FabR[Senior Patek Moderator]
26166
Superb foursome -- so diverse that they are hard to compare, but the beauty and iconic status of the 5196P within the "previous" Calatrava generation wins my vote! ;-)
As for P vs. G, it obviously depends on the watch....but all other things being equal (which is rarely the case), the charm of Platinum for me is unmatched!
Cheers.