Some thoughts on the Jaeger Lecoultre Hybris Mechanica 11.

Feb 07, 2022,10:28 AM
 

I already reviewed the Jaeger Lecoultre Hybris Mechanica in 2014, when it was unveiled, but I could  handle the definitive watch, which will be very soon sent to its owner. 


I furtively saw it at the SIHH, this year, but I could take more time to appreciate it, during my  last visit at the Manufacture, in April 2019, and take pictures of it. 

Aesthetically, it is not far from the prototype. Here is the picture I took in 2014. 


You will immediately see that the G Clef at 8 o' clock and the words " Repetition Minutes " have gone, which is a good thing, I think. 


I remember my feelings very well, when I discovered it, and they didn't change. 

The Hybris Mechanica 11 joins the form and the function, and is very well made. 

Before the " 11 " we didn't have an ultra thin complication in the Hybris Mechanica family. 

With the " 11 " the challenge has been fulfilled in a brilliant way. 

There is nothing easy to make an ultra thin minute repeater and a flying tourbillon in the same watch, and Jaeger Lecoultre did it. At the point that this is the thinner minute repeater of the market, with a height of only 7, 9 mm. 

Indeed, the Vacheron Constantin Patrimony Ultra Thin Minute Repeater is 8, 09 mm thick, with a manual winding movement ( Cal 1731 ) :


Add the fact that the movement is automatic, and you will understand how the challenge was tough. 

Jaeger Lecoultre proved another thing to the skeptic of automatic movements in a high end watch. Indeed, there are very few automatic movements in high end watches which are to my taste... I can mention here Girard-Perregaux with some of their Tourbillons with gold bridges, and till the unveiling of the Hybris Mechanica 11, I didn't see other watches. 


Here, the Calibre 362 has its rotor " hidden " on the dial side, which let you admire the back side without any " round mobile intruder ". 

The photo showing the discreet rotor, surrounding the dial, which you can see through the openings:


The Cal 362 is superbly decorated and very well finished. And one important point I wanted to check in the definitive watch: its rotor is silent. It was not the case with the prototype. 





The second point I wanted to verify was the quality of the minute repeater sound. On the prototype, I guessed it was promising, and the Manufacture told me that they still had to work on it. 

On the definitive watch, the sound is not as high as a Master Minute Repeater ( circa 70 Db ) with " only " 65  Db, but it is rich, and very pleasant to hear. I would even say it is " mature ". An excellent good point. 

So, if I am convinced by the fact that a high end watch can house an automatic movement, I am much less convinced by the presence of a Tourbillon, even if it is a flying one. 

Indeed, I dislike Tourbillons which make a " hole " in the dial, like it is the case here. I much prefer when they are on the back side or when they are part of the dial like a Gyrotourbillon or a Reverso Platinum Tourbillon Skeleton ( 2004 ). 


I do understand its presence, for the reason I mentioned, linked to the exceptional character of watches belonging to the Hybris Mechanica line, but still... 

Though, I can't deny it is a very good watch, well made, with a superb movement and an impressive ultra thin case.

And it sounds so good! 

Best,

Nicolas


More posts: Ballon BleuDuometreFlying TourbillonHybris MechanicaJaeger LeCoultre

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

đŸ€©

 
 By: Jp75 : February 7th, 2022-10:50
Beautiful picture of a dream watch. I agree that removing the extra text and G-note symbol makes the dial much more attractive. Also think there are few „high end“ watch which are automatic, would just add some VC watch the ultra-thin caliber 1120. Regard... 

It is indeed a very speaking watch, I like the architecture of the movement, somehow it reminds me of the old pocket watch repeaters JLC used to make, the tourbillon its not a “dealbreaker” for me, yes, I know the general consensus... but it has that

 
 By: ZSHSZ : February 7th, 2022-11:05
harmonious calming effect when one glances down the wrist... It’s also plausible at lest for my taste the fact that the tourbillon doesn’t cut in the markets, and it’s size is proportional to the dial. The only downside( for meat lest), is that I will nev... 

Same here

 
 By: Jp75 : February 7th, 2022-11:20
Your quote“ The only downside 
 is that I will never own one: I was thinking exactly the same when looking at the beautiful dial details 🧐. Well, that makes it easier to look at the beauty without thinking on whether to buy or not. A bit like walking thru... 

superb piece

 
 By: keks : February 7th, 2022-11:05
lovely dial texture... i do not mind the tourbillon hole at all... but would think if the tourbillon was only visible from the back it would be an ultimate stealth piece! wow what a cool piece that would be! especially had it been made in a polished titan... 

Well said.

 
 By: amanico : February 7th, 2022-14:24

Very impressive

 
 By: takman : February 7th, 2022-14:42
I love thin watches and this is truly amazing with the complications JLC managed to fit in here. The peripheral rotor is also a nice touch and almost makes it look like manual wind. I agree the tourbillon is a bit intrusive but at least there is no date w... 

I remember thinking to myself, when it launched...

 
 By: watchme : February 7th, 2022-15:18
"Hmmm, VC has the 'thinnest' manual-wind minute repeater in the world at SIHH 2014, with sweep seconds, and JLC quietly comes along with a 'nuclear bomb' and presents a 'thinner', automatic minute repeater WITH a flying tourbillon and flying seconds! If t... 

Exactly.

 
 By: InHavenPro : February 7th, 2022-17:21
That's why JLC remains my overall favorite manufacture! Cheers, Filip

Me too.

 
 By: amanico : February 7th, 2022-17:24

I like it tremendously....

 
 By: InHavenPro : February 7th, 2022-15:59
yes, the dial would be nicer/cleaner without the tourbillon hole, but I love tourbillons so I find it forgivable design-wise; and as you emphasize, it is done purposefully in line with the whole historical concept for the Hybris Mechanica line.... The onl... 

Extremely fascinating!

 
 By: MTR : February 7th, 2022-20:25
A piece of watchmaking art that I didn't even know. I have so much to learn!! The hole in the dial created by the tourbillon doesn't bother me at all. On the contrary, I find it very harmonious together with the openings around the dial. At least when I l... 

How about blued...

 
 By: mdg : February 7th, 2022-22:12
...or even better, gold hands?

Heated blue would be great.

 
 By: amanico : February 7th, 2022-22:13

I would love to know if JLC will put this rotor inside other models!

 
 By: eklektik : February 10th, 2022-22:55
A very interesting watch, with a good mix of old/new style on the dial, very pure and balanced! I agree with all your points: clean dial & tourbillon at the back. I would love to hear it! How many were made? Thanks for sharing these exclusive shots!! Best... 

75 pieces, if my memory serves me well, and yes, there was another one with a peripheral rotor...

 
 By: amanico : February 10th, 2022-23:19
The MGT Minute Repeater Perpetual Calendar, from 2019. ...  

My pleasure, Jacques. :)))

 
 By: amanico : February 11th, 2022-14:56

Stunning piece!

 
 By: Freccero : February 13th, 2022-04:10

Thanks, PP5170G.

 
 By: amanico : February 13th, 2022-07:16

Thanks for reading, Louise.

 
 By: amanico : February 14th, 2022-06:51

I totally understand. ;)

 
 By: amanico : February 25th, 2022-05:07

Wow cool!

 
 By: Darron : March 1st, 2022-02:09

Yes, very astute.

 
 By: amanico : March 1st, 2022-06:35