Thanks ;-) [nt]

Nov 12, 2012,07:46 AM
 

No message body

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

My Chinese Tourbillon - One Year Later...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 4th, 2012-00:18
It has been almost a year since the purchase of my first Chinese-made tourbillon and I thought itd be a good idea to revisit this rather inexpensive example of one of watch makings most difficult-to-execute mechanisms. And so, I have been wearing the wat...  

You are spot on!

 
 By: elliot55 : November 4th, 2012-09:46
Hey Fernando - There is definitely a lot of potential here. I'd like to see some more inspired designs and attention to detail. I think we know that's coming. - Scott

Might be good

 
 By: rnaden : November 4th, 2012-06:08
for the future pricing of the other brands - if the Chinese can bring up the level of originality and finishing quality while keeping their prices down, it might see the start of reduction of prices that will make watches more affordable for many of us. I... 

I am surprised too...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 4th, 2012-09:48
... with the watch's overall accuracy. Very impressive for sure. And you are correct - if the Chinese (and others) can do the finish work up to the Swiss standards, as well as come up with some more inspired designs, then prices have to come down. - Scott... 

i was very happy with my chinese tourbillon

 
 By: G99 : November 4th, 2012-10:06
I only let it go as i honestly have no use for a tourbillon in my life. It is a real shame that yours is in a radiomir style case as that automatically makes a lot of people think 'chinese fake' which the movement certainly is not. Mine was also very accu...  

I am totally digging...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 4th, 2012-10:12
... the power reserve. I purchased the wrong design, that's for sure. Sorry you had to let yours go. I was thinking of getting another one soon. - Scott

i have a similar piece

 
 By: lien : November 4th, 2012-21:42
and it does everything u described until a rainy day when it get wet and i sent it to get repaired. the watchman told me since most of its parts r stamped hence lack durability over time, can anyone confirmed that? na interesting toy nonetheless cheers, E... 

impact stamping has on durability?

 
 By: johnswatch1 : November 5th, 2012-00:59
Aren't many of the parts in an ETA movement stamped? What impact would stamping have on the durability of the materials? Are stamped parts usually made using softer alloys? I'm not as hopeful that quality Chinese tourbillons will reduce global prices - th... 

I do not think the stamping of parts...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 5th, 2012-07:10
... is the issue here. As you state, many movements utilize stamped parts, such as wheels and hands. I do believe the Chinese-made tourbillons will have to exhibit more finishing and attention to detail before the Swiss would even consider lowering prices... 

I doubt the swiss will...

 
 By: G99 : November 5th, 2012-07:52
I doubt the swiss will lower their prices. It is more likely that the chinese will raise theirs as their quality improves. As for cases, they should stick to round cases which no one can claim they invented. Then everything should be good. G On Nov 5, 201... 

Stamped Parts...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 5th, 2012-06:58
... are used in many types of movements. And so, durability is not the issue. Perhaps your watch guy is afraid to work on your waterlogged tourbillon. Just sayin'. - Scott

the wet chinese tourbillion

 
 By: lien : November 5th, 2012-07:46
was keeping good time 1 days after getting wet even, & i ask the guy to dry it for me and he warned me about it... thx for clarification on the stamping parts, think i should visit the watch smith sometime cheers, Ed

I recall very clearly ...

 
 By: AndrewD : November 7th, 2012-19:00
... visiting the Sea-Gull Boutique in Hong Kong a few years ago and looking at a series of single and double tourbillons manufactured over a period of about 5 years. There was a very clear improvement in finishing of parts and aesthetic design. The prices... 

I just received a fresh copy of...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 8th, 2012-07:06
... WatchTime - it has the new AP Royal Oak Thin on the cover. Ironically, there's a pretty good article about Chinese tourbillons, particularly the line from MemoOrigin, which I believe uses the Seagull movements. I am thinking of getting one from Stuhrl... 

Interesting feedback

 
 By: mark_third : November 12th, 2012-07:22
May I ask how much it cost?

About a grand...

 
 By: elliot55 : November 12th, 2012-07:35
.... search Stuhrling on Amazon. - Scott

Thanks ;-) [nt]

 
 By: mark_third : November 12th, 2012-07:46