Lots of options when one moves away from the hype pieces. I cannot fathom why the 5159 is going for less than half the price of a simple Nautilus? I also have a Nautilus (my beloved 5712/1A) but I got it when it was discounted at the ADs.
For me the winner is the vc 47112 (top left), then the silver dial 5270. The vc just had the best spacing on the dial, case, lugs, hunter back, MP disc. I love it.