dustin.wu
44
PT
Jul 23, 2020,01:48 AM
1. The mechanism is not as good as PP or AL. I posted my comments and you can review if you like. But since this topic is to choose from one of the FP rattrapante so I think nothing to discuss here.
2. I would say if you occasionally wear it than I recommend PT version. It has some mystery enticement that you never get tire of it. But the weight WILL push you away from daily use. I tried hard but it simply is not for daily use.
3. I don’t like the rubber. Mine has problem getting off from day 3. You can search my post. But the problem is without the rubber my feeling is the bracelet should be at lease 1mm wider especially near the “lugs” position because of the big 44mm or the proportion looks weird. The rubber does a good job hiding this proportion issue to make the curve smooth. Without the rubber I strongly believe Mr Journe should make the bracelet wider at least at the beginning of the bracelet. Look at the new Parmigiani you will know how important to hide or decorate the curve between the lug and the bracelet. Look at PP,AP,VC sport watch and observe their lug to the bracelet how nicely they deal with the curve you will know what I mean. The rubber more or less did the job but if you take off the rubber ( which I like) you need to modify a bit to make it looks better.
4. I seriously consider to sell my rubber PT for a new one without rubber. But the above thought stops me, at least at this stage. Also a source told me maybe less than 30 rubber version are sold so it’s actually a rare one for the future? ( not sure or confirmed) . Maybe it’s also a good reference for your decision.
Cheers and good luck
Comments:
view entire thread
The Rattrapante - let us hear your thoughts?
By: ChristianDK : July 22nd, 2020-14:10
I have been thinking a lot about the rattrapante this summer. I always had a very keen eye on this watch but since we have seen the version without rubber inserts rolling out, my interest has returned I always had my eyes on the Pt with its lovely purple ...
My thoughts
By: cmmnsens : July 22nd, 2020-14:59
I like the aesthetics of the PT model better (color and dial). But realistically the Ti version is more ‘livable’ for my lifestyle. Lightweight and darker finish. If only it had the same guilloche dial as the PT... then that would be perfect!
I think I can follow why you prefer the Pt for this reference, Nik
By: ChristianDK : July 23rd, 2020-00:05
A Rattrapante is something more delicate and refined. Where the Centigraphe is closer to the sports theme. I also think the Pt version is more immediately appealing in terms of aesthetics. Ed’s picture that I attached in my post, says it all I think. Howe...
A couple of months ago I tried both the Ti and the Pt at the Boutique.
By: ZSHSZ : July 22nd, 2020-15:22
I share your observations, the Platinum is much-much nicer, but weights a ton, I’m sure you can get used to it, but still too heavy or me(and I do like lefty pieces). The Titanium is a pleasure to wear, very unique moment design, but I didn’t like the res...
You can take a look here, Venus is a good example.
By: als1678 : July 23rd, 2020-07:52
www.hodinkee.com I have had a chance to play with the titanium one, definitely felt wobbly. Have heard the same from others. But of course you might have had a different experience. I am sure that adjustment matters. My understanding is that it is...
Thanks for your reply and link
By: ChristianDK : July 24th, 2020-08:54
is it because it uses the clamp brake system you say it is vintage inspired? this is very a common system also used by Patek and most others. Its interesting that you compare it to Patek and Lange because I would claim that this one is better in some ways...
I lack an in-depth knowledge of these references.
By: BigAppleBill : July 22nd, 2020-16:16
So I would only add that I really prefer the open work seen through the subdials on the Ti version. Also, prefer Ti for the lightness and toughness because it is a sports watch after all. But they’re all gorgeous little machines, so there’s really no bad ...
An other point for the Ti.
By: ChristianDK : July 23rd, 2020-07:09
First time I hear that point about the apertures in the subdials. I do see your point though. 😊 thanks for chiming in.
Great analysis of the dial
By: ChristianDK : July 23rd, 2020-07:16
It’s not mere decoration but the decoration of the dial serves a purpose and helps the legibility. Probably why the Pt dial just “speaks” more to me. And you are absolutely right. This isn’t a true sports watch. More of a luxury watch on a bracelet. The P...
I have the gold w inserts.
By: shafran : July 22nd, 2020-18:47
you can't go wrong with either choice.i love the open work ti and the purple dial plat. But i do prefer the rubber inserts. Makes it sportier
Yours is truly Beautiful. And it suits you really well.
By: ChristianDK : July 23rd, 2020-07:24
I if I could steal your dial and put it in the Ti I would be happy 😆 The rubber vs not rubber is definitely a two camps discussion. A bit like the good old chocolate vs vanilla discussion. I can see how it makes the watch more sporty and also unusual. I j...
No issues.
By: shafran : July 27th, 2020-18:18
I guess I am lucky.
PT
By: dustin.wu : July 23rd, 2020-01:48
1. The mechanism is not as good as PP or AL. I posted my comments and you can review if you like. But since this topic is to choose from one of the FP rattrapante so I think nothing to discuss here. 2. I would say if you occasionally wear it than I recomm...
Thank you so much Dustin
By: ChristianDK : July 24th, 2020-10:00
i reread your former review. thanks a lot! great work, even if I didnt agree completely with all your points. 1. Im not sure why you consider the PP and ALS better. I perhaps got the impression that the complexity of these movements made a bigger impressi...
Mine is my sporty watch.
By: shafran : July 27th, 2020-18:21
I think it can be worn every day. I just like to rotate with my other watches. I also think it is as nice as the patek and ALS, but also less expensive.
👍😊 [nt]
By: ChristianDK : July 27th, 2020-20:39
Thank you so much for chiming in Ed!
By: ChristianDK : July 24th, 2020-10:09
First, im glad that you find that your piece works as it is supposed to. Its the same impression I have so far, but I also acknowledge that some have found issues. I think a lot of difficulty in building aRattrapante is to get the parts to interact perfec...