Imo (I’m far from an expert) the hands on my 1A seem fine. Under magnification (see pic) the tritium degradation appears legit and under UV light the hands fade consistent with the dial. Given the age of the piece, who’s to say that moisture wasn’t a contributing factor over the years. The watch was also PASC serviced prior to my acquisition and the serial # has been vetted.
I do not own that 2A (thankfully) but I am going to fully inspect it later this week just for my own education.