You listed several important factors already ...

May 15, 2007,13:03 PM
 

... but for starting, please permit me to correct two small errors:

The UN Maxi Diver is rated to 300 meters, if I recall correctly, and the GO Evolution Sport does not come with both, the steel bracelet and the rubber strap. You have to purchase the other one extra.

Hhmmm ... it is difficult to give a good advice. Honestly, I like all three of the watches you mentioned, and I would even add another one to this list: the Chopard Deep One.

Of all these watches, the UN has the least unique movement, since it is based on the ETA 2892A2. So if a so-called in-house movement is really important to you, you have to drop the Maxi Diver. BUT: Especially for a sports watch that is exposed to more hazards than a more elegant timepiece, it is not at all wrong to use movement parts that can be repaired, or better: replaced by any well-trained watchmaker around the world. but how many watchmakers are able to repair a Girard-Perregaux cal. 33 , or a GO cal. 39 movement? They have to send it to the company, or national service center at least, since they would not get any parts, when they are not authorized dealers for the brand.

Regarding functionality, the small date windows, sunk into a deep tunnel, as offered by UN and GP are clearly inferior to the large panorama date of the GO. Also the clever micro-adjustment of the GO's steel bracelet is unique. On the other hand, the power reserve hands of the UN and the GP are horologically interesting, and give these watches a very special and unconventional appearance. The UN's small second hand further increases this effect. I would say, from the three you mentioned, the UN is the most unconventionally designed, including the dial structure and the semi-skeletonized hands.

I think the decision is likely to be based on style, and sympathy. And nobody can help you here, I fear ...

Regards,
Marcus

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

UN vs GO or GP?? Need opinions. Thanks.

 
 By: leopardprey : May 15th, 2007-00:43
Well, been looking to get a dive watch that is different from the Rolex watches I have. Something different than other. Narrowed it down to 3. Gerrad Perragaux Sea Hawk, Ulysee Nardin Maxi Marine Diver and Glashutte SPort Evolution. Kind of put the GP Sea... 

From a trio of magnificent watches I have got ...

 
 By: Dmitriy : May 15th, 2007-04:13
... Gerard-Perregeux. UN Maxi Diver possess true sea "person", but I would not put the given watch in one number neither with Sea Hawk nor with Sport Evolution. Why? The movement. Let it and personalized by company UN, but nevertheless is not present in i... 

You listed several important factors already ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : May 15th, 2007-13:03
... but for starting, please permit me to correct two small errors: The UN Maxi Diver is rated to 300 meters, if I recall correctly, and the GO Evolution Sport does not come with both, the steel bracelet and the rubber strap. You have to purchase the othe... 

UN

 
 By: leopardprey : May 16th, 2007-20:30

mishka

 
 By: michael_shikhman : June 6th, 2007-20:05