patrick_y[PuristSPro Moderator]
28689
A perfect concept, but with a few flaws...
Sep 07, 2017,14:49 PM
When the Toyota 86 debuted, I applauded Toyota for bringing this to market. This is exactly what the industry needed.
Then I drove one, a stock one, for nearly 1000 miles, 1500 kilometers, and I couldn't sing its praises anymore. Drove it in heavy Los Angeles traffic, in the city, on windy roads with WanteringPurist and other sports car fans, on a road trip, and so on.
Conceptually, the car was excellent. But its execution did have a few flaws. Perhaps, I got an unlucky one that slipped past quality control. The Limited Slip Differential clunked on any sharp turns, and clunked heavily in a U-turn. The acceleration needed careful and precise planning on the highway. The car didn't qualify as a momentum car because the car's handling couldn't keep a turn at speed. The Hyundai Genesis two door coupe drove like a better sorted car.
In the end, it brought exposure to a niche that was underserved. It sold reasonably well, but apparently the small number that was sold is such a small percentage of the entire product portfolio that Toyota doesn't care. It's also targeting a market that won't pay for the product; it's too expensive for the people asking for the product (it's kind of like the people who clamor for Ferrari to make more manual stick shifts; those clamor-ers aren't buyers), and for the people who can afford the product they go for something a little bit bigger, like the heavier Lexus IS and RC, the Infiniti Q60 coupe (which wins on looks alone), and the German coupes.
A BMW 2011 or 2012 -year 328i coupe with the 3.0 liter naturally aspirated engine is my choice in this segment. Great steering, good brakes, fantastic handling, and I'll take it in automatic or the comfort-oriented manual. Just gotta watch out for that electric water pump on that generation of 28i engine as they fail randomly and cause the entire engine to overheat. Did I mention it also doesn't have a coolant temperature gauge? Talk about flaws!