You perfectly described the models and their aim !
I like the Sky Dweller a lot, for all the reasons you gave, I hope they will never put a steel piece for this model, it has to stay exclusive to keep its status.
I didn't fall in love with the Tudors, the hands are not what expected but why not, the red bezel, after all I can understand it it's fun, but the crown ! What an awful tuning crown with the red detail, this is what make me definitely not like it.
The Pelagos is not that bad, but on both models I had a problem with the case, I cannot explain why but it didn't look typical like before.
I much prefer the Advisor at Tudor one of their best watch imho in a different style.
just my 2 cents
Thanks for your report !
Francois