C, B, D, A

Jun 03, 2009,05:51 AM
 

Although my mother always told me, " if you don't have anything nice to say, then come sit over here by me...." Oh, wait, wrong bit of advice.

The EOT DR is interesting for its set of complications and its finish, especially the indication of the number of days in the current month at 2 o'clock, so that is why I rank it first.  But if EOT is what you want, I much prefer the stunningly simple and beautiful EOT that GP launched this year.

The JLC is lovely, but there is a LONG list of JLC's I would select  before this one (and you already have the one at the top of the list with the MMR), including other tourbillons.  This new line by JLC is beautiful, but it is not the usual interesting stuff I expect from JLC. 

The UN Sonata -- what can I say?  I love the innovations of UN, but their designs often just go overboard for my taste, and the Sonata is a prime example of this, especially in the colored gold.  I love the concept of the Sonata, and always have, but I just cannot imagine wearing it on a regular basis.  The dial, the hands, the case shape, etc. are all too much for me. If I were collecting alarms, I would have to have this one, but otherwise, no

DR is generally not my cup of tea, so A is by far the lowest in the ranking.

All that said, all four are amazing watches, as you no doubt know.  I think, however, that you have much more interesting and beautiful pieces in your already outrageous collection.

Best,

respo

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Give me your thoughts . . .

 
 By: Craig LA : June 2nd, 2009-12:43
I would appreciate your ranking the following four watches according to which you prefer the most. Thereafter, I welcome your thoughts/opinions regarding each watch. A. Daniel Roth Tourbillon with Retrograde Date B. JLC Tourbillon Perpetual Calendar C. Da...  

C-D-A-B

 
 By: donizetti : June 2nd, 2009-12:56
Except for the Sonata I have not seen or handled any of these but for what it is worth, I think EOT is a poetic complication, the moonphase looks cool, and the dial layout is nice on C. The Sonata is awesome. I do not care for the dial on that particular ... 

DBCA.

 
 By: G99 : June 2nd, 2009-13:29
the sonata is a beautiful watch, the equation of time is a lovely looking perpetual as is the JLC with the other Daniel Roth coming a very close 4th. Graham

To be honest with you...

 
 By: foversta : June 2nd, 2009-14:16
My fav one is A. I love its simplicity, the shape of the case, the dial. A beauty from DR. Fr.Xavier

A for me

 
 By: mrsnak : June 2nd, 2009-15:58
Classic elegance.

Me too , A

 
 By: LVT : June 3rd, 2009-01:52
I agree with Foversta ,my choice is A , timeless design , orinality of DR . Also, I suggest Speake-Marin tourbillon vintage , I took one.

A-B-D-C

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : June 2nd, 2009-15:14
The most beautiful looking of the 4 is the Daniel Roth tourbillon IMO. Extremely balanced an visually pleasing watch. The JLC Tourbillon Perpetual Calendar is my 2nd choice, but knowing that you already have a MMR, I'd venture into another brand before ge... 

DABC

 
 By: Tim Jackson : June 2nd, 2009-15:39
Love the UN concept, practical & unique complications. Elegant Roth Tourbillon, great looking watch. JLC, wonderful complicated watch however, aesthetically doesn't work for me, it just seems it is missing something style wise. Roth Perp EOT, again co... 

B.....

 
 By: MiniCooper : June 2nd, 2009-16:33
B, D ,A & C for me Cheers ps make sure you like the colour of the sonata, it is rose gold but it does look and shine like a yellow gold

A D B C

 
 By: rnaden : June 2nd, 2009-20:32
A - I like clean dials. Not a big fan of a cluttered dial with functions I don't use much D - the technology and mechanical wizardry B - nice timeless look C - a little too cluttered to my liking

BADC. [nt]

 
 By: matrix : June 2nd, 2009-21:22
No message body

DCBA without a doubt.

 
 By: Mitch K : June 2nd, 2009-23:08
By far and away, the Sonata is the most unique, useful and creative of the bunch. I am prejudice towards the JLC over the Roth's, cleaner and again more useful and easier to handle on the eyes. Mitch

DCBA for me

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : June 3rd, 2009-00:37
no particular reason all 4 are great pieces just my personal preference best Damian

My choice is CBAD

 
 By: Topcat30093 : June 3rd, 2009-00:54
I love the complications of C & B and like the beauty of A The only reason that I placed D as fourth, is that I have never seen one, so I have no experience of them.

C-D-A-B for me! [nt]

 
 By: DRMW : June 3rd, 2009-01:02
No message body

C-B-D-A (nt)

 
 By: happyguy1688 : June 3rd, 2009-01:11
nt

My suggestion is ...

 
 By: cen@jkt : June 3rd, 2009-01:40
to stop looking at SJX photos. They are bad for our financial stability . But if you insist: A-C-D-B. This JLC just doesn't seem to be in the same class as the comparisons, don't like sonata's hands, don't understand equation of time, and actually don't r... 

For myself...

 
 By: dxboon : June 3rd, 2009-01:48
...the only watch from this list that I'd throw my money behind is D. I think the Sonata is a fantastic watch with a unique design. If made to rank the selections I'd go with D-A-B-C. Cheers, Daos

C, B, D, A

 
 By: respo : June 3rd, 2009-05:51
Although my mother always told me, " if you don't have anything nice to say, then come sit over here by me...." Oh, wait, wrong bit of advice. The EOT DR is interesting for its set of complications and its finish, especially the indication of the number o... 

Tough Choice

 
 By: VPREGULATOR : June 3rd, 2009-06:14
DCBA for me.

C-B-D-A because....

 
 By: MTF : June 3rd, 2009-08:26
Aesthetic....Technique.....Pratique. Daniel Roth EOT Lunar Phase Tourbillon has them all .....most 1st choice votes and quite a few 2nd choice votes. JLC Perpetual Tourbillon Perpetual. Overall 2nd place by bland technical prowess that irritates the fewes... 

D - B - A - C

 
 By: Emmanuel H : June 3rd, 2009-14:07
An explanation about A & C in the two last positions : do not believe that I don't like Daniel Roth but if I had to buy one, it would rather be this one : Emmanuel...  

C-B-D-A

 
 By: mikethw : June 3rd, 2009-22:02
Personally I like perpetual calendars.....thats why

CABD NT

 
 By: Dje : June 4th, 2009-12:35
NT