jrwong23 (aka watchthebin)
[Moderator]
14255
Ah I understand now Andrew
I see your perspective and can understand what you mean now. Thanks for sharing your thoughts 
Well all brands do some form of marketing... Part of the business
For the HM5 owners, I compared the HM5 and HMX and there are some differences which I feel make the HM5 more robust and feels it commands a higher price tag.
Firstly the HM5 is either in precious metals, carbon Macrolon or titanium. The HMX is in steel with some titanium in the case.
The HM5 also has a much bigger wrist presence with a larger case and more heft, plus it can "open up" to allow "charging" of the super luminova - all these I feel makes the HM5 feel more luxurious and special if you will.
The HM5's time display also looks better and more legible than the HMX IMHO.
Overall I also find the finishing of the case of the HM5 look and feel nicer.
The HMX is also very special being an anniversary piece and also has a very nice curvy case (great design!) and it is definitely worthy of being an anniversary piece but I still think the HM5 is a more robustly built watch which commands a higher price point.
For small wrists like mine, the HMX does fit my wrist more than the bigger HM5
Cheers
Robin
MB&F HMX launch to celebrate 10th anniversary of MB&F
This evening I am fortunate to be invited by Max Busser and the Hour Glass Singapore for a dinner to launch the MB&F HMX. X is the Roman numeral for 10 to mark the 10th anniversary of this independent watchmaker. A quick post here to share with fellow Pur...
Nice on the spot reporting Robin!!! (but...)
and great pics, thanks for sharing it with us and taking the time to post them! I love the HM3 on that gold strap! The watch and marketing BS itself about the HMX... umm... is it right to say that swallowing a mouthful of your own vomit is more enjoyable....
Thanks Andrew
Could you clarify your comments on the HMX? I thought it was a very nice piece so am confused on your comments Cheers Robin
Nothing against the watches Robin...
I like the look of them (cross between the HM5 and Romain Jerome Subcraft) but it is actually the marketing story that goes with it which I had just read before seeing your post which makes me feel like a sucker. I especially found joy in the part of ' Re...
Ah I understand now Andrew
I see your perspective and can understand what you mean now. Thanks for sharing your thoughts Well all brands do some form of marketing... Part of the business For the HM5 owners, I compared the HM5 and HMX and there are some differences which I feel make...
Would be interesting to see a side by side comparison with the HM5
or with the Romain Jerome who also came out with the curved version, I remember everyone comparing the HM5 and RJ starship when they came out at the same time a few years back. It is really interesting to hear your thoughts on the levels of finish and how...
Looking at the past HM
I would think it's quite likely that there will be variants of this HMX appearing down the road...
So you mean...
We will probably see a whole range of super affordable, special favour, made for collectors, 10th Anniversary pieces for the friends in recognition of those who supported MB&F from the start? ;) Cheers Andrew
haha...
Andrew I do understand and share your feelings. Having said that, given the small production & their business strategy centered around 'limited supply' concepts, I don't blame him for trying to reach out to new customers most of the time. And when you...
Thanks, Andrew, very interesting points and...
putting into words some vaguely discomforting "feelings" that some have been feeling. Marketing is one thing, any realist recognizes the need for marketing, but I think the thing that bothers lots of Purists are sincere ideas used insincerely... (above no...
Both Thomas & Andrew are well valid from my perspective.
IMHO, both Andrew & Thomas made very valid points. Being a big fan of MB&F, i love their openess. Period. But if they would like to go after new customers, we totally understand the needs as they are running a business. But if they are creating a ...
Thanks Robin ...very interesting
and these watches are ...simply extraordinary A great meal also Best Christian
Glad you like the post Christian
Nice watches and nice food Perfect pairing Cheers Robin
The VIDEO and thanks for the live report!
I like the way peolpe wearing MB&Fs choose their strap color. It is a move which fits the brand's spirit greatly. I find this HMX very nice, maybe smoother thant the HM5. I wonder which are the features integrated in this one and what are its dimensio...
Thanks for the video Mark!
Really cool video! The dimensions are 46.8 x 44.3 x 20.7 mm according to MB&F's website. Key features: Bi-directional jumping hours and trailing minutes, displayed by dual reflective sapphire crystal prisms with integrated magnifying lens. Cheers robi...
Thanks a lot Robin for this live report!
I see the watch soon so I will make my comments once I see it. Fx
Sure Ronald. Specs from MB&F website
Limited edition of 4 x 20 pieces in grade 5 titanium and stainless steel Case: Grade 5 titanium and stainless steel with detailing in Lotus black, British racing green, Bugatti blue or Ferrari red. Dimensions: 46.8 x 44.3 x 20.7 mm Number of components: 4...
The sellita's movement base is a poor choice.
I really can't undertand why they chose it.
Some collectors told me the same
I guess it helps lower the cost and speed of developing this watch. For those who need a high end movement, this HMX is probably not for them I guess Cheers Robin
I believe so Ronald
Max did say he wanted to make the HMX more affordable Cheers Robin
Ok, but do you really believe it?
MB&F do not produce low cost watches, they turned the watches into artworks, always providing the best in design and mechanics. I know your policy about the price tag, but i don't think the GP basis would have increased the final price so heavily
I won't know for sure to be honest
I chose to believe what I heard in this case That Max wanted the HMX to be a more affordable HM. Why he did this, the intentions - whether to really thank his fans (including me) so they can get an anniversary piece at a good price (which I really respect...
Why's that?
I thought Sellita always provided good solid workhorse type movements? Cheers Andrew
fantastic live report !
enjoyed it thoroughly and lovely photos too. Thanks for taking the time and trouble to share them. Cheers !
Nice!
I want an HM4! Santa Claus, I've been a good boy this year! The Frog with the gold strap is awesome. That's cool.
Tx Robin...
Just to be sure, I think this is yet another iteration/variation based on HM5 right?
No Jester it is quite different
The HMX has a different movement and case. Cheers Robin
I was quite disappointed when I saw the HMX, to be honest...
Is it just me or does iPhone 5C come to mind? similar to an existing product cheaper/watered down variant comes in colours Coincidentally, the HMX's display window does look like its got 2 SIM cards in it, doesn't it? Haha. I too am not a fan of the Selli...
Double SIM cards lol!
Your analogy to the iPhone 5C is funny For me, I only have an LM so this may be a good HM for me. But I must admit compared to the other HMs, especially the HM5, there is no denying the HMX is made to be a lower price variant for sure Cheers Robin
It was fun to attend another MB&F Function
I flew up from Sydney again to attend the launch and enjoyed the company of the friends I made last time. My understanding is that this is a one off concept. My view is that the HMX is exactly what it is meant to be a piece of fun. You cannot compare it t...
Hey Rene
Glad to see you again that night! And glad you enjoyed the evening and the post. Let me know again next time you drop by and maybe we can organize a PuristS gtg Your point on the HMX is well put. Thanks for sharing that perspective! Cheers Robin