One swallow does not a summer make...

Mar 31, 2015,13:05 PM
 

Dear Mark, I appreciate your thoughts on the long term development and contribution of a brand, both for itself as for watchmaking in general. This is why, Rolex, Omega and Patek enjoy the appreciation and status they have today, and this is why other brands struggle and/or have to invest huge amounts of money and energy into marketing efforts.

It also explains why those brands are so defensive in claiming the first, the fastest, the most complicated, the best xxx (fill in ad libitum).

It does not come with surpass to me that Patek got all the buzz around Ref. 5524G - for free, and deservedly so. Not because the watch is such an outstanding piece, but because they developed their brand with such care and respect to both watchmaking and their own tradition that such a watch instantly turned into a talking piece. The talking piece of Basel.

As Oliver wrote: other brands would have killed to get such exposure. Patek gets it for free.

And this also - by extension - implies that watch aficionados have a very precise idea about the essence of Patek. There is substance people understand and care about. This is the result of what I stated above, and this is the reason why I think that Patek absolutely deserved the attention they got.

Yes, Mark, I think this is a good year for Patek. Not great, but good.

But we also should appreciate what Breguet presented this year. Forget about the Marine, that's a business case. But the Tradition is an essential Breguet. as is the Reine de Naples The former collection is now 10 years old, and very close to its original version.

The additions this year show something like a direction Breguet is going to, offering really indigenous complications (or better: proprietary interpretations of such). True, the brand is still very much rooted in its past, and certainly does not have the forward-looking attitude of cutting edge watchmaking Abraham-Luois Breguet had.

But the Tradition shows that the brand follows a line over a decade with integrity, which is always a good start and essential for long term relevance. I liked a lot what they offered this year, and certainly look forward to seeing more.

Cheers, and again thanks for your thoughts.
Magnus


This message has been edited by Ornatus-Mundi on 2015-03-31 13:06:18

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

BaselWorld-Report 2015: The saga continues: 2. part of Magnus’ & Oliver’s quick overview

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-08:54
… another round of appetizers while we are already working on more detailed reports. ...  

Omega

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:01
The main brand within the Swatch Group conglomerate is always a stressful appointment for us: many, many novelties, and very light to shoot ;-) First and most important, a completely new Globemaster , the new first Master Chronometer (certified by the Con...  

Interesting Regatta [nt]

 
 By: Mark in Paris : March 29th, 2015-10:50

The Globemaster wrist shot . . .

 
 By: Dr No : March 29th, 2015-12:23
. . . is another nail in my coffin. :-) I won't say I'm dead set on getting one, at least not yet, but it's highly tempting.

Art, it is, in many way which we shall reveal soon...

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 30th, 2015-00:11
not perfect, but well done! Magnus

Patek Philippe

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:05
Much has already been talked about THIS ( Ref. 5524G ): But there was more, e.g. this all red gold Nautilus Ref. 5711R (worn on the wrist of a very cooperative young lady ;-)). Note that brown-grey dial – close up and you see why Patek is so coveted! The ...  

To me, these pics confirm a good year for Patek. [nt]

 
 By: Mark in Paris : March 29th, 2015-10:51
No message body

+1

 
 By: small-luxury-world : March 29th, 2015-13:11
Some brands would kill or pay a fortune to get that much attention :-)

True...

 
 By: Mark in Paris : March 29th, 2015-14:53
and I guess that Marketting creates a part of the dream...

A Good Year??????

 
 By: jkingston : March 31st, 2015-02:14
I have a hard time saying "a good year for Patek", unless "good year" equals "commercial year". To me a good year requires technical innovation, new movements, something that advances the watchmaking art. Those are things to celebrate. There were no new m... 

Compared to previous years, this is to me a good year.

 
 By: Mark in Paris : March 31st, 2015-02:49
It is nonsense to me to expect to have new movements nearly every year, even if I'd like something new on the side of the manual 215. The design and tests of a new movement is a huge work and needs several years of investment in time and money. But we had... 

One swallow does not a summer make...

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 31st, 2015-13:05
Dear Mark, I appreciate your thoughts on the long term development and contribution of a brand, both for itself as for watchmaking in general. This is why, Rolex, Omega and Patek enjoy the appreciation and status they have today, and this is why other bra... 

Words of wisdom Magnus

 
 By: Mark in Paris : March 31st, 2015-14:18
I also think that the Tradition line holds a special place in watchmaking and is very different from the rest of Breguet's offer. Breguet is the name many of the complications we know today come from. Even if I think a part of the collection is not true a... 

Gentleman, I read quite a few valid points ...

 
 By: small-luxury-world : April 4th, 2015-10:08
and thought it could be an interesting discussion together with Jeff. Well, once more he just joined the party with one statement, which could be biased as he is in charge for the Breguet magazine. A dislike for the "silence", Jeff. I just like passionate... 

Some people just can't keep being objective

 
 By: Mark in Paris : April 4th, 2015-13:28
and hence lose their credibility

Romain Gauthier

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:09
Here we were taught who different finishing’s, all at the same highest level, could turn an already excellent watch into a different entity. We were quite surprised how well that worked! Logical One in two very different iterations. A two-piece only colle...  

Tudor

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:12
One of the greatest surprises for us – Rolex’ small sister becomes independent with its first in-house movement, Caliber MT5621 (“MT” for “Manufacture Tudor”): Very interesting details we will discuss later… But one thing already now: Complete independenc...  

Urwerk

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:14
The small Zurich/Geneva brand presented iterations, such as a metal bracelet for the UR-210 … … and a wrist holding frame for the UR-1001 “TITAN” pocket watch: ...  

Zenith

 
 By: Ornatus-Mundi : March 29th, 2015-09:18
For the brand’s 150 th anniversary this year nothing could be better suited than a new movement – and here it is: the Zenith Elite 6150 (‘6’ for Elite, ‘150’ for the anniversary): 100h power reserve, stored in two barrels: Not only that, Zenith presented ...