Puffy
308
5146 or 5205?
Input appreciated....
I want an AC and love the look of these two...
I have a 5711 and 5167 so fancy something with a lighter coloured dial
I love the 5146 as it's typical classic patek
5205 is great too but more contemporary.. Also a bit bigger at 40mm vs 39mm for the 5146..
Any owners of these two who can comment pls?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2
Collection
Explore Miles_151's passion for the Patek Philippe Aquanaut Ref. 5167A-001. Discover why this 'under the radar' sports watch captivates collectors.
32 replies7650 views
5146 or 5205?
Input appreciated.... I want an AC and love the look of these two... I have a 5711 and 5167 so fancy something with a lighter coloured dial I love the 5146 as it's typical classic patek 5205 is great too but more contemporary.. Also a bit bigger at 40mm v...
Here's my take...
Hi Puffy... It wasn't a tough decision for me as the 5146 has been on my grail list for some time. As you mentioned, it has this extremely classic, quintessential, Patek Calatrava look. I absolutely love the soft-rounded corners from the bezel to the lugs...
thanks for the snaps :) I also love how nicely rounded it is. while I hate
cluttered dials, and let's be honest there's a lot going on here, I think it comes together very nicely. The power reserve is the icing on the cake... Wonderful... Compared to my 5167 and 5711 the 5146g would also offer the most contrast I guess..... This...
I much prefer the 5205
I think the use of apertures is much better than the dial on the 5146. I used to own a 5146 1/g and switched to a 5726 Nautilus. I also think the am/pm indicator is great, especially when setting it. The case of the 5205 is a very classic Patek case while...
art deco, that's a good description! and you're right about the two tone grey... amazing
biggest issue I'd have is the lack of contrast between my other pateks... how does the tang buckle work when wearing for long periods of time?
Trying to guess your age by the hand in the pictures...
You are less than 40, probably my age. I'm 37. Am I close? I think you should go for the 5205, that is what I would do. It satisfies all the requests: annual calendar, dressier, light dial. Besides, I find it a bit more versatile than the 5146. I do not o...
cheers. close, bit younger but I'm not worried about people thinking
I'm wearing an old man's watch! Both are great... It'd be perfect to own both there are other watches to be owned...
My vote will be the 5205...
Because I love the concave bezel, the pierced lugs and the 24-hour indicator in the said watch. I am also a fan of the aperture calendar and the two tone dial, makes the watch absolutely modern IMHO. I own a 5711 and a 5164 as well. Each watch will have i...
thanks Fernando. dont you have the 5146? if so pls post pics....
And merry Christmas!
5146 for me
I prefer the 5146 for its classic and timeless look. Both the slate dial and cream lacquered dials are nice but as I prefer classical looks, the cream dial did it for me. I recently got the 5146R with cream dial (R only comes with cream dial). See this li...
5205 dark dial....
if it's going to be a special occassion wearer, 5146 if it's for every day. The 5205 is more dressy and formal, the 5146 more practical. I personally don't like the "cartoon" power reserve indicator on the 5146 and the fat & fluffy numerals at the qua...
Hi Anders..........
I have had the privilege to own both the 5146 in J & G with the same coloured dial,as in your photo. It is a great piece and one that I wish in many ways I had hung onto, the subdials give it that, imo, a more vintage feel. And as Carl has pointed out, I ...
How about the 5396?
I think the 5396 is better annual than both the 5146 or the 5205? Classic design. A little thinner in profile. ...
What's wrong with date window?
I have no opinion either way. Just wondering what your feelings are on the subject.
But it's still a classic well balanced dial?
Take a look at the Reardon book and compare the 5396 to References from the 40's and 50's that have apetures. They're not AC's but the dial layouts are unquestionably where the 5396 has its roots.
More 5396
It's not exactly the same dial, but you get the idea. Classic layout of day and month apetures. BTW, I don't have a 5396 and therefore I'm not insulted either way? I just think the 5396 is a viable consideration when the conversation involves Patek AC's. ...
Easy choice
I have a 5146g (as pictured) and chose that one because it is much more timeless. It's dial and sub dials are clean, easy to read, classic and for me the design will hold up forever. I guess I'm biased but I've had the watch for a year and a half and have...