Mark in Paris
[Purist]
10488
My pleasure :)
It is quite a nice step to make and we can always enrich our thoughts with different views. I do that too.
I had a look at other 5059 and 5159 pictures and they indeed bring something quite different. The 5059 is a little more classical and "calm" while the 5159 is more on the "fun" side of the traditional style (the rose gold plays a lot in that feeling I have).
Yes, the "hamburger" proportions is something we see in that watch as we see it in the 3970 that I tried in J not long ago. I must say I like this too for older watches and that it is a detail I enjoyed in the 5930G. The latter is new, more 1950's, not as thicker but its proportions is something I like also in the same field.
I imagine you could try them all (this is very important) and that you could think about them for a while now (this helps to find if we will get fed up of something on the long run or not).
Best, Mark
Available on the marketplace
2,937 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1722 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
Perpetual question please.
I am considering purchasing either the 5940G or the 5159R. This will be my first QP. Currently I have the 5170G, 5110J and 5146R. ( chronograph, world time and annual calendar respectively). Any thought on these two perpetual calendars would be appreciate...
From the 5159R i love the retrograde date and the onion crown. The design is in my opinion too classical.
On the other I absolutely adore the 5940G, for me this year's best release by Patek. I generally love tonneau shapes, here perfectly combined with a PC. I would say that for a Tonneau shape the PC is ITS complication. Further the dimension are very elegan...
Both great watches
But 5940 is one of my favorites. It's slim with a nice dial layout and I am a fan of breguet numerals. Again, both are good choices for a PC but for me the 5940 wins. Also congrats on already having a great rotation of Pateks. Either one you choose will b...
Any thoughts on a trade?
I was thinking to possible make a trade for the 5940G. Perhaps the 5170G since they are both white gold. It would help reduce the cost. The Perpetual calendar function is better for me compared to the chronograph. Just thinking of my options. So may watch...
Thanks for the opinion.
I think you are correct. It is a lovely reference that is a keeper. On question. It seems that the amount of pressure it takes to open the 5170G deploy any clasp is minimal compared to my 5146R. This make me nervous since on a few occasions the deployant ...
Both are great watches but
I have a preference for the 5940G because of the case shape, the Breguet numerals which add a certain elegance and the 240 mini rotor which I find more attractive than the 324 automatic movement of the 5159R. I am biased as I own a 5940G (silver dial). I ...
I like the 5940G
The 5159 is much too cluttered for my taste. The 5940 has a clean dial and is very legible. I got a white dial 5940g.
The 5159 has a little bit of a Old Fashion look.....
which is very good in this case. The 5940 is designed for speedy legibility in my view . Both movements are top notch, I would ask my second half for opinion and go for that one. Enjoy. Best Regards Edward.
Looks like a landslide for 5940
..and I add my vote too. Unusual by unmistakeable PP DNA - in face and of course movement.
Well, I see how important this new step is in your collection
The choice of a QP from Patek is something we wish to make very special and enjoy as much as we can. You have chosen 2 unusual and very appealing models. They are both traditional but the 5159R, because of the material color but also for the round specifi...
Thank young for the comments Mark.
It is somewhat of a vexing decision. I really like the hunter case. It reminds me of my very first Patek I purchased 20 years ago, 5054 J. The hunter or officers case is quite unique making the watch special. I like the retrograde date on the 5159. I do a...
My pleasure :)
It is quite a nice step to make and we can always enrich our thoughts with different views. I do that too. I had a look at other 5059 and 5159 pictures and they indeed bring something quite different. The 5059 is a little more classical and "calm" while t...
Mark I would like your opinion on the QP
5940G-010 which is the black dial. I have a chance to acquire this as a new piece. As you know I am also considering the white dial. Currently I only have white dial watches so this might be a nice addition. Best, CB
I made a litte review about this one
I think the 5940 has a lot of charm, while not being too "original" (cushion shape case) in a way one can appreciate it on the long run with a yet traditional feeling. Here was my article: www.watchprosite.com Some watches with black dial have a s...
I'd like to give a contrarian view here
Since it will be your first QP, I would suggest going for a round shaped QP like a 5140 (recently discontinued perhaps available in NOS or used) or the more modern 5320 which can evoke vintage-feel similar to the 5940. Something I'm not completely sold on...
Both superb
Much less clear to me. I have a 3940J and 5159R and absolutely love them both. The 5159 is mesmerizing. I don't think you could go wrong with either.
Thank you.
My first Patek had a hunter case 5054J. I wore it every day for 10 years. This is why the 5159 appeals to me. I love the nostalgia and the look of the classic hunter case. I have always wanted a perpetual calendar as well.