Part V: Face-Off Legend Divers Blancpain FF vs. Omega PloProf

Sep 29, 2009,10:02 AM
 

Round 5: Casing, Dial and Crown

Blancpain FF


Very fine finishing, mirror polished all over the casing and crown with solid case back. It has soft iron inner case shielding the movement. While mirror polished casing is prone to scratches, but they are easy to be polished away.


It has the word "BLANCPAIN" engraved at the side

The solid case back is also highly polished and very glossy, engraved with the serial number. I am not sure whether the serial number is=running production number.


The solid case back with engraved serial number

The screwed-in crown is protected by protruded side casing and it is big enough for my finger to wind it.

Case Dimensions:

Thickness: 15.50 mm
Diameter: 45 mm
Lug width: 23 mm

The watch is rated 300 m (1000 feet) Water resistant, although it has a name 50 Fathhoms=91m. But I guess the name just pay tribute to the classic 50 Fatthoms.


Fifty Fathoms, but 300m WR (1000 feet)

The dial is perfect, the font size is just nice, not too big/small with beautiful raised markers. The domed sapphire crystal makes the watch very unique and beautiful. Blancpain spent long hours to design the crystal that capture the muscular ambiance of the 1953 original. The date window is located at the 4:30 position and the size of the window is adequate.


Simple and beautiful dial with proportionate font size


The curved sapphire crystal is outstanding

+ Beautiful case finishing
+ Crown size is just nice
+ The curved sapphire crystal is absolutely stunning
+ Antimagnetic case

- The wordings engraved on the case back is not alligned horizontally


Omega PloProf

Very chunky SS case with fine brushed and has polished bevels. PloProf is definetely the heaviest watch that I ever own. The Ploprof has an automatic helium escape valve located on the side of the case at the 4 o’clock position. This feature allows helium atoms to escape during decompression, and is particularly useful for professional divers operating from diving bells.


Helium valve

The Ploprof’s case cannot be mistaken for that of any other watch: the screwed-in crown is located at 9 o’clock with unique crown protector.


The unique crown protector, hallmark of PloProf


The centre piece of the two-piece oriented caseback features a background of straight, parallel waves with a polished OMEGA logo, the word “Seamaster” and the famous Seahorse on a matt surface. The centre piece is sealed in place with an outer screw-in ring with black-chromed engraving of “1200m/4000ft”, “Ploprof”, and “OMEGA 8500 Co-Axial Escapement.”


The case back with nice engravings

The Ploprof has a polished, lacquered black dial with an applied polished OMEGA name and logo. The polished indexes are coated with white Super-LumiNova, as are the varnished hour and seconds hands. The oversized minute hand is crafted from orange aluminium and is coated with white Super-LumiNova. The date window is at the 4:30 position.

Case Dimensions:
Inner diameter with bezel: 40mm
Outer diameter: 44mm
Thickness: 18 mm
Lug width: 24 mm


The PloProf is water resistant to an astounding 1200 metres (4000 feet).


1200m, too deep for a deskdiver like me

+ Excellent case finishing
+ Great case back engraving
+ Unique (hate it or love it) casing with trademark crown protector
+ Helium escape valve


Verdict:

Both are excellent in their case finishing, PloProf is more unique due to its design, but Blancpain's dial and the curved sapphire crystal make FiftyFathoms really special.
I cannot find any serious faults at both watches. Simply outstanding. [B]Five (5) Stars for both.[/B]


More posts: PloprofSeamaster

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Outstanding serial review, Hary . . .

 
 By: Dr No : September 29th, 2009-21:48
. . . I'd been withholding comment until now, but even if there are more installments, I'd like first to say thanks for assembling this beautifully photographed serial review, and second, I can't wait for the performance testing! With anticipation, Art

Great comparison!

 
 By: Peter  : September 29th, 2009-23:13
Thks for sharing

I've been traveling lately but now I have read from Part I.

 
 By: Ruckdee : September 30th, 2009-04:16
This is a very interesting, objective comparison of two fine timepieces. I have never had the chance to strap this Blancpain on my wrist before. The flushed, roundness of the case profile and the bezel makes it look very refined and special indeed. And th... 

Great "face-off" comparison - again

 
 By: hans_jorgen_1968 : September 30th, 2009-07:50
..Looking forward to part VI . Movement or tech stuff eventually ;-) Thanks for sharing BR Hans