I liked this version the best - so I got one :)

Nov 01, 2017,02:27 AM
 

First off Amanico, thank you for your indepth reports in the past on these trio of watches. They were very helpful in helping me make my decision!


I just wanted to give my input on my decision for this version. FYI, I owned the "original" current version in the past. Loved that piece as well but it was a bit dressy for my lifestyle. I thought this 'sector' version was very fitting for me and my frequest business travels. 

The points that drew me to this watch (with some points that may not be exclusive to the geographic version)
- the thinner mutli-beveled bezel of the three (which was also one of the details that drew me to the original version before
- cleaner dial with the lack of date and power reserve that adds a symmetrical dial (albeit the small day/night indicator exists but IMO adds a subtle and pleasant nuace to the dial)
- the newer gold rotor (such a beautiful case back)
- skeleton hands - know this is a bit controversial but I felt that it was actually a logical design by JLC as the second timezone at 6 would be better visible through the hands
- the perfect 39mm size with a bit of thickness (11.77mm) to give a subtle heft to the watch
- 50m water resistance vs 30m you find in other similar pieces offered by other brands (IWC for one)
- the multi-level subdial at the 6...I really have a soft spot for that. I love that it also has the guilloche finishing 
- the blue details (the city indicators, the 5 minute hashes, the hands) give this watch, as well as the other sector dial models, character and a bit of modernity without overdoing it

One of the things I didn't like (and this is a personal preference of course) was the tang buckle. I quickly added the 4th generation deployant buckle + an OEM JLC matte black strap and I'm pleasantly happy with the outcome!

Here are some pics from my instagram account (@grnbeanwatch)


This picture really captures the mutli-levels of the subdial at 6

gone but not forgotten

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Jaeger Lecoultre Master Geographique Sector Dial 2017.

 
 By: amanico : October 9th, 2017-06:37
I already posted a review on that watch, and some fresh pictures of the Master Control Date and the Master Chronograph with their respective sector dials. I had to post some better pictures of the Master Géographique, which, in this configuration, has a s...  

A pure gem, in each of its iterations.

 
 By: TheMadDruid : October 9th, 2017-06:45
You could have posted this one for this past week's WS. I would have voted it the winner, preventing both Damjan and Joe from achieving their nefarious plans.

their plans will be foiled in any case!

 
 By: cazalea : October 9th, 2017-07:34
anonymous judge

I like the chrono version better

 
 By: Gelato Monster : October 9th, 2017-06:53
.

Agreed Nicholas.

 
 By: kev09 : October 9th, 2017-11:36
Curious how the choice of hands can affect ones feelings about a watch for better or worse. Regards Kev.

Syringe shaped hands are some of my favorite...

 
 By: Brandon Skinner : October 9th, 2017-17:22
but the same hands filled with lume would have been preferred.

Thanks, Georges. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : October 9th, 2017-08:56

Better legibility but less personality than old models

 
 By: Karlisnet : October 9th, 2017-08:12
Hands are also quite specific. Not my cup of coffee. ...  

Although I own & prefer the "classical" Geographic ( from 2004) I like this one, with the pretty clean sector dial & the cool blue cities..

 
 By: hs111 : October 9th, 2017-13:41
.. I'm still a bit irritated by these hands. Guess I would go for the Chrono version.. Best, hs

What about chrono

 
 By: Gelato Monster : October 10th, 2017-04:44
in Black instead of Blue?

I don't like this iteration...

 
 By: Brandon Skinner : October 9th, 2017-17:18
I LOVE THIS ITERATION!!!

I like this version best

 
 By: Tim_M : October 9th, 2017-17:32
This model is the one for me. I rarely use chronographs, I often travel, and the base sector dial Master Control enchants me less than the standard black dial version. This Geographic is a very useful complication for travelers and families of travelers a... 

I liked this version the best - so I got one :)

 
 By: grnbean : November 1st, 2017-02:27
First off Amanico, thank you for your indepth reports in the past on these trio of watches. They were very helpful in helping me make my decision! I just wanted to give my input on my decision for this version. FYI, I owned the "original" current version ...  

Thank you so much for your very interesting input! Your point on skeleton hands for the Geographique is spot on.

 
 By: amanico : November 1st, 2017-02:44
This is the only watch among the three which can justify the choice of pointed skeleton hands. Bravo and enjoy! Best, Nicolas

Thank you Nicolas!

 
 By: grnbean : November 1st, 2017-03:39
Here's one more picture to show the skeleton hands in 'action' ...