Audemars Piguet

Audemars Piguet 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak - Pink Gold

An On-the-Wrist Review

 

By Ping Tsai

  

 

When one thinks of iconic watches that are still on the market today, a short list of candidates comes to mind. These are watches that have been well sought after throughout their histories. They’ve acquired their own identities and often carry the signature image of the brand. Perhaps one of the most iconic watches to date is none other than Audemars Piguet’s Royal Oak.

 

 

The Royal Oak has long since piqued my watch interests from the days when I watched stage-side in admiration as Jumbos were talked about and Alinghis were acquired. I saw T3s being fought over and Barrichellos introduced, all the while knowing that the spotlight wasn’t on me (being of the opposite sex) when it came to the focus of these watches. Sure there were some ladies versions but those seemed more like an afterthought and there simply isn’t much available when it comes to mechanical Royal Oaks in smaller sizes. I’m talking about the interesting ones that is. Yet I still welcome my first AP Royal Oak assignment. It will however, have to be an “up close and personal” review as opposed to an “on the wrist” review. Even with the new smaller 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak, my small wrist could not do it justice. Having the chance to review an AP Royal Oak almost seems like a right of passage for well, people who review watches and finally the opportunity is now mine. 

 

The History  

The Royal Oak was first introduced to the watch public in 1972 by Audemars Piguet, a manufacture originating from Le Brassus that has all the makings of one of the top watch companies in the industry – a rich history, the most talented watchmakers and designers, great marketing and Swiss made tradition. Established in 1875, AP has come to be known as one of the “big three” Swiss watchmakers along with Patek Philippe and Vacheron Constantin. 

 

The brand’s release of the Royal Oak in the 70’s, is thought to be revolutionary for its time, not only in design but price and material as well. Designed by the famous watchmaker Gerald Genta, the first Royal Oak was made of stainless steel and carried a price tag of about 3200 CHF. Even luxury watches in gold were less expensive at the time. In 1972 it was unheard of for a luxury sports watch, a stainless steel one for that matter, to be so highly priced. However it appears that this was precisely AP’s intention serving to create the exclusivity and intrigue behind the piece. The angular case and octagonal bezel were also atypical design features for a sports watch at the time but they gave the Royal Oak a unique identity that added to its allure. The Royal Oak was a bold move for the historical brand but one that paid off in the long run, saving the company from financial crisis and launching it into the world power watchmaking giant that it has become today.

  

37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak

The Royal Oak is Audemars Piguet’s signature watch. As many people may already be aware, there are several variations of the Royal Oak; so many in fact that for a non-AP watch expert such as myself it was enough to make ones head spin. Needless to say, a bit of research was required to sort them all out. The specific watch that I have chosen for this review is one of the new 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oaks in 18 carat pink gold with a brown crocodile strap, date and central second hand – Reference 15450. To gain a better understanding of the Royal Oak in its totality it was important for me to find out where this watch placed in reference to the other models and the significance of its movement, Calibre 3120. I’ll attempt to provide a summary in brief. 

 

The most coveted Royal Oaks for collectors are the “A series”. These were the original “Jumbos” that were part of the first 2000 piece series that were made back in the early 1970s. They contained an ultra thin self winding base Jaeger LeCoultre movement. AP later released B and C series. The current version of the original Royal Oak is the 39mm “Jumbo” Reference 15202 which is ultra-thin and lacks a second hand. The movement is AP’s Calibre 2121 which has the same base JLC Calibre 920. The 15202 has a higher price point and is a regular production piece but AP keeps the production low to preserve its desirability as a collectible. 

 

 

Royal Oak Jumbo 15202

 

AP also has the 39mm 15300 which is the same size as the Jumbo but slightly thicker, has a second hand and is less expensive. Just this year at SIHH, the brand discontinued production of the 15300 and replaced the 39mm with the 41mm 15400 and the 37mm 15450. All three models have a second hand and contain AP’s in-house movement Calibre 3120.

 

Excited that AP had introduced a smaller sized “unisex" Royal Oak, I was curious to see how the fit would be and how the sized down version would look compared to its larger predecessor. It was a chance to experience an icon that has just been made more accessible and relevant to a woman while still enjoying all the intricacies of a legendary watch in its purest form. I was also amazed by AP’s ability to put one movement into three different sized cases. It’s watchmaking efficiency at its height and deserves a closer examination into the design and workmanship of what has been created. Let us take a closer look at the 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak in all its greatness and elegance.

 

Case and Dial

The Royal Oak was named after three historical warships in the British Royal Navy that date from the early 19^th century. The naval inspiration evident in the name can also be seen in the shape of the case and bezel which is indicative of a porthole on a ship. The shape of the Royal Oak is distinctive, sporty and elegant with its octagonal appearance and hexagon shaped screws that circle the bezel. I don’t know of another watch that is more easily recognizable on someone’s wrist than the Royal Oak. It is one of those watches that with a single glance, someone can instantly tell that the watch is a Royal Oak. The signature lugs which provide smooth integration from the case to the strap instantly gives away the watch’s identity as well. 

 

 

The pink gold version raises the watch’s sporty character to a whole new level of elegance and opulence. AP’s pink gold is simply beautiful with the perfect balance of warmth and richness. Its appearance varies depending on the type of light that surrounds it and the angle at which it hits the surface, illuminating all the edges and corners. The variations lend to the watch’s dynamic character.

 

Varied finishes also contribute to this dynamic play on light as the treatment alters between brushed and polished finishing. The polished outer and inner edges of the bezel and other edges not only illustrate this but also give the entire watch a heightened luxurious upscale look and feel. I am told that a lot of AP watches including Royal Oak Offshores do not have this polished inner bezel. The ends of the hour markers are reflected in the mirrored surface and extending their appearance on the dial. 

 

 

 

The case is constructed as a solid piece to ensure better water resistance, a “state-of-the-art engineered strongbox case”. The watch also has glare-proof sapphire crystal and caseback and a screw-down crown with a hexagonal profile, further adding to the sporty design. The case and all its details achieve the ideal balance between strength and prominence along with elegance and luxury.

 

“Grande Tapisserie”

The dial is silver and has pink gold applied hour-markers and Royal Oak hands with luminescent coating. The most striking aspect of the watch and my favorite by far is the signature design motif on the dial which AP calls “Grande Tapisserie”. The textured treatment has a metallic finish and checkered pattern that catches the light beautifully, creating angles of lighted and shadowed areas that move and change as I tilt the watch and roll my wrist around. The “Grande Tapisserie” pattern gives the dial a dynamic and 3-dimensional geometric feel while the silver finishing makes it more upscale and elegant. 

 

 

 

 

 

The Grande Tapisserie dials were made by dial manufacturer, Stern Creations in the past but are now made in house at the AP manufacture facilities. The process that is used to make them is not as high-tech as one might think. It actually involves a centuries old technique that dates back to the early 1600s using a pantograph like machine. The pantograph is a “mechanical linkage” system that uses parallelograms to connect a tracing element and the chisel. As the tracing element is guided across the “tapisserie” pattern on one end, the burin engraves that pattern into the dial on the other end thus duplicating the pattern. Employing ancient techniques in creating such a modern watch definitely gives it a specialized hand crafted character. 

 

Machine for producing Tapisserie dials

I do have to say that I am not a big fan of the word “AUTOMATIC” printed in caps at 6 o’clock. Perhaps it was needed to balance the AP logo and name at 12 o’clock. I know that it keeps with tradition and that is why no one questions it. Having the simple “AP” initials at 6 o’clock in the Jumbo provides a cleaner look in my opinion.

 

Movement

The 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak is equipped with Calibre 3120, AP’s excellent in-house movement which is also used in the 39mm and 41mm Royal Oaks as well. It has hour, minute, center second and date functions. Below are some quick specifications of the movement.

 

Movement Specifications

• Functions:  hours, minutes, center seconds, date
• Movement thickness with module:  4.26 mm
• Total diameter:  26.6 mm
• Type of balance:  With Variable inertia blocks
• Frequency of balance wheel:  3,00 Hz(=21'600 alternances/hour)
• Type of balance-spring stud-holder:  Screwed mobile stud
• Balance-spring type:  Flat
• Direction of automatic winding:  Bidirectional
• Type of oscillating weight:  Monobloc in 22-carat gold
• Number of jewels:  40
• Power reserve:  60 h
• Number of parts:  280

Specificities 

• Stop balance when setting time
• Oscillating weight with ceramic ball bearings
• Bevels of the bridges are diamond graved
• Inverted snailing on bridges
• Date / Date in Dial aperture

 

When looking at the 3120 the first thing that catches my eye is the beautifully engraved rotor, which is completely made of 22K gold. The decorations on either side of the centered AP logo are the Audemars and Piguet family crests in relief. What is interesting about this rotor is its shape and angle of arch which appears to be smaller than most rotors. The rotors of most movements have arches that are closer to 180 degrees. The 3120 has a smaller arch likely to compensate for the solid gold construction which is heavier. The edges of the rotor have a gentle curve that offsets its substantial visual weight. It has massive presence but is well balanced and proportioned in accordance with its size and design.

 

 

The design of the rest of the movement echoes this same mastery in balance and proportion. With a diameter of 26.6mm, AP has managed to fit a significant amount of material within a small volume of space. The components of the primary structure, such as the bridges and plates, all appear to be made of solid blocks of steel instead of thin sheets.

 

The movement also has a larger balance and barrel for its size, a feature that improves the watch’s performance. Peeping out from behind the balance wheel and bridge one can see the perlage finishing on the base plate. There isn’t a tremendous amount going on in terms of finishing and decoration. The beauty in the movement lies in its balance and exquisite proportions. You can read more about the 3120 in depth in an excellent movement breakdown review here.

 

Strap and Fit

The 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak in rose gold comes with a brown, hand-stitched "large square scale" crocodile strap with 18-carat pink gold AP folding clasp. The Royal Oak (and Offshore) isn’t an easy watch for people with small wrists to wear. Men with smaller wrists will now have the option of a smaller sized Royal Oak that may fit them better. Women with larger wrists will have the option of a larger “men’s” style watch in the 37mm Royal Oak.

 

 

 

I found the watch to wear much larger than its size. 37mm felt more like 41mm or 42mm to me because of the lugs and extended top and bottom of the case. When you wear an AP Royal Oak, you are wearing a lot of case so anyone who is not used to this might find the watch slightly uncomfortable if it doesn’t fit the right way. For the most part, Royal Oaks are extremely comfortable to wear due to the integrated lug construction which allows a smoother transition from the case to the strap. 

 

 

 

Final Thoughts    

The AP Royal Oak reflects true sporting refinement in a watch. The 37mm Selfwinding Royal Oak in rose gold is the ultimate statement of this; driving the integration between sport and luxury to unimaginable heights. The watch is considered a sports watch but with the rose gold, you don’t feel like you are wearing a sports watch at all. One might even say that the rose gold version is a bit too dressy for everyday wear. Perhaps a businessman who lives in suits can pull it off without question. Regardless, an AP Royal Oak is desirable in any occasion.

 

The 37mm Royal Oak is considered a unisex watch and has the benefit of appealing to men with smaller wrists who aren’t able to wear the larger Royal Oaks as well as women who want something larger than the designated ladies line of AP watches. 

 

 

There has been criticism toward AP’s discontinuation of the 39mm Royal Oak and replacing it with the 41mm and 37mm ones. It forces people who want the 39mm size to buy the Jumbo which is more expensive or size up to the 41mm which may not be the ideal size. I think it’s ingenious marketing on AP’s part. They’ve made an attempt to answer to the needs of several groups in order to capture a larger portion of clientele. Perhaps AP wanted to size up the Royal Oak due to the trend towards larger watches. It’s nice to see that they didn’t neglect the individuals who prefer the smaller size by releasing the 37mm as well.

 

The 37mm Royal Oak 15450 retails for $16,300 in stainless steel and $31,000 in pink gold.

 

This message has been edited by pingtsai on 2012-12-04 21:11:23 This message has been edited by AnthonyTsai on 2012-12-17 19:11:08

... may be good even for more small wrist
You made me want a Royal Oak someday even more.

Thanks.  Great review.

Ken

....with the wear with Royal Oaks. But that's ok. I'm sure you would do great with one. Thanks Ken! This message has been edited by pingtsai on 2012-12-04 21:58:00

It's SOOOOOOOOO beautiful and so photogenic.  I loved taking pics of my ex-Montoya rose gold and had a blast taking these Royal Oak rose gold. 

Anyways, thanks for the great review Ping.  I really like the polished inner bezel because it's not something I'm used to from the Offshores I've owned before.  It really gives the watch an extra umpf and "bang", adding to the already luxurious aura.  With all the polished and brushed finish accents, this Royal Oak has a very tasteful bling, yet refined at the same time.

Cheers,
Anthony

No message body

No message body

Can you tell me your wristsize, as a point of reference, so that I know how it fits?

No message body

Thanks for reviewing the history of the Royal Oak.  I agree it is a great release for AP to have this 37mm Royal Oak.

IMO the criticism of the discontinuation of the 15300 is not so much that it forces a potential buyer up in price on the jumbo or in size on the 15400, but more simply that the 15300 was a beloved rendition of the Royal Oak.  The 39mm case looked larger than its actual size and was a joy to wear.  I prefer its dial with the AP marker at 12 to the newer dial used on the 41mm version.  It also debuted the 3120 movement now so widely employed by the brand on current models.

But these new dials have united the Royal Oak line with the double stick marker at 12.  Certainly that trait offers advantages to the branding.  The revised 15202 remains my choice as my next Royal Oak, but this 37mm version is quite right to my eyes.

...for your comments and explanation. Now I understand better  

it's the perfect size, especially with the 3120 movement.

of a beautiful watch, if my wife had a bigger wrist this AP would definitely be on my cards as a bithday present in rose gold of course, sport/chic/elegant.

Kind regards, Francois

Sadly I am in the same boat as your wife. But how nice that you would consider it for her, lucky woman

No message body

Thank you for sharing!

Thanks for the reading and the fantastic pics, you've captured all its beauty. For me, this is the most beautiful and balanced Royal Oak from the current collection. Love it.

The 15400 is a mess, specially the white dial version, IMHO.

 

Thanks for sharing.

 

 

Vte

 

 

 

...that this Royal Oak is one of the nicest ones. It has beautiful proportions. I have not seen the 15400 in person so I can't comment but just out of curiosity, what do you not like about it?

The lack of balance. I guess AP has done it because of the market demands, but from what I see it's similar to what happened with the Rolex Explorer I in 39 mm.  The 36 mm is, to me, one of the most balanced watches in the world in terms of proportions, and with the changes they did in the 39, they have lost the balance.

 

In the 15400, the dial looks too big and the bezel too small, the width of the bezel and the case don't match, so it hurts when I look at it. Have shared opinions with many people (some of them from the watch industry, even inside AP), and most of them agreed. Of course there are some very pleased with the new size.

 

This is just my personal opinion, sorry I can not say that I like it.  Nothing like the "original", the 15202.

 

 

Cheers.

 

 

 

Vte

I would say that this case size is perfect for the 3120...

The watch is gorgeous on your wrist.

Thanks!

Fx

LOL...that is actually a shot of Anthony's wrist. I thought it looked better on a man's wrist. The lugs stuck out too much on my wrist. 

when its so well done, both writing and imaging!

For your kind words and comments. I enjoyed learning about the history of AP and the Royal Oak and writing this review a great deal. Glad that you enjoyed it. Thanks again! 

The history of the AP Royal Oak is truly incredible; the original first Sports Watch from the Swiss Big Three.  Always loved the Royal Oak, the combination of a restrained amount of polished surfaces and large amount of brushed surfaces makes this watch so classically elegant, so 1970s, that when i think of the design era of the 1970s I think of this watch (1920s, Art Deco; 50s/60s Bauhaus, etc.).  I think this watch to me represents the icon of 1970s design.  And it's a great combination of classic modern styling with the traditional but modern square guilloche.  Didn't know the dials were originally made by Stern Creations, good to know!  

....for your great comments as always. What an excellent idea to try it with a white strap! Definitely would make the watch more feminine. Now if only it would fit me better, lol. Thanks again!

Stunning pictures. Thank you!

to come to an end. I like the size differentiation in the cases, but then you cannot be everything to all people!

Thanks - fab photos too!

Andrew H

No message body

Black Dial 37mm only comes with the gold case, according to the AP's site.