I'm equally weak

Nov 29, 2006,10:10 AM
 

so I have both as well. The "classic" yellow gold/silver Lange 1 and the red gold/silver CS.

They're oil and water but, last time I checked, most of us need both oil and water.



Interestingly, I was quite sure I'd get the platinum CS, but when I saw the red gold one, I was done for.

Date functions are useful, but in this day and age of the ubiquitous cell phone and blackberry, do we really need to make that a go/no-go for our time pieces?

My slant in watch choices is face design and the overall look and feel. Movements are important but not the first thing. To me, each of these watches expresses something essential about timepiece design. The Lange 1 is cooly modern, intellectual, Bauhaus, Mies van de Rohe. The CS is, on the other hand, extravagantly post-modern, playful, neoclassic, Frank Gehry (OK, not quite Frank Gehry, that would be Vianney, but maybe Michael Graves?). Both offer the highest degree of mechanical craftsmanship and exquisite, jewel-like construction.

So start saving. You know you can't eat just one.


More posts: Lange 1

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Chronometre Souverain vs. Lange 1

 
 By: Samuel Lock : November 16th, 2006-05:05
I'm considering a three hand manual winding watch. Sadly, the Roger Smith Series 2 is out of my budget so I've narrowed my choices down to these two watches. I know it's like comparing apples to oranges but I like to hear what you have to say regarding th... 

Tough Choice

 
 By: Chucky1103 : November 17th, 2006-12:12
Sam, tough choice. I will suggest what others have suggested me. Choose which one speaks the loudest to you. try both if you can and see how they look like on your wrist. Both watches are quality products. Another one that you might want to consider is th... 

Which color combination?

 
 By: bs22fly : November 17th, 2006-01:01
The Lange 1 will feel like hit has more substance. It's a heavier piece with crisp finishing. The dial design with big date is always impressive to look at. The CS on the other hand is equally impressive but has a completely different feel. In addition to... 

My choices are...

 
 By: Samuel Lock : November 17th, 2006-05:05
Lange 1 in white gold with guilloche MOP dial since it has a striking resemblance to the Lange 1A. As for the Chronometre Souverain, I like it in platinum. My dealer quoted me the price for the platinum CS which is a mere $1000 more than the white gold La... 

Re: My choices are...

 
 By: Huitieme : November 17th, 2006-08:08

Too weak to decide between these two...

 
 By: glickman : November 17th, 2006-09:09
I feel drawn to both watches, and I agree with the others' comments completely. So I own a "Stealth" Lange 1, which has solid, smooth and modern presence, and a CS in platinum, which feels like much more of a classic. I will say that while I appreciate bo...  

Roger, you are...

 
 By: Samuel Lock : November 17th, 2006-10:22

I'm equally weak

 
 By: PS : November 29th, 2006-10:10

If you must have SHEER quality, then the Lange is above it.

 
 By: bernard cheong : November 17th, 2006-04:16
I am more than familiar with both watches, and the Lange has an edge over the FP in both visually obvious quality in finish, and tactile quality...feel the wind of the crown, and also as you pull and push the crown in and out. Also, if you run your finger... 

Actually...

 
 By: Samuel Lock : November 17th, 2006-09:21
I've been quietly awaiting your perceptive response. You never fail to deliver when most needed! Thank you for your feedback...

LOL! Pull up your pants folks, because it's too late to save the shoes

 
 By: felipe : November 18th, 2006-06:06
>> Also, if you run your fingers around each watch, you can feel the difference in Lange's better finish. According to this scientific study, blind people have better tactile spacial resolution than non-blind people, and even that is only about 0.8 mm wit... 

Perhaps if we are going to discuss this on a scientific level...

 
 By: MKTing : November 20th, 2006-02:14
then we'll need to distinguish between different "types of touching". Active touch is when a subject's finger moves over sa tationary surface which I believe is the motion that is being described. The limit of discrimination with touch is about 0.8mm. The... 

You guys are crazy :P (nt)

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : November 20th, 2006-04:16
. .

:D (nt)

 
 By: felipe : November 20th, 2006-04:16

An excellent point, but...

 
 By: felipe : November 20th, 2006-04:16
Hi Mike, I thought I might get such a response. I have to admit that what you have highlighted is true in certain contexts, but you have to remember that as alluded to in ISO 13091 (click here) , when identifying or manipulating curved objects such as a w... 

well said

 
 By: ei8htohms : November 20th, 2006-05:17

Actually that is quite a nice synopsis Felipe...

 
 By: MKTing : November 20th, 2006-05:17
Sorry as this diverges offtopic but it was a research project of mine so hence the interest. You are right that the limit of discrimination that I quoted was for active touch along a linear surface not along a curved plane. The edge sensitivity of mechano... 

:-) My research project was in regards to building a bionic arm.

 
 By: MKTing : November 20th, 2006-06:18
with a bionic finger attached ! Way too complex of a project and it will definitely cost more than 6 million dollars to develop. Cheers Felipe! Mike

Valid point and also...this "tactile" quality is subjective but highly valued among design

 
 By: bernard cheong : November 21st, 2006-05:05
I had this discussion with car designers, watch designers, and leather goods guys...it is very subjective...this feeling of quality. 9 out of 10 it is usually not an illusion, but the use of texture, weight, warmth (or the lack of it), and the relative ch... 

Entire departments??????

 
 By: BDLJ : November 14th, 2008-19:32

Different watches

 
 By: tahoeblue : November 17th, 2006-07:19

It's wasn't difficult for me...

 
 By: DennisB : November 17th, 2006-08:20
...