This is one instance where I'd choose the Lange over the Journe...

This is very subjective, but since you've asked... the Lange 1 MP is a beautiful version of the iconic L1 and it works very well. I don't particularly like the Octa Lune, while I'm a big fan of Journes. I just don't think this permutation of the classic Journe RDM is as successful, but I'm sure many others would disagree with me.

💰437 Marketplace Listings for A. Lange and Söhne›

Octa Lune or Lange 1 Moonphase (both platinum)

By: eryck.su : October 28th, 2007-18:31

Yes, they are different in many ways but have similar functions. If you were to buy only one, which would it be?

...

L1 MP is simply fantastic

By: The Goal is Soul : October 29th, 2007-04:43

Octa Lune for me

By: Sumate : October 29th, 2007-05:18

Cheers...

I think that's the nicest version. Unfortunately, not available anymore. [nt]

By: SRG : October 29th, 2007-08:08

No message body

Octa Lune and Lange 1 MP

By: eryck.su : October 29th, 2007-08:45

Thanks everyone for your opinions. Now, I am really not sure but will try to see both again to see which one speaks to me. Surprisingly most votes have gone to the Lange. Surprising because this is an FPJ forum! I've also posted on the Lange forum and sim...

F.P. Journe