christophe_123
9
Calatrava 5127 vs FP Journe Octa automatique reserve
Hi Patek lovers,
I am thinking of aquiring the watch of my life and the Calatrava 5127 has been in my mind for a few years. I really appreciate the elegance in its simplicity, its harmonious curves and the finish of the movement. However I recently discovered the Octa automatique reserve from FP Journe. Although it's style is quite different from the 5127, I really like its dial and the movement looks stunning too. Unfortunately I don't know much about the difference between FP Journe and Patek which I think is the benchmark. The Octa automatique reserve is also surprisingly about 40 % more expensive than the 5127 ! It only has the power reserve as an extra feature from the 5127.
Do you think I might make a mistake if I go for the FP Journe instead of the 5127 ?
How does Journe compare to Patek ?
Would Patek fans like you go for a Journe which seems more exclusive (I read Journ makes 2,000 watches a year while Patek make 40,000) ?
Thank so much for helping me in that decision with you expertise.
This message has been edited by christophe_123 on 2010-11-15 13:40:21
FP Journe Octa automatique reserve dial
FP Journe Octa automatique reserve back
This message has been edited by christophe_123 on 2010-11-15 13:43:44
💰1729 Marketplace Listings for Patek Philippe›Patek Philippe Calatrava · 2 for sale · 8349 discussions›
Collection
EDJA shares his Patek Philippe 5127R Calatrava, reportedly the last produced. Compare it with 5205R and 5227R, and explore collector insights.
26 replies16225 views
Market
Explore the F.P. Journe Chronomètre Bleu's meteoric rise to multi-million dollar valuations. Collectors debate market sustainability, production scarcity, and the impact on watch enjoyment.
45 replies6280 views
Collection
Patek_3944 considers compressing his Patek Philippe collection (5035J, 5110J, 5196J, 5127G, 5296G) to acquire a higher-level piece like a 5170. Explore community advice on collection strategy and prestige.
34 replies12887 views
Reference Guide
Explore the F.P. Journe Tokyo Boutique Anniversaire Series. A detailed guide to the 6 limited-edition titanium watches, their unique ruthenium dials, and burgundy straps. Essential for collectors.
13 replies2307 views
Review
First look at the Patek Philippe 5227G black dial Calatrava. Mark in Paris shares photos and thoughts on this elegant dress watch.
29 replies22931 views
Reference Guide
Explore Patek Philippe's 2016 anniversaries: the CH 28-520 caliber and the launch of Nautilus references 5711, 5712, and 5980. A look back at key milestones.
33 replies15391 views
Calatrava 5127 vs FP Journe Octa automatique reserve
Hi Patek lovers, I am thinking of aquiring the watch of my life and the Calatrava 5127 has been in my mind for a few years. I really appreciate the elegance in its simplicity, its harmonious curves and the finish of the movement. However I recently discov...
Listen to your heart !
First of all, if you choose an Octa Automatique, be sure that you get a great watch. I find it more appealing than the 5127: the caliber is really beautiful and the dial more original. Of course, with Patek, you will get a watch from the most prestigious ...
wow this fpj is
very nice! first time i see the movement. I could live with both the fpj and the pp. just looking at the movement i have an idea why the fpj is more expensive....
The FP Journe has got also a big date and a small second ...
... compared to the PP 5127. Try both on and see which one is best looking on the wrist. At times the watch can look quite different as expected on the wrist. If you can not decide, than go for the PP as it is the benchmark, as you very correctly mentione...
Hi.....
Welcome to the forum..... Between the two, I would choose the FPJ.... However it is not a "fair" comparison between these two watches, as the FPJ has a double date and a power reserve (as the Count has mentioned)...... Both manufacturers are top quality a...
It is a big date ;-) : big date does not have to be necessarily big, just ...
... more than one disc, therefore a two disc display is defining a big date. So any double date is a big date. I know quite anal (I was also quite shocked that the English use this for "pingelig"=fussy , when I heard the first time the usage of this word)...
That's not always the case
The Sarpaneva big-date uses a single wheel, just with the numerals vertically so they can be much larger A
Not convinced with the Sarpaneva being a big date...
... contraire to the "double date": a big date showing is also not a real big date COMPLICATION. The difficulties of a clear, straight two digit display of the date makes it a complication and not a single date wheel with larger numerals only. Regards Mor...
I'm not disagreeing with the difficulty
I'm only disputing your assertion that the term "Big Date" requires a 2-wheel setup. As it's commonly used big, in this case, just means big. Since this complication, unlike say a pointer date versus a guichet date, is rather recent, we don't have much hi...
That is an argument: no historic reference. But in German literature it is ...
... classed as a big date if two date wheels are used. In accordance to that Langes Zeitwerk would be a "BIG TIME" ? ( ;-) ). But I reckon Lange does not have any worries that this powerplant of a watch will bring them theire big time. Regards Moritz
two different timepieces....
As others have mentioned, the Journe and Patek are two different creatures, both design and watch function wise. The Journe does have the PR function, big date, and off center seconds dial as others have discussed. The Patek is very nice but admittedly ra...
tough question,,
However I think as a long term love affair if it was me .....PP for sure Why? the history for a start then the looks probab mvt wise they are the same, maybe FPJ is even better? and despite 40,000 pcs, remember that the PP production includes a lot of lad...
I noticed the back ...
picture is of the Octa Perpetual but the base movement is the same I suppose. As other have said,these two are not close enough for a direct comparison but will depend on other factors such as personal preference in terms of size,(FPJ is slightly larger) ...
5127 as a starter
PP has a much more reliable movement and as it will be your "life watch", the reliability should be one of the most relevant concerns of you. FPJ is very innovative, however, you should be aware that the techinical quality (not the decorative) and quality...
FPJ problems,
I had FPJ Octa, there a was a problem with big date. The watch had been repaired twice. Then sold out. My choice is Patek
Journe reliability
Thank you very much for your replies. I think you raised a very important point in the fact the Patek has a long history of reliable movement but FP Journe doesn't. I also read that there were a few issues with Journe, mainly with the first batch of Octa....
FPJ vs PP
I have the FPJ you are considering (38 mm) black label...it is superb. I have had no problems and it as accurate as any of my PPs, ALSs, APs, etc...perhaps more so. The best advice is get what you love - not what others suggest. I love the 5127 and someda...
Get the Patek
...for all of the above reasons. I thought my Richard Lange would quench my thirst for a Patek 5127. It hasn't. I lust after one in white gold. DB Darien
out of production?
I hear the 5127s are gone only whats in inventory at the ADs. I tried to order in rose and was told no way to get them by the AD. I had read earlier they were only put back in the 2010 cat. because a few were still in the factory and earmarked for the US.
One for FPJ
Hi! I am the fortunate owner of 3 Pateks, i love them all and, being in these shoes, i would take the Journe. Being in yours, i would try both, ask my wife, and decide. Probably for FPJ again. There's something magnetic in this watch, i do not know what. ...