I think it would have looked better if it retained more of the panoreserve which manages to be both elegant and, well, reserved. If this looked just like a standard PR with the date gone and the dual swan necks sitting in it s place I believe I might be tempted. I would still have to past the XL part which is a trend I have never liked. I often wonder if 20 years from now the pieces on sale today will be considered to be something akin to bell bottoms and the source of some mirth? Overall, I like the idea but they didn't ring my own personal bell.