WatchProSite|Market|Digest
WatchProSite|Market|Digest

Breguet

Hi John

 

I am not pretending to be in any way an expert and certainly not in your league. I am just sharing what I saw with my eyes, there were several screws that were 'scratched' or otherwise not more than poorly finished--it gave the impression of 'fine details being overlooked'. The overall 'glow' of the movement--purely personal--seemed dim and even darkish compared to my VC Les Historiques. I was surprised that the Breguet did not hold a candle to it. Again, only my opinion, my eyes.

Funny, when I bought it, I was of course, 'blown away'. But when I got it home, and examined it under magnification at length, I was honestly shocked at the what I perceived as oversights.

I respect your knowledge and contributions greatly, John, and as I said before, I do not mean to provoke anyone or insult anyone.

But I am not saying Breguet is not a wonderful brand. I am only saying, it made an impression on me, and I would have to look very closely at a Breguet in the future before I 'trusted' it would be Magnificent.

I have also found a damaged hand on a new Patek. And other such oversights.

It;s not really an indictment of Breguet.  But worth mentioning?

  login to reply
Related Content
expand_more
Historiques
💰210 Marketplace Listings for Vacheron Constantin›
15 Comments view entire thread 

breguet reputation

 
By: ange : December 26th, 2007-10:51
Can anyone comment on Breguet's reputation as a watchmaker. I understand it was bought (and is owned) by Swatch Watch Group. How does this affect quality as well as a Breguet watch holding its value. Thanks much.

Good, great...... maybe not truly excellent?

 
By: Mostel : December 26th, 2007-11:32
I recently sold my Breguet 5237, disappointed with the finish of the movement, and botched screws. It may have been a fluke example--it may be bad reason to sell a watch, it may be my perception only, but it made an impression on me. I wouldn't spend the ... 

I don't suppose you took any pictures did you?

 
By: ei8htohms : December 26th, 2007-12:54
Hi Mostel, "Botched screws" is pretty strong, how bad were they? Visible cosmetic damage is possible with any brand, but it's surprising on a Breguet at least. _john

Hi John

 
By: Mostel : December 27th, 2007-15:33
I am not pretending to be in any way an expert and certainly not in your league. I am just sharing what I saw with my eyes, there were several screws that were 'scratched' or otherwise not more than poorly finished--it gave the impression of 'fine details... 

This is the place to air your issues

 
By: Bill : December 26th, 2007-14:43
Please let us know. Though thing seem sleepy from time to time. The passion runs high in this forum. Help us understand and help us resolve your issue. It is a real pleasure to have this forum to be heard and to be supported. Best for 08 Bill

Let's hear it....

 
By: BHK9 : December 26th, 2007-18:36
Hi Mostel, Totally agreed with Bill!Voice it out and the best if you have any pictures around.I am totally stunn to hear that especially with a Bruguet!!!simply unbelievable.Admitting that the giant SWATCH group acquired the brand but knowing and adimring... 

Reverting to the original question....

 
By: Tassos : December 29th, 2007-10:29
I am an admirer of A.L. Breguet art and inventions... I own ( proudly) a perpetual calendar ref. 5327...I can make sacrifices in order to have one day a Messidor tourbillon.. I, personally feel happy that Breguet is belonging to the Swatch group... If you... 

probably my camera is not good enough,but

 
By: lutz : December 30th, 2007-05:00
I cannot remember seeing any flaws,perhaps a microscope would serve better ;-) but in earnest I have some difficulties to believe the term "botched screws" with a Breguet,esp.a fine one as the 5237. The camera I used is certainly no professional makro-equ...  

You might want to post the same question on the Patek, Lange and Vacheron fora.

 
By: mkvc : January 26th, 2008-23:15
You would probably receive some interesting answers. I think it's generally agreed that Breguet makes very nice watches, and it's understood that every watch brand establishes its identity through a combination of marketing and watchmaking. However, outsi...