined. As toy-like as they appear in photos, the feel in the hand is that of a seriously substantial watch.
I do think these watches will enjoy a cult status in the future. Perhaps, they will gain the same kind of ironic appeal that has rejuvenated collector interest in the endearingly monstrous watches of the '70s.
While my wrist is too small to wear one, perhaps I'll acquire a Defy for the sake of completing my Zenith collection; Nataf was an important episode in the company's contemporary history. I can't use a Defy as a watch, but as a clock, perhaps. It can occupy a space of honor by my JLC Atmos 
Regards,
Tim
It may be ...
By: nilomis : December 16th, 2013-09:25
The PreV Panerais and the Defy X requires the same over sized wrist. True, "in metal" the Defy is a very impressive piece. On my dreams, I stay with a Type 20, 40mm as the memorable piece. Don't forget the ones that I own (1969 re edition). I would love t...
In most of cases ...
By: nilomis : December 16th, 2013-12:15
Being ahead of time always has a price to pay. This Defy is perfectly acceptable today but it was not when it was released, in special with those adverts carrying young guys with languid looks. For my personal taste I prefer the current designs, with a da...
Size
By: Spellbound : December 16th, 2013-16:25
Hi Nilo, You seem dissapointed and frustrated with size. But to be honest, Pilot watches and Divers need to be big. I would say that 46mm is probably ideal. The 40mm Pilot is too small (I tried it) but ideal for women. My only gripe with this Defy was the...
Allow me to disagree ...
By: nilomis : December 16th, 2013-16:51
Watches needs to be on a size that's comfortable for the owner and ... What is the most iconic dive watch? Rolex Sub (disclaimer: I don't own one), 40mm. What is the most iconic pilot watch? Omega Speedmaster (it was good to fly to the Moon), 42mm. I don'...
Iconic
By: Spellbound : December 16th, 2013-17:09
Nilo, Iconic does not necessarily translate into ideal for diving. As a diver myself, I know the need for legibility. The most worn timepiece for divers is the Suunto which is typically 45mm. (Yes it is a dive computer) Even The Rolex Deepsea is 44mm. Div...
Count me among the fans
By: Tim_M : December 16th, 2013-17:18
Philosophically, these watches were a bold departure. There's something to be said for management that shows courage and makes a leap of faith. The Rolex approach is very fair to current owners and respects the enormous tradition, established reputation, ...
Well said Tim
By: Spellbound : December 16th, 2013-18:07
I think we should all raise a glass to the somewhat visionary Thierry Nataf ! He himself had tremendous gusto and charisma, and his designs reflected this. It was he who got me devoted to Zenith. He taunted us to dare to be different. Dean