A piece of history - Cartier Tortue Minute Repeater circa 1928

Nov 05, 2010,08:59 AM
 

This Tortue minute repeater wristwatch, c. 1928, from Cartier Paris is a small watch, at 30 mm wide and 33 mm long. It is cased in yellow gold and fitted with a modern lizard skin strap. A watch similar to this one, but dating from 1929, still holds the record for the most expensive Cartier wristwatch ever sold at auction when it hammered for CHF993,500 at Antiquorum in 2002.


 

The movement is a minute repeater calibre from European Watch & Clock Company (EWC), which obtained its movements from LeCoultre. Adjusted to 8 positions with wolf's teeth winding wheels and Breguet overcoil, it is a movement of peerless quality, equal to the absolute best of the period (Patek, Vacheron et al), as majority of the EWC movements were.



 

The back of the watch is engraved on the back:


A search online indicates Mr Audibert was a stockbroker with Gude, Winmill & Co. The Union Club on the other hand is one of the oldest men's clubs in the United States and one that has in the past counted amongst its members various illustratrious members of American society. click here for an NYT piece on the Union Club.

You can feel the history in a watch like this and it makes you ponder. With a watch like that and a membership of the Union Club, Mr Audibert must have been a fairly rich man. One wonders what Mr Audibert's reaction to the typographical error in the engraving was.


Pictured above with a contemporary Tortue Monopoussoir chronograph


And here with a modern Santos 100 XL  

And for those wondering, the repeater still does sound fantastic after 80 years. It is loud, clear and resonant, though it strikes a bit quickly. Besides the lost arts of the gong alloy and repeater construction, another reason for the sound is the thinner and lighter case compared to modern repeater watches.

Beautiful as it is, this is an exceedingly rare watch. Only two have ever come up at auction and this is one of them. It is an almost sentimental reminder of Cartier's first golden age in watchmaking.

- SJX

This message has been edited by SJX on 2010-11-05 09:36:04


More posts: SantosSantos 100

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

A beautiful watch...

 
 By: patrick_y : November 5th, 2010-23:09
A beautiful watch that is every bit as modern today as it was back in 1928. I have heard the present day Cartier Tortue Minute Repeater's chimes. I can only wonder if they match the original's chiming as well.

The original is better

 
 By: SJX : November 5th, 2010-23:15
I have heard two samples of the modern version with the Renaud et Papi calibre, while it has a pleasant enough tone and is clear, it is not as loud as the vintage model. Like I wrote in my earlier post I suspect it has to do with the construction and heft...  

They don't make it like they used to...

 
 By: patrick_y : November 5th, 2010-23:19
I like loud and crisp minute repeaters. Amazing that the new Cartier minute repeater is water resistant. Not a lot of minute repeaters are fortunate enough to be water resistant. Jaeger-LeCoultre is the only one that comes to mind.

But I prefer the bolder look

 
 By: Geo : November 6th, 2010-00:07
of the CPCP version. It's still a bit more robust, without being too large. GEO

Stunning piece - aesthetics are absolutely spot on

 
 By: 219 : November 5th, 2010-23:55
and if only the engraver could spell! Must have had a Scottish accent for 'Ney York'. Great watch though. Thanks Andrew H

At least it wasn't 'Noo York'. :-) [nt]

 
 By: SJX : November 7th, 2010-07:24
No message body

no words for these pieces...

 
 By: cisco : November 6th, 2010-10:33
just admiring The duo you show is for me one of the most fantastic in all wristwatch history Thanks

Movement question

 
 By: aaronm : November 6th, 2010-16:18
Is there a round movement in the vintage piece like in the modern one, or does the older movement fill the case? a

It is a round movement

 
 By: SJX : November 6th, 2010-19:31
Form minute repeaters are exceedingly rare, even today. In fact I don't recall EWC or LeCoultre ever making a form repeater ebauche. - SJX

I wasn't sure

 
 By: aaronm : November 7th, 2010-19:50
if form repeaters were one of those things that used to be common, like form movements in general, and became rare, or were always rare... I was thinking, the only non-round modern repeater I can think of is the JLC reverso.... A

You're right regarding the JLC Reverso

 
 By: SJX : November 7th, 2010-19:54
and also Franck Muller's repeater-tourbillon. But they are rare now, and they were rare in the past too. - SJX

Thank you....

 
 By: MiniCooper : November 8th, 2010-12:37
for reminding us.... Cartier has a rich history indeed... Cheers