What is/are the watch/es you most regret trading and/or selling?

May 24, 2018,11:55 AM
 

Dear all,


Every time we attain a watch, there is the next best watch we could have obtained. Sometimes, we trade or sell pieces to attain the time piece that our heart beckons us to attain.

Here are my two watches pains me to think of losing in a trade and my thoughts.

Traded in part for JLC Mut Steel Perpetual Calendar (which I've owned for a year and still think was the right decision). 
- JLC Reverso Tribute to 1931 (with Casa Fagliano Straps). This is a watch that I adored but it had a slight annoyance I could not correct for on my 7-7.25 in wrist: lug overhangs. The watch wore perfectly with the OEM black strap (with plastic inserts) better than the Casa Fagliano straps (which I've been told in the past year started to develop thicker curved straps in response to multiple feed backs). The black on black strap look was phenomenal for formal occasions (oxfords, blazers, and suits), however in my opinion did not mesh well with my casual outfits. This is the one watch I gave up that I miss every month. If only the lugs wouldn't overhang the way it did, I'd still be an owner of this fantastic slim and simple piece. Nicolas has recommended the Reverso duo, but I'm unsure if that Reverso would match the ultra-thin embodiment that was the TT1931. Perhaps JLC can bring this tribute line up and somehow engineer a piece with less lug overhang; but I can only dream.

- Rolex Ceramic Sub No Date 14060. This watch embodied my idea of a simple tool watch, albeit ubiquitous. The one nagging thing about this watch was how the case extruded and touched my wrist in a circular plateau leaving spacing often revealing a gap between the wrist and the watch. That coupled with the thickness of the watch had me fall out of love with the 14060. I looked carefully at the non-ceramic models, but decided against getting a steel strap that is inferior to the modern strap. However, I suspect what contributes most to my annoyance of letting this piece go is that the price of the watch has risen another 1.5K since the trade, making it harder for me to attain it later on, if no superior substitute emerges.

Overall, I think the decision making process in attaining a watch is a fascinating one in which we analyze and emote about one watch versus several until we're down to a few watches. This is one of the most interesting aspects of watch collecting and I hope some of you can share similar analysis in your decision-making.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

I guess....

 
 By: InHavenPro : May 24th, 2018-12:13
I could say I regret selling two watches - the basic Omega Speedmaster and the TAG Heuer Monza. Both of 'em were really well worn and thoroughly enjoyed before I had to let them go. Cheers, Filip

All the time :).

 
 By: InHavenPro : May 25th, 2018-10:52
The Speedmaster will be re-purchased in an even better variant certainly and even the Monza is up there as a possibility. Cheers, Filip

These 2!!!

 
 By: Steiner1975 : May 24th, 2018-12:36
...  

Up to now, no regrets.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : May 24th, 2018-15:32
This is mostly attributed to 1) me very rarely selling (~10 watches over 20+ years) and 2) when I have the incoming has always been better mechanically, aesthetically, historically or just in terms of suitability / wearability (e.g. I've sold almost every... 

Those are very valid points.

 
 By: jh8cw : May 25th, 2018-08:44
I made that trade thinking it was my best shot at the watch at that point in time. Trading merely 10 watches over 20 years is remarkable; to me it speaks of you discipline, careful thinking, that you're very much in tune with your taste as well as stabili... 

There have been some impulsive buys, but only a few. And I think I've been lucky with my choices at times.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : May 27th, 2018-12:08
Lucky insofar as choosing the more established or classic model within a brand lineup or more establish brand over something newer, hotter, trendier, blog favourite etc.

Moonwatch for me

 
 By: jayeyedoubleemmwhy : May 24th, 2018-16:07
I purchased a pre-owned Omega Speedmaster Pro Moonwatch but immediately had doubts about it because I thought 42mm was too big for my wrist. Sold it after a few months, but then came to regret the decision. This was right when I started a two year watchma... 

where to start?

 
 By: aston.db4 : May 24th, 2018-20:34
There's been a few watches that I occasionally miss. The one that stands out the most is the Cartier Tank Basculante ref. 2390.

Still till today no regrets .

 
 By: Watchonthewrists : May 24th, 2018-22:52
I am allways looking for the next ,,new,, watch . And when i do let go of a watch its because i want a upgrade of that model or brand .

One special Patek.....

 
 By: baufoam : May 24th, 2018-23:00
The first Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar that I ever bought. It is a 3940 with a Dore dial. I sold the watch twice and bought it back twice! This happened over a time frame of about 10 years. Unhealthy,unsound, un -economical! That watch β€œbit” me hard.... 

I sold this one about 3 years ago- I just could not wear it. Too gold

 
 By: watch-guy.com : May 24th, 2018-23:47
I struggled to sell it My jaw dropped when a similar model at Phillips for >$150k But I did buy this one with the proceeds which I find much more wearable Do I regret selling the first one - No ....but I should have sold it now and not 3 years ago Financi...  

This Type XX

 
 By: Rascal : May 25th, 2018-00:13
From Breguet 😭😭😭 ...  

I blame myself

 
 By: Rascal : May 25th, 2018-02:14
Everyday, MikeH too... Moreover if you know it was for 8,5kβ‚¬πŸ˜±

Oh...

 
 By: MTR : May 25th, 2018-09:31
no... Best, Thomas

Ah, so this regret echoes my own, just that it is amplified by a thousand times!

 
 By: jh8cw : May 25th, 2018-08:47
I'm starting to think the only means of not having such regrets is to hold on to our pieces and accumulate at the expense of having watches in your collection that you don't wear as much. Not sure whether that path is worth it!

This one I regret...

 
 By: MTR : May 25th, 2018-09:33
Best, Thomas ...  

Yes, thank you for your kind

 
 By: MTR : May 25th, 2018-12:40
compassion! And the pain is NOT sweet... 😳 ...  

I feel the pain vicariously just glancing at the Blancpain divers and the Reverso movement!

 
 By: jh8cw : May 25th, 2018-10:51
Such classy pieces, and that Panerai piece is probably the classiest one I've seen so far! I hope they were replaced by amazing pieces...

Help!!!!!

 
 By: MTR : May 25th, 2018-11:00
Why the Gyrotourbillon? Best, Thomas

Painful ....

 
 By: Horology75 : May 26th, 2018-07:11
Regret selling my Rolex Daytona 6263, Patek 3710/1a, Patek 3712/1A , 5980/1a lastly I sincerely regret selling my Patek 5070g . Mistakes of my life and now I kick myself for the grave mistakes i made. Iam gonna Get few back ...

I'd imagine these are severe monetary losses!

 
 By: jh8cw : May 26th, 2018-11:06
I hope the happiness from the pieces you acquired in the process of unloading these offset some of these regrets!

This definitely!

 
 By: Alfisti : May 28th, 2018-05:52
...