Platinum Deployant for my 5905P - What would you do?

Dec 07, 2019,11:03 AM
 

Cognoscenti,

As many of you are aware I just purchased a 5905P and am in love with it. My only critique of it is that it did not come with a platinum deployant clasp and instead comes with the platinum tang buckle. My AD was unwilling to negotiate a swap of the platinum buckle for platinum deployant, which is fine, so I began searching for alternative solutions. I called HSWA in New York and was informed the price of a platinum deployant will be $4,800. I also spoke to a gray dealer in New York that has a new/unworn Patek watch with a platinum deployant, and he is willing to work a deal where he would sell me the new platinum deployant for only $3,500 but I would need to give him my platinum tang buckle to replace the deployant on the watch he is selling (which is fine because I’ll never use it again once I have the deployant). I can’t justify the $4,800 under any circumstance from HSWA, but $3,500 is doable — the question is, should I? If you were me, assuming you strongly desired a platinum deployant and did not prefer the tang, what would you do given the options?



More posts: 59055905Pcomplications

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

It's your personal prefrence. If you don't mind paying for it get the buckle you like. [nt]

 
 By: mpg13 : December 7th, 2019-11:27
If you're considering resale value keep both.

Go with the Deployant Clasp instead of the Buckle

 
 By: bradleg : December 7th, 2019-11:58
I traded my buckle on my 5227G to a deployant clasp. It made the watch easier, quicker and safer to put on and remove. In the long run you will save on the cost of leather watch bands which could be several hundred dollars a year, if the watch is a daily ... 

The Price is right

 
 By: bradleg : December 7th, 2019-20:50
The price for the platinum deployant clasp with the buckle trade-in is about right. Everything with a Patek is expensive. Ask your A.D. how much would a replacement spring bar for your watch strap would cost and you would know exactly what I mean. Good lu... 

I would do it.

 
 By: shafran : December 7th, 2019-12:00
Its doable with the trade.

For me, with this reference, I would prefer to get the deployant clasp and trade in the pin buckle.

 
 By: NoH : December 7th, 2019-12:00
In saying that, the $3,500 for this seems high to me, however I am no expert on the value so cannot really comment other than if I had the means, and it would exponentially improve my feeling when wearing/looking at the timepiece, I would go for the chang... 

I think you are being stingy....... you need both......

 
 By: Patek_3944 : December 7th, 2019-21:17
I don't understand this type of first world problem...... If the watch came on the deployant only.... then you could have the deployant only..... BUT If it came on a tang buckle..... I would want to retain the original....... Also the strap is different -...  

I am surprised your AD wasn’t willing to play ball on the deployant instead of the tang.

 
 By: russell996 : December 8th, 2019-02:34
I have done just this with a number of pieces from Patek and Lange. I would get the deployant, doing the swop makes perfect sense as why have a redundant tang but you will need a new strap for best fit on the wrist.

I prefer the aesthetic simplicity of the regular buckle.

 
 By: Rapwatch : December 8th, 2019-03:44
Personally I find the excessively ornate and showy PP symbol on the deployant very jarring.