Thanks Randy for raising this to a vote

I believe that the comparison was made between 5712G and 5726A because they appear to be the same -- both are in leather strap and have same case appearance although one is in white gold (5712) and the other in SS (5726).

My vote basically goes to the 5712G for the following reasons:
1. Slimmer case
2. Uniqueness of the dial
3. Practicality of the complication

Having said that, the 5726A is a great watch. It's so happen that I preferred the 5205G not because of the metal but more on the uniqueness of the two-toned dial, the pierced lug, the concave bezel, and the calendar aperture location, all of which IMHO can become a collection Item features 20 to 30 years from now.

Available on the marketplace

2,837 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.

163,000 USD

Pre-owned - Excellent · GB

View all Patek Philippe on the marketplace →

Patek Philippe 5726a Nautilus Jumbo Annual Calendar Moonphase

129,895 USD

Pre-owned - Excellent · US

2025 Patek Philippe Nautilus 5726A-001 Annual Calendar Black Dial

103,750 USD

New with box and papers · US

NEW 2025 PAPERS Patek Philippe Nautilus Moonphase Steel 40.5mm 5726A-001 BOX

100,974 USD

New with box and papers · US

Please vote between PP Nautilus 5712G or 5726A

By: randy_yeap : January 30th, 2012-14:36

Thank you for the respond

By: randy_yeap : January 30th, 2012-14:39

I have difficulty choosing between these two. I prefer the complication of Annual Calendar but can't resist the elegant of white gold. Please help.

5726 is my vote , like my nautilus in steel [nt]

By: darma : January 30th, 2012-15:58

No message body

5712 A.

By: amanico : January 30th, 2012-20:09

But I am french, I always decide on what is not part of the choice. Best, Nicolas

5712 A........

By: DP1 : January 30th, 2012-23:22

I'm with Nicolas on this one.

5712G for me.

By: BABKA : January 30th, 2012-16:12

I like the offset dial much more.

Agreed. [nt]

By: bulliondesk : January 30th, 2012-17:27

No message body

Thanks for the reply any other thought ? Please share

By: randy_yeap : January 30th, 2012-21:26

Now we have one 5726 two 5712G and one 5712/1A thanks

One more 5712 because

By: dr.kol : January 30th, 2012-23:44

Nautilus is a sporting watch a gold if the wrong material for such a watch. Furthermore, the annual calendar version is quite thick while 5712 is slim, elegant and pleasant to wear. I have noticed that lots of Nautilus Annual Calendars are sold 2nd hand. ...

Since Nicholas has restarted the french revolution

By: darma : January 31st, 2012-00:42

If I had to choose between the 5712a and the 5726 it would be the 5712a as well, however in saying this my next nautilus would be the 5980a if this was on the table, love the thickness and sportiness of this piece. As nautilus in Latin means blue it would...

I think the nautilus in SS is the most attractive among the nautilus line (of course this is my personal opinion) Will take the 5726A.

Tough call

By: Le Chef : January 31st, 2012-09:22

Even though I have a 5712G I would suggest getting a 5712/1a for its versatility. I also like the 3/4 rotor movement in the 5712, and prefer the dial to the 5726.

My choice would be for........

By: Topcat30093 : January 31st, 2012-12:12

The 5726A. Nearly two years ago it was either this piece or the 5205G. In the end it was the 5205 that came back with me

Finally make my choice guess what

By: randy_yeap : January 31st, 2012-15:32

Neither 5712G nor 5726A and not even 57121A It's 5712R that won my heart most when I put it on my wrist. it sit perfectly on my wrist and I just prefer the weight of gold. I must said 5726 is really cool and stunning n of course comfortable too but I stay...

Patek Philippe