Neither are particularly fierce LOL!

Mar 18, 2018,18:41 PM
 

However, I like the PP because its comical look gives it  a somewhat appealing personality and sense of humor. Maybe because I know the picture's provenance, is the painter's style. Regardless, they're both beautiful pieces. Congrats!

p.s. were you looking to make it a hat trick at that Into the Wild auction? smile

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Hi All, Warning!! Man eating lions out loose in the concrete jungle attending β€œinto the wild” auction ! The Pride Lions are finally hunting...

 
 By: GLau : March 17th, 2018-10:01
together for animal artworks from a charity ! Sibling rivalry of enamel dial by Master enameler Anita Porchet vs Japanese urushi (lacquer) master painter. Which one is more fierce ? LOL ! Which one do you like and why ? Cheers, Gordon What a meaningful th...  

I like the

 
 By: Passionata_george : March 17th, 2018-10:09
PP more it s more refined to my taste.

You think that lion saw something really scary? :) [nt]

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : March 17th, 2018-12:13
No message body

Your daughter πŸ˜‚

 
 By: Alkiro1 : March 17th, 2018-12:27
Afraid to be banned from the jungle πŸ˜‰ Best wishes Alkiro

LOL most probably yes 😁

 
 By: Alkiro1 : March 17th, 2018-13:01
Best wishes Alkiro

Yes, Ares501, the lion saw itself being painted by...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-10:57
Henri Rouuseau and got scared! LOL ! Cheers, Gorkk

Hi Alkiro, yes, Rosseau Lion's expression is well captured by Anita Porchet...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-10:53
in accordance with the painting "The Dream" by Henri Rosseau. Cheers,

The PP permits to recognize the motif more quickly ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : March 17th, 2018-10:39
... but in my eyes rather resembles something taken from a children's room. Additionally, the bold brand name compromises the artistic value, imho. IN this respect, the Chopard is more interesting, but without a good reading glass, it would be difficult t... 

Hi Marcus, the Patek Rouseau Lion motif is actually taken from...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:15
the Dream, a famous painting by Henri Rousseau and this panting is housed in the Momo in New York. Cheers, Gordon

With all due respect ....

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : March 19th, 2018-01:32
.... but extracting a small detail from a complex painting, ripping it from its full context, leaves a better mockery. Aside the - undisputed - excellence in the watch dial's execution, it is a piece of masterly handcraft, but not of art. It is missing an...  

Hi Marcus.....

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : March 19th, 2018-01:57
......I guess we are all entitled to our own view. I have collected works of art for many years now and know only too well that interpretation of art is an incredibly subjective issue. Interpretation is, almost uniquely, in the eye of the beholder. I thin... 

I recognize the artwork, but not my cup of tea

 
 By: piccolochimico (aka dsgalaxy1) : March 17th, 2018-10:44
It's me, i don't like figurative paintings that much However i'm more struck by the HK concrete jungle on the wall.

beautiful creatures!

 
 By: Robert65 : March 17th, 2018-10:45
Congratulations on enjoying such a wonderful event.

Hi 5980, you will appreciate them both when you...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:30
come to HK and have a GTG ! Cheers, Gordon

Wonderful pieces...

 
 By: NautNut : March 17th, 2018-11:21
...I have watch envy!

Ha Ha SPSEMOLA, no need to be envious ! I will...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:34
post photos more often then ! Cheers, Gordon

Thanks mj23, The Chopard lion is going to ...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:37
hunt after you now ! LOL ! Cheers, Gordon

Can I just say I like both?

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : March 17th, 2018-11:31
They're just too different to favour one over the other...

Yes KC...KU, you can say both because...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:38
I have the same answer ! Cheers, Gordon

I forgot you own both! πŸ˜‚

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : March 18th, 2018-13:31
The real question would be if you were forced to part with one, which would you choose to keep...?

Difficult

 
 By: Frank. : March 17th, 2018-12:05
Would not like to wear one or the other. Bit blingy. Lion looks like it's seen a ghost. Not for me. Lion has such wierd look on it's face.

Yeah

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : March 17th, 2018-14:46
Like it is scared by? Yes by what? A hunter with a big riffle? But I have to say that that is exactly what a like about this Patek. It has something comical about it without doubt. It is funny. That lion reminds me off The Cowardly Lion from The Wizard of... 

Hi Frank, yes, the Patek Lion has a weird look because this dial is the enamel version of the lion in "The Dream", a...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:40
painting by Henri Rousseau ! FYI the history of this watch www.watchprosite.com / Cheers, Gordon

me?

 
 By: Frank. : March 18th, 2018-13:56
i would rather have the painting. On the watch it just looks wierd.

Thanks avatarian74, these Lions want to...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:44
hunt down your enamel Rousseau Owl ! Cheers, Gordon

Hi Fab, thanks for your kind words ! Now these two Lions want to go to...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:45
your country for a hunt & have a GTG with your marquetry dial ! Cheers, Gordon

The PP for me.

 
 By: Mitch K : March 18th, 2018-10:02
Having both of your gems the app has a depth to it that the Chopard lacks. Both are marvelous artistryvig the PP has the edge. I’d clearly suffer emensely if either was on my risk. Bravo my friend Mitch

Hi Mitch, ha ha, suffering is great...

 
 By: GLau : March 18th, 2018-11:46
pleasure for you then ! Cheers, Gordon

Neither are particularly fierce LOL!

 
 By: alwoo888 : March 18th, 2018-18:41
However, I like the PP because its comical look gives it a somewhat appealing personality and sense of humor. Maybe because I know the picture's provenance, is the painter's style. Regardless, they're both beautiful pieces. Congrats! p.s. were you looking... 

I like the Patek better than the Chopard.

 
 By: geross : March 19th, 2018-06:45
Its a clearer dial , based on your pictures Gordon. Glad your enjoying your collection. Best wishes! Geross.

Both are exquisite...

 
 By: patrick_y : March 19th, 2018-15:39
I can't tell which one I like more... I like the brightness of the Chopard more. But I like the Patek Philippe one a lot too because I've met the artist Anita Porchet. Both are just so exquisite!