MTF[PuristS]
13383
I would trust MB&F with one caveat
Chris,
MB&F know their products best.
It may be that your watch is so banged up that a complete mirror polish is easier to do than trying to bring back the satin finish.
Your question made it seem like an option but what if it is a serious nudge by MB&F to choose a route to achieve a better result?
If both finishes can be achieved, then your question becomes a true choice of aesthetic.
Then, it really is a personal preference. Half the people you ask will like either.
Based on photos, I like shiny.
Why don't you ask Max Busser?
Regards,
MTF