Patek Philippe - Dear all purists, I’m saving for my next Patek purchase and would like to hear your advises...

Dear all purists, I’m saving for my next Patek purchase and would like to hear your advises...

Feb 07, 2020,18:49 PM

I’m struggling between which of the following I should acquire.

5059R
3940J
5056P

Their current market prices are kind of similar (well, less for 5056P since it’s an annual calendar not a perpetual).

It’s very tempting for me to be able to own a Grand Complication from Patek (I believe it’s normal ) however I also like the fact that I could own a platinum Patek (5056) with a very practical no nonsense complication. I used to own a 5035G but I let it go as I found its dial kind of plain (it’s just me).

I’m more a dressy guy. Not full suit everyday but sport coat pants style.

Look forward to your suggestions and inspiration. Thank you!

* I’m sorry but for some reason I cannot post any pictures...

Nig

More posts: 394050355059complicationsgrand complications

Comments: view entire thread

Gotta go with the 3940j. Such a classic piece. [nt]

By: vitalsigns : February 7th, 2020-19:03

Thank you!! Well heard. [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-01:41

Zero hesitation, here. Go for the 3940. Just one question, please: Why just the J, why not the R or the G? [nt]

By: amanico : February 7th, 2020-23:20

Thank you!!! Firm and clear answer. To answer your question, just because the R and G will be much more expensive than the J!! [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-01:41

If you allow me this thought, you should maybe consider it the other way and go for the one which pleases you the most. Imagine you much prefer the R or the G, you may, in the long term, regret the J. [nt]

By: amanico : February 8th, 2020-02:08

Honestly the metal colour doesn’t bother me much but yes a G would be much more versatile choice!!! Thank you. [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-19:38

I'd have a hard time deciding.

By: VMM : February 8th, 2020-02:37

3940G or 5056P I like the look of the 5056P, however, the perpetual complication of the 3940 is highly tempting. I'd need to see and feel them on my wrist for a final decision. Good luck! Vte

Thank you and yes 5056 looks cool! [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-19:39

5059 I would not consider...

By: lascases : February 8th, 2020-05:22

... because of the rather flat dial and also it is not the original (which 5050 is). 5056 is very nice to wear, quite substantial and heavy. More sporty than 3940. 3940 is less heavy but so beautiful and a key milestone in PPs history. In summary: I would...

I have owned

By: baufoam : February 8th, 2020-08:46

Two different 5056 watches. It’s a great piece. I sold one of them to help finance a 3940j. I have never regretted that decision. The 3940 is a stellar example of Patek Philippe. You will not regret it.

Thank you!! Another thing I’m hesitated about the 5059 is it’s hands, which tends to oxidised very easily.... which may bother me at some point. [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-22:44

Hi Nig, I think you should focus on the PCs because you already had an annual calendar. Between the two PCs, it depends on whether you want the...

By: GLau : February 8th, 2020-09:16

retrograde date function. If so, the 5059 definitely has an interesting (i.e. not plain) dial. If not, the 3940 dial design is well balanced and attractive. Enjoy your hunt !

Thank you for your helpful advise!! Yes maybe I should focus on the lovely Grand Complication and thanks for reminding me to “enjoy” the hunt (instead of becoming anxious about it):) [nt]

By: Musigny82 : February 8th, 2020-22:46

Another vote goes to the 3940J

By: Huei : February 9th, 2020-23:21

Very classic and easy to wear. All the best in your watch hunting : )