HasanR
33
5140r or 6196p
Hi all,
First world problems but I have a dilemma and hope some feedback from you all will help me!
I am trying to decide between a 5140r and the new 2025 model 6196p with the rose gilt dial.
They are exactly the same price (both pre owned)
They are both beautiful in their own way but not sure which one to choose…..
Which one would hold its value better if I decided to sell in future?
Thanks in advance

Vintage
quattro · Apr 2, 2025
Explore the vintage Patek Philippe Calatrava ref. 2451, featuring a 31mm steel Francois Borgel case, radium dial, and manual caliber 10-200. A deep dive into its collector appeal.
23 replies3416 views
5140r or 6196p
By: HasanR : October 16th, 2025-21:07
Hi all, First world problems but I have a dilemma and hope some feedback from you all will help me! I am trying to decide between a 5140r and the new 2025 model 6196p with the rose gilt dial. They are exactly the same price (both pre owned) They are both ...
No contest actually
By: sham1 : October 17th, 2025-12:49
The 5140R is a grand complication and is definitely better value now and will hold its value better too. But buy the watch that you love, the watch that suits your wrist and lifesyle. I was not impressed by the over hyped 6196P when I tried it on. The dia...