aj_tucker
1
Great post!
I bought a 5170P a few weeks ago, but I can't get the 5170G out of my head and I don't have the budget for both. I like the description you made of the G and I think it's the watch I would get more long term enjoyment out of. It's more refined, more flexible, albeit not as bold, not as likely to stand out.
Available on the marketplace
2,850 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
A „long term comparision“ - 5170g vs 5170p vs 5172g
What‘s better to do on a sunday morning, than spending time with one‘s favorite hobbies. I‘ve seen questions regarding the comparision of these timepieces from time to time, so I thought I might write down my experiences after spending a longer time with ...
Great review, nafetS!
Thanks a lot for this. I love those reviews that describe the character of a watch, instead of describing their features and properties. Even if by nature, describing the character of a watch is always subjective, to me this is what it comes down to! Ther...
Actually it’s more that I love the VC Cornes de Vache so much
I think the 5170 to be executed very well, but I would have liked a bit more personality. However, I understand this is also a quality (being understated), especially for the 5170g. You described it very well.
The VC Cornes de Vache is also a great chrono. I've tried one on in the past. I didn't buy it, because it was slightly too small for me, being almost 2m tall.
But I can see why one would choose the VC CdV over the 5170g.
Great review, nicely described as very accurate.
I agree with your opinion on all three references. For me personally the top is the 5170G, because as you said, it’s the most mature and restrained with the punch for the trained eye. For me it’s the watch that when in your wrist, makes you fit in every e...
Thank you, ZSHSZ. I agree with you. The 5170g is, if it matches your character and style, the most versatile of the three. And it's a very nice exit watch.
You could wear it with the most outfits and to the most different occasions. The 5170P is imho the "hardest" to match. There are still plenty of occasions to wear it, but it's not a as good as a daily wearer.
wonderfully defined each of these versions !
my personal fav is 5172G, as you've mentioned have a tinge of sportyness or non-serious in nature !! you've well captured the essence of them. Best, mahesh.,
Great description, I love your story telling 👍
As for the watches, 5172G is my choice too, cool refined and sophisticated at the same time, strong presence without show off, I love it
Yes, I also think, that the 5172g is more refined. But some edges can be good for the long term interest in a watch. A very refined design can possibly become boring at some point in time.
I wonder, what I'll think about them in a few years.
An excellent post to explain their differences !
Please do the same for other pieces that you have.
Thank you, GLau. I'll think about what comparision I could do next. Won't be that easy.
I usually don't have several watches of the same type and if so, they are less different in character.
Not owning any of these, but being somewhat facials with them, I think your assessment is perfect.
I’m a longtime fan of the 5170G. When one looks at the G and P together they are such different watches, dial colour yes, but also dial layout, sub dials etc. And of course those diamond markers. I can completely understand why owning both makes perfect s...
Of these, the 5172...
...it would be a tougher choice if there were leaf hands involved...
What a terrific write up!
Your observations are spot on. Of the three the 5172 does have slightly more appeal, as it’s a formidable piece yet doesn’t take itself too seriously.
Great post!
I bought a 5170P a few weeks ago, but I can't get the 5170G out of my head and I don't have the budget for both. I like the description you made of the G and I think it's the watch I would get more long term enjoyment out of. It's more refined, more flexi...
Thank you! And congratulations to your 5170p and welcome to the board.
P or G is definitely not an easy choice, I wouldn‘t know, which one I‘d sell first, if I had to. On the other hand, if I‘d only have one and could only have one, I‘d probably stick ith the one I already have until I‘m completely sure I wanted to change. ...
great review and comparison
even if I like the 5170 case design and your 2 models in G & P, I admit that the 5975P case design should be a great addition to your comparative post/ collection. My 2 cents. Enjoy your beauties +++++ ...
I agree, it wouln'd be an accurate comparison according to the movement.
But what a case design +++++ Maybe for your fourth watchbox (empty) place ;-)
Fantastic collection...
Plain to see you're someone who likes their chronographs! I fall into that category too, I had the 5170G (white dial) and sold it to fund my 5270R yet there's a part of me that misses it so much that I'm thinking of adding it back again yet I'd want a pri...
5975R a 5270R congrats +++++
Rose gold amplifies better any angles of the case under the light.
love the 5270R
the white dial of the 5170G is too clinic/boring to me, but love their Breguet markers. So, my bespoke=compilation of my tastes ;-) www.watchprosite.com